29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Willimantic

“Loves it“

“Excellent service, fresh and delicious food, definitely the best. I give it a 1000 ah papas pizza 🍕“

“I came to CT for a visit recently to see the old home town of Lebanon CT. My girlfriend and I used visit Mama's Pizza regularly back about 35 years ago when we were in our late teens. I just love coming to a restaurant that has stood the test and has not changed it's values or it's awesome flavorful menu. The staff very pleasant and always ready to help at anytime. Thank you all for helping to relive a part of our lives that is very near and dear to both our hearts.“

“Excellent! Delivery was fast, all items hot and well prepared!“

“We have been coming to this pizza joint for five years. We love it. Although they recently started charging for dipping sauce alongside wings. A dollar for 2 ounces. 🤔“

“The service is wonderful and the food is 💯 great a 10+... the owners are great and humble people...my favorite pizza spot..“

“Love this place. Great food. Great prices. Very friendly. Love the pasta and calzone is SO GOOD!“

“Very friendly atmosphere!! My favorite place to go with my family and friends ♥️“

“Had the Red Potato Pizza, as well as the Taco Pizza. All I can say is WOW! Red Potato came highly recommended by a UConn alum; It did not disappoint. HUGE pizza for the $$. Fantastic cold too! Thanks for the experience.“

“The best pizza for the soul.“

“The best pizza for the soul.“

“We don’t eat anywhere else! The food never disappoints and is honestly delicious. Everyone in there is so friendly and really wants to please.“

“Great pizza“

“I come by this place ATLEAST twice a week and my go to is always the mamas fajitas(depending on my mood I’ll go with seafood or steak) and it never fails me. My father and I have made it basically a weekly routine to have breakfast here every Wednesday and have been coming here for yearsss! Al is such a stand up dude and always treats us like family! If you are looking for a great breakfast or dinner and wanna feel like you’re at home? Go to Emely’s!“

“A local and area gem that's not to be overlooked!

Six years later, absolutely thrilled to see how welcoming and phenomenal everything remains.

I did want to update my review after seeing there being a complaint about the prices of food. Seeing how *consistent* their prices are is remarkable, and above and beyond that the value is particularly noteworthy.

Altogether from the quality (and *portions*) of the food, to the amazing staff, definitely a place to come to and make a regular stop.“

“Today was my first time eating here and I'll say right now that I will be back. This place reminds me a bit of a cozy diner.

We took my fiancé's dad here for an early birthday lunch. He was craving their calamari and onion rings and he said they hit the spot today. My fiancé got one of the daily specials (rodeo burger, I think) with sweet potato fries and I got the cheeseburger club plate with onion rings.

Come here with a big appetite, the expectation of a to go box or both! Portions here are very generous! We came home with at least half our rings and fries and I had part of my club sandwich left as well. A good portion of the calamari went into a to go box as well - that will make at least another two meals for my fiance's dad.

My burger club was very good! I wasn't given a choice on the doneness of my burger, but that wasn't a problem for me. My fiancé pronounced his burger as one of the better ones he's had in a while.

This place is very busy on Sundays and they close early (about three p.m. or so.) We did have to wait a little after we were seated for service, but that service was pretty good! Our food was as we wanted it and we got the things we asked for (cocktail sauce, extra cokes, etc.) despite our waitress running herself crazy to and from all her tables.

Prices were pretty decent for what we got (my plate was about $15.95 or so) The menu had a lot of variety - breakfast items, steaks, burgers and sandwiches, and salads. There is also a cabinet full of a variety of cakes at the front of the restaurant and they looked delicious!“

“Enjoyed everything about Plum Tomato!“

“Great pizza and service every time I have ordered, also really great Buffalo wings too! Definitely worth a try if you haven’t had it yet and bonus that they deliver !!“

“We've catered for our men's college basketball team with Gansett Wraps many times over the past couple of years, and they never disappoint. The food consistently hits the spot—fresh, flavorful, and satisfying every time. The service is always top-notch, and the managers are a pleasure to work with. A special shoutout to Khal, who has been amazing at ensuring all of our accommodations are met seamlessly. Gansett Wraps has become a go-to favorite for our team, and we’re grateful for their reliability and excellence.“

“This is the store I order from on a average 3-4 times a week, my order is mostly always the same however tonight I placed a order for my kid and husband and I thought I ordered it correctly but this time I actually didn’t! I forgot to hit the bacon button so I called to have the correct order made and even though I ordered it wrong they remade it and delivered it! They didn’t have to remake it cause Im the one that ordered it wrong but Tim had it remade and had it delivered anyways!! He said Due to the fact I order from them a lot he went above and beyond what Great customer service and service like this keeps a customer returning again and again! Keep up the great work!!“

“Not sure who exactly made my pizza but it said Tony, but whoever it was saw the vision for sure!! I wanted a chicken parm pizza and got the perfect one. The cheesy bread was also incredible!!! Thank you so much, I know it can be hard sometimes to work at a busy store especially near a college campus, you guys are doing great.“

“They have a new crew working now and they are by far the friendliest, and most attentive group of staff that's ever been here. The pizzas are great, and they have great vegan pizza too!

The atmosphere is loud. That's literally the only downside.“

“I am addicted to their breakfast sandwiches. Jake, Armando, Jerry, and the whole crew are doing a great job!“

“Great food and service… o had stuffed mushrooms, calamari, shepherds pie and my friend had baked flounder and French fries. 😋 sooooo yummy“

“Ordered for third time the Bacon,potato cheese broccoli pizza it is the most fantastic pizza! Crust crispy! Try it you’ll agree!“

“I ordered a steak and cheese calzone for myself and the End Zone for my husband, both with the works. They tasted great, and the texture was soft. I can't wait to try the other items on the menu. A while back, I tried the cheese bread, and it was pretty good, too. They have a hard working team there.“

“What a little gem. This hidden treasure has the most amazing pizza in the area. The other dishes are amazing and very authentic.

All dishes we have tried have been thoughtfully made. The staff is kind. I would recommend this for good food and value.

I plan to use this restaurant for catering an event as well.“

“Came in and grabbed a seat at the bar and had such a great experience. I ordered the Caesar salad and wow — it was so good, fresh, perfectly dressed, honestly one of the best I’ve had. Shoutout to the cook Teddy — absolute legend. Amazing food, great vibe, and awesome people. Will definitely be back.“

“My family was passing through the area and we decided to stop. We were not disappointed. The gluten free pizza was excellent! The veal piccata and penne alla vodka were delicious. The chicken parm sub was cooked perfectly with a lightly toasted roll. And the chick-fil-A quesadillas were tasty with a hint of sweet. We all also took home leftovers for a good price. It was so good that if we are passing through again we will definitely stop here!!“