15 Best Seafood Restaurants near Boca Grande

“This is another place that deserves more than a 1000 reviews.
I stopped here first to pick up lunch for the groom and friends, when someone mentioned about their popar lobster sandwiches. Although they are a bit expensive ($34), it was worth every bite.
Came back the next day for another lobster sandwich and crab cake, and it tastes gooooddd, is still the best sandwich I have ever had.“

“So good!! We ate here twice while in BG. We loved their sausage & pepper app. We did takeout this time around, ravioli w/ meat sauce & fet alf. & Italian sausage. The pasta is so homemade & the Alf sauce was perfect, not too heavy , just right! I def recommended the food & will 100% be back next visit . Thank you for the delish food!!“

“Eagle Grille & Miller's Dockside in Boca Grande, Florida offers an impressive dining experience. The food is not only delicious, but also generous in portions, ensuring complete satisfaction. The care we received was exceptional, highlighted by a very pleasant and professional lady who made the visit even more special. Additionally, the restaurant's location, right in front of a marina, adds a unique touch to the environment, providing beautiful views that complement the experience. A highly recommended place for those looking to enjoy good food in a charming environment.“

“7 of us were there for dinner tonight. Pizza was wonderful, lasagna & salads were delicious. The BEST part was our waitress Tosha. She.Is.Hilarious. Seriously, a gem.“

“My wife and I just had the best burgers and onion rings there. Really cool bar also.“

“We always love it here. It's a "have to" destination while visiting the island. Can't go wrong on any of their dishes. See y'all soon!

Parking: Can get limited parking during busy hours. Usually can find a spot in the lot next door.“

“Great food in an historical setting.“

“Can't beat this place. Pine Island folks doing what they do best. We do miss their Pi eland Marina location but we get it. Best Breakfast amd service on the island. Do not overlook their lunch menu as well. Can't go wrong!“

“Great food, drinks and service. You wouldn't get me to eat fish dip, but the smoked mahi dip was unbelievable! Regulars now.“

“Took the water taxi to Rum Bay restaurant. Our captain, Captain Dave was amazing and accommodating! This is really a fun experience to enjoy before dining at Rum Bay. Thank you Captain Dave for being fun, informative, and so accommodating! We hope to see you again soon! Keep making your chowda!☺️“

“Very, very busy when we were there mid March 2022 so I'll certainly cut them some slack for (kind of) slow service. Our server really hustled and when the food arrived it was really good. If you like a good sized burger, this is the place! Fries were fantastic, too. One small complaint; Cool Pickle is a place where they sometimes have (continuous) karaoke, which I can personally do without. Kinda loud and difficult to have a conversation with the other diners we were with. Some of the performers couldn't carry a note if they had a 5 gallon pail, but some were quite good. However, very good for the most part and I will be returning again.“

“Cool old school nautical bar, restaurant. My resident hosts said best on island. Away I went for Sunday brunch,lunch.

My hosts said try the fish. Catch of the day. Etc etc. I ordered triple tail platter. I'm from Boston so I have no idea what a triple tail is. I asked for grilled fillet. Small thin serving. Reminded me of TV ad...." where's the beef." Good yet could have eaten 2x.

Platter came with fries and small serving of coleslaw. Coleslaw was good, IMHO.

good local beer, attentive service, ( I sat at the bar). One dollar bills on the ceiling. ( I did not ask). Very good vibe. Why is fish so expensive on an island. I would return to investigate alt. Items on menu.“

“Friendly, attentive staff. Excellent food with great presentation, and the desserts are phenomenal!! A great 'go to' place for a special occasion, or just cocktails & a bite at the bar. We'll definitely be back to work our way down the menu!!“

“The best Italian food in the area you will not be disappointed. The staff are amazing too they have had the same people working there since they opened. I can’t say enough good things about them if you haven’t been you are really missing out make Sure you make reservations they want you to have a nice dining experience and enjoy your dinner no rushing you out the door no delays on getting your food this place is amazing“

“We took the water taxi over to Rum Bay Restaurant and it did not disappoint. Our server Debbie was so attentive and funny. It was happy hour and we got a bogo appetizer of conch fritters. There were 9 in an order and so yummy. I got the blackened tacos, my son got the Mahi dinner and hubby got the blackened grouper. Everything was presented wonderfully and so very tasty. I can't wait till my next guests get here to experience this all over again. Thank you Rum Bay Restaurant. Hope to see you soon.

Vegetarian options: My son is a vegetarian and this was a really good pick for his tastes.“