26 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark

“Evelyn was very pleasant and got everything we needed. Would recommend bertcci’s and our lovely server to everyone! 5 stars“

“We stop in once a week. Sometimes we eat there and sometimes we call and pick up. The atmosphere is fabulous. If we ever do have to wait for our food, it’s totally worth it. If my husband and I are together we sit and have wine while we wait. They are all very friendly! If we get take out, we always get extra so we can have leftovers, which are always delicious. We reheat the pizza in the toaster oven, it’s amazing. We also love the desserts there! It’s just a great spot and we love it! I’ve never once been disappointed with any of their service or food.“

“The gluten free pizza is delicious and safe for those with even the most gluten sensitivity! Highly recommend!“

“Going to Tony's is always a wonderful experience. The owners and staff are amazingly warm and friendly. And of course, the food is mouth watering delicious; the very best around.“

“Can't believe I've never reviewed one of my favorite restaurants.

Pizza is outstanding here, but my favorite thing is the smiley chicken sandwich. It's the greatest chicken sandwich in all of the land. The chips absolutely rule too.“

“First time trying this place and it was amazing! We had a friendly, attentive server. He checked in with us many times, refilling our drinks and chatting with us. The garlic bread, salad and Pizza was absolutely amazing!! Can’t wait to go back again.“

“It was really good thanks!“

“I give them a five star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating. I always knew this little shop was tucked in this shopping plaza but I never ever tried. Well let me just say I was missing out. I’ve now tried several different items and different pizzas and all of them have been delicious. You gotta try the BBQ beef cheesesteak (add extra meat and extra cheese) and BBQ chicken pizza. Wow 👍👍. I can tell they get slammed with takeout and delivery orders. Great staff. They’re my new go to.“

“Best pizza & customer service in town! We love it!“

“Outstanding dining experience. Delicious food & wonderful atmosphere.“

“Ordered delivery while in Elkton on business. Food was delivered quick, hot and delicious. Had the pasta, steak sandwich, and chicken rice soup....All delicious and will order again when back in town or passing through...“

“amazing pizza would return to area just for this pizza“

“Love this place go all the time get all the spaghetti dishes the staff great friendly people love it“

“my first visit I tried the chicken alfredo pizza and fell in love, it was delicious 😋 then the second visit I went for a cheese steak, I am definitely hooked to this restaurant. I would highly recommend this place to try, you will not be disappointed! Also, the staff on the phone & in person were very friendly and helpful....GREAT SERVICE👍“

“Great food and atmosphere!!“

“Enjoyed the chicken tenders which were perfectly prepared! Nice size portion with moist meat inside and a super delicious crispy coating on outside. Excellent choice. The spaghetti and meatballs is also an excellent meal and very large potion. Very tasty sauce and the meatballs are tasty and moist. Two excellent choices!“

“My very first time here. But when I tell you the pizza is good. It’s good! I got two slices of cheese and these slices are huge!! Good food for awesome value! Awesome atmosphere, and clean. Very pleasant customer service. I will be returning“

“I’ve been here. For Father’s Day. Good customer. Survice.“

“Great double cheeseburgers and fries! Friendly atmosphere and owners!!“

“Second time ordering from here, food is fresh pizza is very good, and buffalo wings were good ,excellent service great customer service.“

“We stopped in for dinner. The dining area was empty. Generally speaking, everything was pretty good. My boyfriend chose the choose-your-own pasta with chicken and Alfredo. The chicken was very chewy and fatty, making it impossible for him to eat. Everything else was fine. I had the signature cheese steak with ketchup and pickles, which was very good.“

“K es muy muy bueno“

“stoll as good as it was 20 years ago when I was eating it for study fuel!“

“I ordered a build your own stromboli with 1 ingredient wrong and was mad at myself for forgetting the ingredient and settled for what I was getting. The manager said no I'll make you a new one I want you to be happy. I couldn't believe it it. When it arrived it was amazing so I highly recommend this seasons 5 stars“

“This is probably our favorite takeout spot. The prices are so reasonable, and the food is always great. I don't think I've ever had a bad experience here, and we've ordered here for several years. That's pretty amazing when I think about it. The cashiers are always pleasant. The order is always on time, and well-packaged

Message to the owners and staff: I think you are doing everything right, and I hope you never change. ☺️“

“It's a college bar, and you get what you expect. Dirty floor and the atmosphere is clearly catered to 21 year olds. That being said, Grotto's wings are always solid and the grand slam sauce brings it home. The pizza is plain but is done so consistently you always know you can count on the taste and texture. Would definitely recommend if you want to go watch a game and enjoy some quick food.“