Ice Cream Shops near Lithia

1 Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

4.8 Superb 90 Reviews

5648 Circa Fishhawk Boulevard, Lithia

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I had an amazing experience at Rita's! The staff was incredibly knowledgeable, friendly, and welcoming—always ready with a smile and eager to help. Their dedication to customer service is evident in every aspect of the store. The variety of frozen treats, from their famous Italian ice to the creamy custards, was outstanding. The flavors were perfectly balanced. I particularly loved the blend of Italian ice with custard—it was a deliciously refreshing treat. The atmosphere was relaxed, and I could tell they really care about giving customers a great experience. I’ll definitely be coming back! Highly recommend for anyone looking for a sweet, refreshing indulgence!”

2 Art Monkey Emporium

4.4 Superb 74 Reviews

16132 Churchview Drive Suite 112, Lithia

• Take-Out

“Cannot recommend Art Monkey enough! We recently hosted our young daughter’s birthday there and it was the absolute sweetest time! The new owners made planning flawless and everything was set up and ready to go when we arrived. She was so good with the kids and they had a blast. Made her day so special and all the parents kept commenting how they enjoyed it as well (food and wine/beer a major plus!). The kids all got to paint a ceramic followed but a delicious ice cream treat. What a special afternoon ☺️”

3 The Sandwich Shop

4.2 Good 78 Reviews

10421 S County Rd 39, Lithia

“Fast, friendly, and delicious! Haven’t had something I didn’t like”

4 Baskin-Robbins

2.3 Poor 7 Reviews

16645 Fishhawk Boulevard, Lithia

• Delivery

5 Jack's Shack Ice Cream - Brandon

5.0 Superb 119 Reviews

823 East Brandon Boulevard, Brandon

• Delivery

“We had a wonderful time at this place! Attention was amazing, ice cream flavors are just great. We tried the matcha cake with kiwi and strawberry and the vanilla macaroons as well and they taste delicious; We definitely will visit again soon!”

6 Cold Stone Creamery

4.5 Superb 271 Reviews

3426 Lithia Pinecrest Road, Valrico

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I stopped by Cold Stone on a Thursday night, and I just wanted to give Andrew a shoutout because he was amazing. There had to be at least 10–15 people in front of me, but he stayed patient, friendly, and in a good mood the whole time. He treated everyone with kindness and never looked annoyed or rushed, even with such a long line. By the time it was my turn, he made my ice cream perfectly, and you could tell he actually enjoyed helping people. It honestly made my night. Give that man a tip, a bonus, or a raise—he deserves it! And y’all definitely need a third person working on holiday weekdays because it gets busy.”

7 Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4.5 Superb 212 Reviews

825 East Bloomingdale Avenue, Brandon

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing Italian shaved ice! We don’t have anything like this back in Michigan. So would definitely recommend stopping to try it out with the large selection of flavors and the combinations you can do with soft serve ice cream.”

8 Campbell's Dairyland

4.3 Superb 428 Reviews

200 South Parsons Avenue, Brandon

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“21 years after first working here I still recommend the Cuban sandwich 🥪. I've brought my own hatchlings here since then and they like the different ice cream options. for me, a twister still with peanut butter cups and snickers 😃”

9 Twistee Treat Valrico

4.3 Superb 293 Reviews

1886 E FL-60, Brandon

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Very close to the house. They have excellent customer service and the treats are amazing!! Definitely will be going back!!”

10 Bruster's Real Ice Cream

4.1 Good 110 Reviews

1025 East Bloomingdale Avenue, Valrico

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Dairy free ice cream vegan ice cream … so delicious”