50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bay Harbor Islands

“Right when you think pizza is pizza - here comes Mister01 with a very delicious and unique pizza! GREAT ingredients. FANTASTIC crust! We tried & loved the Star Luca & Hawaiana pizzas. We also thoroughly enjoyed the Laura salad. Portions were huge, and we have dinner for tomorrow. Try the spicey olive oil on your pizza. The staff is the BEST! First class operation indeed. Aidan was our server - and was so polite, knowledgeable, had solid recommendations - and made the already great experience even better!! We will be regulars! Thanks!!“

“Admittedly I did not dine in as I was staying at a hotel around the corner, but I did hear that their table service is very good. I ordered the Thai Fried Rice with Chicken - it was well prepared and very balanced in flavor. Not overly spiced, it was delicious. The right amount of Chicken and vegetables for a solid take out meal. The restaurant was busy but didn't feel overwhelming - a small spot with tables outside as well. Would definitely recommend for someone seeking familiar dishes prepared with care and thought.“

“Stopped by today on my way home loved the atmosphere, the customer service was excellent, tasty food and a great environment to bring your family. I will definitely be back. I got the chance to try a new menu item which was the portobello mushroom pizza, a delicious combination of fresh toppings and hard work. 10/10!“

“My first time was tonight… I’m going to be honest, GREAT pizza. I am a pizza snob. It was my first job as a kid and I spent 10 years doing it. Total home run! Can’t wait to come back!“

“Best Italian restaurant in Miami“

“The pizza was amazing, and the price was not to bad for Miami Beach. I highly recommend a visit here.“

“I first had the pleasure of dining here nearly two years ago, and it instantly became one of my favorite restaurants. From the warm atmosphere to the unforgettable flavors, everything about the experience was exceptional. The plate of pasta I had on that first visit was so memorable, it’s still the background on my phone — and I’ve made multiple trips to Miami just to come back and enjoy it again. The quality has never wavered. I can’t recommend this place highly enough.“

“This was our first time eating here in Grapevine Texas location. My husband and I had a Caesar salad and a meat lovers pizza. The Caesar salad was huge and we took home half of it. The pizza is crispy and fresh out of the oven. It was a great meal. We had a friendly and knowledgeable, waitress named Kelsey. On the way out, we met the owner Luis. He was very friendly and took the time to talk about their restaurants and all the other locations they had. We will definitely be back.“

“Pummarola is so good I’m going there at least twice a week to get some good Italian food. The food quality you get for the price you pay is by far the best in Miami. The atmosphere is also super nice and the employees are always smiling !“

“Nice place. Good service.“

“My sister had been talking about this pizza for MONTHS once she knew we were going to be in Miami for a few days before leaving for our cruise. And when I say she was persistent about us trying it... she was NOT letting us leave Miami without going to Mega Pizza.

Now, I’m pretty hard to impress when it comes to food. I’m a Taurus, okay? We take our food seriously! But I have to give it to her because this pizza was GOOD.

First of all, the slices are HUGE! I couldn’t even finish mine in one sitting. I ended up saving the rest and eating it cold the next day, and mannnn... tell me why it was even better cold?! That’s when you KNOW you have some good pizza.

I’ve never been to New York, so I can’t personally tell you what authentic New York-style pizza is supposed to taste like. But from what I’ve heard people say, this comes pretty close and if that’s true, I see what all the hype is about! I can honestly say this was some of the greatest pizza I’ve had.

It is a little on the pricey side, but with the size of those slices and how good it was, it was worth it to me. Definitely a great South Beach find.

And yes, my sister absolutely got her “I TOLD Y’ALL!” moment because she was right. I’d definitely come back whenever I’m in Miami!

-A Taurus Ate Here-“

“Un po' come stare a casa. La vera pizza Napoletana con l'opzione gluten free. Una menzione particolare al personale, sempre attento, cortese e professionale. Un grazie a Giovanni per avermi preparato la miglior pizza gluten free ever. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“The food was very good, and you can tell it was prepared using traditional cooking methods. The flavors were authentic, everything was fresh, and the dishes were well presented. If you're looking for a place that serves quality traditional cuisine, this restaurant is definitely worth a visit.“

“Stanzione Pizza is a great place to enjoy a unique Italian pizza experience inside Citadel Hall. The variety of pizzas and, especially, their preparation method really set this place apart.

A major plus is that they cook their pizzas in a Neapolitan-style oven, which gives the crust a delicious smoky flavor and a more authentic taste. The ingredients are fresh, everything is made to order, and the presentation is excellent.

The quality-to-price ratio is excellent, especially considering the quality of the ingredients and the care that goes into the preparation.

Even though it is located inside a food court, the atmosphere is surprisingly quiet, relaxed, and welcoming. It's a great spot for a pizza afternoon with your partner, friends, or family.

The only downside is the parking inside Citadel Hall — $10 per hour feels quite expensive. My recommendation is to look for parking outside the main area, where it can be around $3 per hour.

Overall, Stanzione Pizza is definitely worth trying if you enjoy authentic Italian pizza, fresh ingredients, and traditional preparation. 🍕🇮🇹 Highly recommended!“

“El lugar es muy acogedor, y la comida es muy buena e innovadora.“

“I really enjoyed my dinner here! Great service & great food! Definitely a highlight during my visit to Miami.“

“Amazing food by a profession and friendly staff! Tonight’s entree is Linguine Al Gamberi! It was amazing! Thanks Piccola Team! Another great dinner!“

“I wanted to acknowledge the staff at Nicks Pizza for being generally awesome and making outstanding food. I love these huge Brooklyn type slices and the unique add’s like hot honey, stracciatella and pecorino. Nicks is a fun, casual and easy stop to and from the beach.:. Nos vemos pronto mi amigos :)“

“The quality of food is high, for that I recommend it. The reason I wouldn’t go back is that the staff just did not care we were there at all. Still waiting for them to ask how everything is… we came through last year and had a totally different experience staff was super friendly and engaged even though the place was packed. We caught them at turnover and they couldn’t care less. We talked about hitting craft as a high point for our one night in Miami before cruising… and now we won’t bother going back to Bayside.“

“Our orders were delicious and fresh. Will definitely visit again.“

“Excelente! La pizza fabulosa!“

“First stop on arrival to Miami; enjoy the ambiance, excitement, and tropical style outdoor dining experience; excellent place to people-gaze and tingle your palate with well prepared savory dishes according to your dietary needs or preference. Oh, get happy or happier with superbly mixed libations!! Say hello to Valentina; she is an exceptional waiter, with a dazzling disposition, and professionalism; she and the entire staff will make your visit Ocean Drive leisure-stop more memorable, enjoyable, and entertaining!“

“We had a great experience un piola, Melissa our server was wonderful! She was very attentive, friendly, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout the meal. She really made our visit more enjoyable. Thank you for the great service!“

“This peaceful patio is an absolute hidden gem, boasting a gorgeous marina setting surrounded by greenery that makes it the ideal spot to unwind over coffee, lunch, or brunch. Everything we ordered—including the fresh, flavorful shakshuka, a glass of moscato, and a cappuccino—was delicious and beautifully presented. The service struck the right balance of friendly and attentive. Plus, the $5 cash valet parking across the street adds great convenience. We will definitely be returning!“

“Yes, Best pizza ever!!! I am originally from NY and omg this pizza was amazing!“

“awesome, fresh & delicious pizza,highly recommend“

“Complimeenti! Una vera pizza napoletana, degna della nostra grande tradizione.“

“Muy buena atención por parte de yaslin,y la pizza muy buena.“

“Mary Alexa es la mejor . Y la comida súper rica“

“I love this hidden gem!!!“

“Absolutely wonderful experience!! Everything was amazing from start to finish. The food was delicious, and beautifully prepared, and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. You can really tell that a lot of care goes into every detail. We had such a great time and enjoyed everything we ordered!!! Definitely a place I would recommend and happily come back to !!!“

“There delicious Italian food made fresh and there great service ! And it's family friendly“

“Excelente lugar, la pizza estilo New York buenisima, muy buena atención, lo recomiendo“

“The quality of food is high, for that I recommend it. The reason I wouldn’t go back is that the staff just did not care we were there at all. Still waiting for them to ask how everything is… we came through last year and had a totally different experience staff was super friendly and engaged even though the place was packed. We caught them at turnover and they couldn’t care less. We talked about hitting craft as a high point for our one night in Miami before cruising… and now we won’t bother going back to Bayside.“

“buena atención lindo ambiente buena música ..y la comida delicioza“

“As a former owner of 17 restaurants, I know exactly what it takes to run a successful business and deliver outstanding hospitality. My recent dining experience at Piola on Hallandale Beach Boulevard completely blew me away, thanks to two incredible team members.
From the moment I arrived, I was welcomed by the manager, Lucio. His professionalism and leadership were evident right away, setting a fantastic tone for the entire establishment.
However, the absolute highlight of the experience was our server, Viviana. Her attention to detail, genuine kindness, and high level of professionalism were unmatched. In my professional opinion, her skills go far beyond standard service—she operates at the level of an Assistant Manager at the very least.
It is rare to find staff members who truly understand the art of hospitality. Lucio and Viviana make an outstanding team, and because of them, I will definitely be returning. Highly recommended!“

“I went there Last Saturday with my mom and my two fur babies so we sat outside of course and Rebecca was Soooo super friendly and helpful that it made it our visit there extremely enjoyable. The ambiance and service are excellent. The food: Was so super tasty and flavorful. We ordered the Bruschetta (delicious), the prosciutto and mozzarella (fabulous) and a pizza (stunning). We absolutely enjoyed everything and will definitely be returning. My fur babies had an excellent time as well and they will also be returning with us. They even had some of the food and totally agree. Absolutely delicious 😋. Thank you Rebecca for everything and we will see you real soon. 😘“

“Salsiccia and Nonna Meatball pizzas with bruschetta appetizer. Got a side of marinara as well, which is legit. Got one classic crust and tried the charcoal crust which was a first. All good and will be back. Worth a visit if you’re in Wynwood.“

“Fantastic place to go for pizza! Staff are amazing and so friendly. Food is freshly made and the portions are huge! Restaurant is very clean and nicely done. We will definitely be going back again when we are in town.“

“The pizzas and pastas are really amazing.“

“Perfecto Pizza and Salads !“

“Never disappoints always delicious“

“Great atmosphere and even better food“

“Great staff, amazing food and awesome views!“

“Best pizza I have had in a long time, perfect crust“

“This place pleasantly by far exceeded our expectations. The Philly cheese steak sandwich was scrumptious and the chicken strips and onion wrings were mouth watering as well. Even more importantly it was clean and the staff and owner were most accommodating! Thank you J. Sanders from Illinois“

“awesome, fresh & delicious pizza,highly recommend“

“The best pizza in town!!! We ordered 9 pizzas for my son’s Birthday and they were delicious! Everything came out exactly by the time we ordered it. And the prices are very fair. Julio is the owner, works there by himself. It was such a pleasure to have business with him. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Best pizzas in Miami!!!❤️❤️“