17 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sanibel

The Shack of Sanibel Ice Cream Shop • $
1219 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel

Customers` Favorites

Buckeye Peanut Butter Custard
Blue Raspberry Shaved Ice
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Two Scoop S'Mores CuO
Mint Cookies 'N Creme
Sea Turtle Ice Cream
Cookies 'N' Creme
Ice Cream Sundae
Heath Bar Crunch
Chocolate Flakes

“Awesome ice cream!!!!! I'll be back!!!!“

4.9 Superb116 Reviews
Sanibel's Best Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
362 Periwinkle Way #5, Sanibel

“Popped in with my besty Anna for a couple of scoops. Anna had a espresso with ice cream and I had 2 scoops of the chocolate. Well, it was so good that we went back in for seconds!“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
2075 Periwinkle Way #33, Sanibel

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream-Dirty Sanddollar Vanilla Based with Caramel and Chunks of Chocolate
Double Flavor Sprinkle Chocolate Dipped Cone
Single Flavor Chocolate Dipped Cone
Reeces Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Double Flavor Waffle Cone
Mint Chocolate Chip
Brownie Explosion
Lemon Sorbet
Butter Pecan
Mango Sorbet

“We are on a girls weekend trip, we came across Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream on our first night and it was so delicious that we had to go back on our second night. Our dinner plans ran over and we pulled in to Pinocchio's at 9:02pm. We were greeted by the sweetest employees Maddy & Talon. They let the five of us in and served us with a smile! We were in and out in less than 5 or so minutes. They made our night!! We made sure to tip well! We likely will go back for our third and final night on the island!“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
Love Boat Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
1700 Periwinkle Way #9, Sanibel

“One of the best Ice cream we had in recent times in Florida. The cheesecake flavors are the best.“

4.6 Superb10 Reviews
Gelato-go Fort Myers Ice Cream Shop • $
15271 McGregor Blvd #8, Fort Myers - 7.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Gluten Free Cake with Scoop of Gelato
Chocolate Hazelnut Cake and Torrone Gelato
Hazelnut and Strawberry Cheesecake
Tuiti Fruiti and White Chocolate
Several Gelato Flavors
Eggplant Parmesana
Gelato Small Cone
Focaccia Friulano
Lasagna Bolognese
Arancini Di Riso

“What can I say? Amazing gelato , amazing experience , and amazing food love this place.“

4.9 Superb185 Reviews
Cape Creamery Premium Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1715 Cape Coral Pkwy W, Cape Coral - 7.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salted Caramel Hot Fudge Sundae
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Ice Cream Assortment
Toasted Coconut
Cherry Amaretto
Banana Pudding
Nutella Chip
Butter Pecan
Waffle Cone
Mint Chip

“Great visit to Cape Creamery. Super Friendly staff and lush ice cream. We’ll Definitely be back! X“

4.9 Superb90 Reviews
Holy Moly Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
3512 Del Prado Blvd S Suite 111, Cape Coral - 10.76 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Gelato Choco Loco and Banana Split
Spaghetti Ice Cream Kids Surprise
Spaghetti Ice Cream Banana Split
Spaghetti Ice Cream Cheesecake
Spaghetti Ice Cream Choco Loco
Spaghetti Ice Cream Strawberry
Spaghetti Ice Cream Blueberry
Spaghetti Ice Cream Nut Wave
Strawberry Cheesecake Gelato
Spaghetti Ice Cream Amarena

“A fun experience! The ice cream was really good and they are presented in a fun way! Will definitely be back and will recommend it to everyone! Edit: When we went the other day my mom asked for pecans and they didn’t have them. We loved this place so much we went again today and the owner showed us that he got pecans. He said he listens to his customers and wanted to make sure he had pecans now. This is true customer service and an owner who truly cares about his customer! I highly recommend this place to everyone!“

4.8 Superb88 Reviews
Ice Sssscreamin/Cape Coral Ice Cream Shop • $$
1017A Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral - 9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Donuts Ice Cream Sandwitch
Cookie Dough Avalanche
Death by Chocolate
Cotton Candy Cloud
Tiramisu Special
Cookie Monster
Cream Sandwich
Key Lime Pie
Oreo Sundae
Banana Split

“Very friendly and fast service! Highly recommend!“

4.7 Superb220 Reviews
Sidecar Treats Cape Coral Ice Cream Shop • $
434 SE 47th Terrace Suite A, Cape Coral - 8.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Dipped Waffle Cone
Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip
Raspberry Cheesecake
Coconut Ice Cream
Specialty Sundae
Mocha Ice Cream
Brownie Batter
Ice Cream Cone
Banana Split

“Awesome selection! Highly recommend, we visited from Wisconsin and we were not disappointed. 🍦“

4.6 Superb95 Reviews
Sunset Beach Hershey's Ice Cream Real Fruit Smoothies Ice Cream Shop • $
1028 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach - 4.13 miles

“Love love loved it all...can't wait till your reopening!!! ;) keep us posted please!“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Love Boat Home Made Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
16475 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream Sundae
Blueberry Cheesecake
Chocolate Ice Cream
Banana Cream Pie
Salted Caramel
Chocolate Chip
Birthday Cake
Butter Pecan
Banana Split
Small Cone

“One of the best Ice cream we had in recent times in Florida. The cheesecake flavors are the best.“

4.5 Superb141 Reviews
2000 Flavors Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1000 Fifth St, Fort Myers Beach - 4.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Float

“Everything was fabulous. So good that I got distracted and left my vari-focal prescription glasses behind. I don’t suppose you have them do you? Thank you. PS. Glasses last seen on the table on the left in the photo!“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Pinocchios Original Italian Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
16230 Summerlin Rd #202, Fort Myers - 7.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cones
Banana Split
Sundaes
Gelato

“We are on a girls weekend trip, we came across Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream on our first night and it was so delicious that we had to go back on our second night. Our dinner plans ran over and we pulled in to Pinocchio's at 9:02pm. We were greeted by the sweetest employees Maddy & Talon. They let the five of us in and served us with a smile! We were in and out in less than 5 or so minutes. They made our night!! We made sure to tip well! We likely will go back for our third and final night on the island!“

4.4 Superb38 Reviews
Gulf Coast Fudge Co Ice Cream Shop • $
5971 Silver King Blvd #110, Cape Coral - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashion Fudge
Pretzels

“I definitely recommend Gulf Coast Fudge Co!!!! the staff is so amazing, specifically Sarah! Very friendly environment. I had the “Mint To Be” freak shake and it was delicious!!! Will be back for sure!“

4.1 Good17 Reviews
The French Press Coffee Shops • $
5789 Cape Harbour Dr #101, Cape Coral - 6.72 miles

Customers` Favorites

Americano Coffee and Chocolate Croissant
Egg and Bacon Breakfast
Lazy Sunday Morning
Breakfast Burrito
Donatella Gelato
Breakfast Club
Avocado Toast
Apple Crepes
Croissants
Sandwich

“My visit to The French Press in Cape Coral, Florida, was absolutely delightful! I indulged in their mango gelato and a peanut butter and jelly chocolate truffle, and both were excellent. The mango gelato was refreshingly fruity and creamy, perfect for a warm day. The peanut butter and jelly chocolate truffle was a delightful surprise, combining rich chocolate with the classic flavors of PB&J in a sophisticated and delicious way.

The facilities are located right on the water, facing many boats docked nearby, which adds a unique and picturesque element to the dining experience. It was truly enjoyable to sit by the water and watch the boats.

I will definitely be returning to try more of their offerings!“

4.4 Superb66 Reviews
Planet Smoothie Juice • $
11600 Gladiolus Dr #101, Fort Myers - 6.84 miles

“This was a colorful, bright, and clean place that was empty of patrons when we were there. I'm not sure if they get much drive-through business, but it was super quiet. We had three small bowls of ice cream, one with gummy bears, and the bill was almost $20 - so perhaps this is why.“

3.6 Good10 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1607 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral - 9.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Butter Burger and Fresh Fries
Concrete Mixer or Sundae
Butterburger Cheese
Crinkle Cut Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Tenders
Crispy Chicken
Fish and Chips
Frozen Custard
Turtle Sundae

“Piper loves her once a week pup cup!!“

4 Good143 Reviews

Similar Cuisines In Sanibel

You May Also Like