50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bay Harbor Islands

“Right when you think pizza is pizza - here comes Mister01 with a very delicious and unique pizza! GREAT ingredients. FANTASTIC crust! We tried & loved the Star Luca & Hawaiana pizzas. We also thoroughly enjoyed the Laura salad. Portions were huge, and we have dinner for tomorrow. Try the spicey olive oil on your pizza. The staff is the BEST! First class operation indeed. Aidan was our server - and was so polite, knowledgeable, had solid recommendations - and made the already great experience even better!! We will be regulars! Thanks!!“

“My first time was tonight… I’m going to be honest, GREAT pizza. I am a pizza snob. It was my first job as a kid and I spent 10 years doing it. Total home run! Can’t wait to come back!“

“Best Italian restaurant in Miami“

“I first had the pleasure of dining here nearly two years ago, and it instantly became one of my favorite restaurants. From the warm atmosphere to the unforgettable flavors, everything about the experience was exceptional. The plate of pasta I had on that first visit was so memorable, it’s still the background on my phone — and I’ve made multiple trips to Miami just to come back and enjoy it again. The quality has never wavered. I can’t recommend this place highly enough.“

“This was our first time eating here in Grapevine Texas location. My husband and I had a Caesar salad and a meat lovers pizza. The Caesar salad was huge and we took home half of it. The pizza is crispy and fresh out of the oven. It was a great meal. We had a friendly and knowledgeable, waitress named Kelsey. On the way out, we met the owner Luis. He was very friendly and took the time to talk about their restaurants and all the other locations they had. We will definitely be back.“

“The pizza was amazing, and the price was not to bad for Miami Beach. I highly recommend a visit here.“

“The food was very good, and you can tell it was prepared using traditional cooking methods. The flavors were authentic, everything was fresh, and the dishes were well presented. If you're looking for a place that serves quality traditional cuisine, this restaurant is definitely worth a visit.“

“Nice place. Good service.“

“Real deal Italian pizza here, fresh ingredients and you can tell they don’t cut corners. Loved the little red vintage car parked inside too, cute touch that gives the whole place character.

Cozy spot, staff were attentive and made us feel welcome. They also do pizza, making classes which sounds like a fun time for a group or even a date. Great meal, great vibe.“

“Un po' come stare a casa. La vera pizza Napoletana con l'opzione gluten free. Una menzione particolare al personale, sempre attento, cortese e professionale. Un grazie a Giovanni per avermi preparato la miglior pizza gluten free ever. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Excelente! La pizza fabulosa!“

“Mega Pizza was worth the stop! Huge, flavorful slices with crispy crust and generous toppings. Friendly staff and quick service. Great spot for a tasty, affordable bite in Miami Beach. I'll be back!
While walking to our Uber Saturday morning at 435 a.m and the line was out the building for that Mega Pizza!“

“El lugar es muy acogedor, y la comida es muy buena e innovadora.“

“I really enjoyed my dinner here! Great service & great food! Definitely a highlight during my visit to Miami.“

“Amazing food by a profession and friendly staff! Tonight’s entree is Linguine Al Gamberi! It was amazing! Thanks Piccola Team! Another great dinner!“

“I wanted to acknowledge the staff at Nicks Pizza for being generally awesome and making outstanding food. I love these huge Brooklyn type slices and the unique add’s like hot honey, stracciatella and pecorino. Nicks is a fun, casual and easy stop to and from the beach.:. Nos vemos pronto mi amigos :)“

“The quality of food is high, for that I recommend it. The reason I wouldn’t go back is that the staff just did not care we were there at all. Still waiting for them to ask how everything is… we came through last year and had a totally different experience staff was super friendly and engaged even though the place was packed. We caught them at turnover and they couldn’t care less. We talked about hitting craft as a high point for our one night in Miami before cruising… and now we won’t bother going back to Bayside.“

“Our orders were delicious and fresh. Will definitely visit again.“

“Yes, Best pizza ever!!! I am originally from NY and omg this pizza was amazing!“

“Valentina is absolutely wonderful! She is so kind, friendly, and always has a smile on her face. Sheis incredibly helpful and always happy to answer our questions and offer recommendations. Thank you so much, Valentina, for making our experience so pleasant! We truly appreciate your excellent service.“

“We had such a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and full of flavor. Every dish we ordered was excellent, and the atmosphere was warm and welcoming.

A special thank you to Chantale, who made our visit truly memorable. She was incredibly friendly, attentive, and professional, always checking in at just the right time and making sure we had everything we needed. Her genuine kindness and outstanding service made us feel so well taken care of.

We'll definitely be back and highly recommend Piola to anyone looking for a fantastic meal paired with exceptional hospitality. Thank you, Chantale, for making our evening so enjoyable!“

“awesome, fresh & delicious pizza,highly recommend“

“Antonina our server for the afternoon was amazing. Antonina is warm but professional and very intuitive. She is attentive to detail and onpoint on her recommendations in the menu. We took our boys in summer vacation and the restaurant was very comprehensive and kid friendly. Greenpoint s must in miami. High quality food and five star service“

“Mary Alexa es la mejor . Y la comida súper rica“

“Food is amazing.the spot at the citadel has the best hospitality you can find. everything is always hot, fresh just to my liking. Pizza is always a plus but the mozzarella sticks are always on point. For sure would recommend. definitely a 5 star rating.“

“Muy buena atención por parte de yaslin,y la pizza muy buena.“

“Complimeenti! Una vera pizza napoletana, degna della nostra grande tradizione.“

“Excelente lugar, la pizza estilo New York buenisima, muy buena atención, lo recomiendo“

“There delicious Italian food made fresh and there great service ! And it's family friendly“

“The quality of food is high, for that I recommend it. The reason I wouldn’t go back is that the staff just did not care we were there at all. Still waiting for them to ask how everything is… we came through last year and had a totally different experience staff was super friendly and engaged even though the place was packed. We caught them at turnover and they couldn’t care less. We talked about hitting craft as a high point for our one night in Miami before cruising… and now we won’t bother going back to Bayside.“

“Great staff, amazing food and awesome views!“

“Salsiccia and Nonna Meatball pizzas with bruschetta appetizer. Got a side of marinara as well, which is legit. Got one classic crust and tried the charcoal crust which was a first. All good and will be back. Worth a visit if you’re in Wynwood.“

“I went there Last Saturday with my mom and my two fur babies so we sat outside of course and Rebecca was Soooo super friendly and helpful that it made it our visit there extremely enjoyable. The ambiance and service are excellent. The food: Was so super tasty and flavorful. We ordered the Bruschetta (delicious), the prosciutto and mozzarella (fabulous) and a pizza (stunning). We absolutely enjoyed everything and will definitely be returning. My fur babies had an excellent time as well and they will also be returning with us. They even had some of the food and totally agree. Absolutely delicious 😋. Thank you Rebecca for everything and we will see you real soon. 😘“

“We stayed in Miami for a couple of nights and tried different places for dinner , but this one was on a whole different level. The food , Service and the staff was sooo good. Authentic and a must go.
Shot out goes to the chef for giving personalised service and making us feel so special. He is the kindest and made food personally which was very delicious.
MUST GO“

“The pizzas and pastas are really amazing.“

“Perfecto Pizza and Salads !“

“Yummy pizza, the garlic knots were my fave, and Josephina was so sweet.“

“Hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We were in Miami for vacation and popped in for dinner. Everything was amazing. The owners were present helping, our sever was fantastic as well as everything we ordered. If I’m ever back in Miami I will definitely be stopping back by!“

“This place pleasantly by far exceeded our expectations. The Philly cheese steak sandwich was scrumptious and the chicken strips and onion wrings were mouth watering as well. Even more importantly it was clean and the staff and owner were most accommodating! Thank you J. Sanders from Illinois“

“This place pleasantly by far exceeded our expectations. The Philly cheese steak sandwich was scrumptious and the chicken strips and onion wrings were mouth watering as well. Even more importantly it was clean and the staff and owner were most accommodating! Thank you J. Sanders from Illinois“

“🍝 The Kind of Place That Never Fails
I’ve been here dozens of times and would keep coming back without hesitation. It’s one of those places that’s simple, quick, fresh, and consistently good. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual lunch, dinner, or a last minute meal, it rarely disappoints.
The menu has a little bit of everything. We’ve tried the pizzas, salads, and several pasta dishes over the years, and the ingredients always taste fresh. One of my favorite things they offer is the all you can eat gnocchi on the 29th of every month. They have a wide variety of sauces to choose from, and you can keep ordering until you’re completely full. Considering the price, it’s one of the best values on the menu.
For dessert, we recently tried the profiteroles and they were excellent. The ice cream in the middle makes them even better. The tiramisu is also worth mentioning. They seem to update the recipe from time to time, but somehow it keeps getting better.
Service is usually quick, which is one of the reasons I keep coming back. There are often new team members, but the experience remains efficient and reliable.
The restaurant is fairly spacious and could work for a small celebration, but I personally think it works best for couples or groups of four to six people. It tends to fill up quickly, especially on weekends, so arriving early is never a bad idea.
Another nice touch is the TVs and projector screens throughout the restaurant. With major sporting events coming up, it’s a great option if you’re looking for somewhere to watch a game while enjoying a meal.
Overall, this is a place I continue to return to because it delivers exactly what it promises. Fresh food, reasonable prices, quick service, and a consistently good experience.“

“awesome, fresh & delicious pizza,highly recommend“

“Best pizza I have had in a long time, perfect crust“

“Best pizzas in Miami!!!❤️❤️“

“Such a cute store! Delicious and authentic pizza, they do it the moment you order. We had takeout but I couldn't help and open the pizza in my car, it smelled amazing and I wish I could've stayed at the place, it's really cute, definitely a hidden gem! ✨“

“Awesome Aperol Spritz @pizza“

“Best authentic Napoletana pizza you can find in Miami. Thought I was back home. Food is fire people. Need to try this place. Love pasta? They do not disappoint. So good. Acacia provided amazing service this last visit. She was very attentive and prompt. The entire staff is great. Many of them speak Italian and make you feel at home.“

“Great atmosphere and even better food“

“Best salad … shrimp beets avocado OMG … 10 out of 10“