18 Best Ice Cream Shops near Highland City

“It was great food Great service“

“This is a wonderful dessert shop with a wide variety of Italian ice, gelato, ice cream and shakes. Items are gluten free, dairy free and sugar free. Owners are wonderful and always welcoming and friendly. Business is sparkling clean and inviting.“

“My husband love the moonpie ice cream, and we had to go to Mulberry Ice Cream Company. The lady even placed a birthday candle on top of the ice cream. We all signed happy birthday. Thank you for a wonderful time.“

“Good ice cream ! Never disappoints.“

“This is hands down the best açaí bowl I’ve ever had. Welcoming, friendly, knowledgeable and patient as I decided what we wanted. I chose to build my own but I was nervous about trying the dragon fruit base and was given the option to do half açaí and half dragon fruit. Dragon fruit is what I prefer now! My bf and I really enjoyed it. Two words.. EARLY BIRD! ;)

Vegetarian options: More fruit smoothies , juices , açaí bowls, but they do have chips and cookies, muffins and brownies.“

“This is the best ice cream! So many flavors to choose from and they change flavors frequently. I love the ice cream is nice and hard too! It’s absolutely delicious!“

“Son muy ricos los helados y muy naturales!!! 100% recomendado y el lugar muy limpio y los dueños muy amables me encantó ♡“

“very friendly. Best icecream we have had.“

“Always wonderful service, friendly employees, super quick, and very Delicious!!!! Always have stamp cards and coupons“

“Jeremiah’s Italian Ice in South Lakeland is hands-down one of our favorite local spots — a total gem for the whole family! From the moment you walk up to the colorful and upbeat storefront, you can feel the good vibes. The staff is always friendly, patient, and full of energy, even when the line is long (which it often is — and for good reason!).

The flavor choices are endless, and the combinations you can create with their Gelatis (layered Italian ice and soft-serve) are absolutely next level. Whether you’re a classic mango fan or like to go wild with flavors like cotton candy, root beer, or cookies & cream — there’s something for every mood and every age. The texture of the Italian ice is perfect every time — smooth, icy, and packed with flavor, not watery or bland like others. And their soft-serve? So creamy it’s addictive.

My kids are obsessed, and honestly, so am I. It’s become our go-to reward after games, a pick-me-up on hot Florida afternoons, and a no-brainer when friends visit. Prices are reasonable, portions are generous!

Big thanks to the South Lakeland Jeremiah’s team for keeping the treats delicious and the atmosphere top-notch. If you haven’t tried it yet — you’re missing out. Trust me, one visit and you’ll be hooked! Oh Yeah…Unlimited Samples!!! Just in case you have a thought time choosing.“

“Went to the Auburndale flea market and bought some. Great product. Great sense of humor. He had us laughing. It was Northern pecan vs Southern pecan lol. Will definitely be visiting their store in Bartow.“

“Exactly what you would expect from a small town ice cream shoppe! Reasonable prices, great ice cream, food menu is pretty simple but, everything we tried was very good and prepared well. Great service, we go here often and love supporting this local small business!“

“Love this place ! The food is always so good (especially the chili!) & fresh. Love the decor and vibes of the workers everyone is friendly. Definitely a Bartow staple, it’s a must try if you haven’t already.“

“Really enjoyed spending time at the park. Plenty of shaded areas and paths to walk. Wished they had changing tables in the restrooms.“

“I am so hooked on all the flavors of Italian ice I’m sad when they’re not open very delicious dessert the wife and I like to have it as much as we can highly recommend best Italian ice I’ve had“

“It’s your local Baskin Robins. They have great ice cream and open late. Love this location.“