17 Best American Restaurants in Lake Mary

“Had a great experience here over the weekend. The food was amazing, drinks were strong, and the service is worth writing home about. We started with the fruit/cheese platter and that would have filled us up by itself. I had the grilled chicken Caesar salad, which was one of the best I’ve had. Both drinks i ordered were strong and tasted great. Will definitely be back.“

“The manager on duty last night was awesome! I’m only assuming he was the manager. Made our order wrong because of something trivial and made it right in the name of customer service. My wife and I have been going there for years and we will continue being patrons because of people like him !“

“Huge rave!!!! I just got home from dinner and have never been more pleased. I have Celiac Disease and a wheat allergy. My server, Sydney C., was knowledgeable about the GF options and even double checked with her manager. She even brought up cross contamination before I did and assured me it would not be an issue. I was actually able to enjoy a meal with my family at a restaurant, which is not something I have been able to do in a long time. Thank you so much for being so accommodating. We will definitely be coming back.“

“Great service by Emily and Marley is a great trivia hostess and Liz is a great manager. They all do a super job at Duffy’s we will be back!“

“This place is amazing! I haven't written a Google review in forever, and I am literally writing this one while sitting at the table after having an incredibly delicious breakfast with my hubby for Valentine's Day! Alli, our server, was fantastic, and we already can't wait to go back and ask for her next time! My hubby had the cookie dough waffle, bacon, and fried potatoes. I had the apple fritter French toast with blueberries, bacon, and scrambled eggs. My hubby likes his bacon wiggly, and I like mine cooked until it's crunchy, and they cooked everything perfectly! We also started with the cinnamon bun cold brew, holy frijoles, it was DELISH!! This is our new favorite breakfast spot and we will be bringing family and friends FOR SURE!! Thank you Alli and chefs for a fantastic breakfast!!“

“Ended up sitting at the bar but had a great time. Dawna and Steven were both quite friendly and attentive. We had good moderately priced cocktails and the food was great. We had a big wedge salad, mini crabcakes and 2 orders of blackened steak tips.“

“I’ve been here maybe 50 times 😂 either via uber eats or in person. The service is super quick, nice, and today, even a chef stepped up to the check out counter to make sure the process was quick and I didn’t have to wait on a check out person. The food never leaves me feeling sick, and they only use olive oil (vs canola or other sub par, cheap oil) - huge perk. For a vegan - this place is a huge win!!

Dietary restrictions: Vegan“

“Huge rave!!!! I just got home from dinner and have never been more pleased. I have Celiac Disease and a wheat allergy. My server, Sydney C., was knowledgeable about the GF options and even double checked with her manager. She even brought up cross contamination before I did and assured me it would not be an issue. I was actually able to enjoy a meal with my family at a restaurant, which is not something I have been able to do in a long time. Thank you so much for being so accommodating. We will definitely be coming back.“

“Jasmyn is a wonderful server. Pleasant atmosphere, food is deee lish !!“

“My first time here and I LOVED it! Quiet, clean, and stylish. The workers and patrons alike were considerate and respectful of noise levels. The food is very reasonably priced and delicious!! I can say that the lettuce burger, their classic double burger, fries, and cookies and cream custard milkshake were all exceptional (and that was all just $40). I would surely recommend this establishment and consider it to be a much higher level than McDonalds, Burger King, etc, but still in the same price range. BurgerFi has high quality ingredients that don't just taste like grease and they also use real beef without weird additives or preservatives. 100% coming back, and 100% recommend!“

“Just had the best Breakfast at First Watch! Sarah (and Nicole, one of the Hosts who helped Sarah as she had the large table by our booth!) were excellent! They took great care of us! Awesome food as always! Thank you!!!“

“Great food and service ! It’s a whole vibe!“

“Topgolf is great for the whole family. My wife and I enjoy coming here on both a date night as well as visiting here with the kids.
The facility design in Lake Mary is top-notch. We are usually able to grab a bite to eat and then get right to playing without any weight. The staff is attentive and professional.
Always a fun time!“

“Just wonderful. The Christmas buffet was amazing. So much to offer. Something for everyone. The servers and omelet station people were so friendly and accommodating. Making sure we were very well taken care of. Great job.“

“3 stars only because one of the beautiful, fun, bartenders can get really hammered.
But they've got poker 3 times a week at 7 o'clock $10 or $20 buy in ($80-120 to winner), and if you get there before 11 o clock the staff is sweet, pretty, and definitely worth coming back for.
Also the 2 pool tables and Dart board locals are competitive but never unwelcoming.“

“Great atmosphere, nice spacious rooms and amenities. Just relaxing!!“

“ToGo is super easy. Mary Beth made transaction happen with no wait. Super quick. Ty“