31 Best Italian Restaurants near Sanibel

1 Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen

4.6 Superb 298 Reviews

1200 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our beach wedding was torrential downpour rained out 😭. Robin to the rescue! She pulled it all together and we were able to gather everyone and do our vows in the loft where our reception was scheduled to be!!! It was perfect and the food and service was amazing! Everyone had a great time! Thank you so much to Robin and the entire staff!”

2 Dante's Coal Fired Pizza

4.1 Good 294 Reviews

937 East Gulf Drive, Sanibel

• Take-Out

“Came to Dante‘s at 8:40 PM closing at nine. It wasn’t very crowded but the service was fantastic. The head chef came out out of the kitchen to ask us about allergies. The food we ordered was fresh and exceedingly tasty and I think it was an excellent experience.”

3 Italian to Go

5.0 Superb 133 Reviews

6314 Corporate Court Suite 150, Fort Myers · 11.29 miles

• Delivery

“Recommended by friends. Hidden treasure! We had an amazing dinner tonight with huge portions of authentic Italian food. Great service. So much personality in this restaurant. Highly recommend .... we will be back!”

4 CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar

4.7 Superb 368 Reviews

12901 McGregor Boulevard Suite 16, Fort Myers · 9.98 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We always go here when we are in town. We absolutely loved our service tonight with James, our server. In addition to his amazing service and great personality, we truly enjoy the atmosphere and how friendly everyone is. This is such a well ran restaurant…forever our favorite Italian food here! ❤️”

5 Osteria Celli

4.7 Superb 336 Reviews

15880 Summerlin Road Suite 308, Fort Myers · 8.85 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Where do I begin... This establishment came highly recommended, and did not disappoint! Tajh was our server, greeted us immediately with a friendly smile, was very attentive, and knew the menu like the back of her hand. We sat at the bar, where you can see the food being prepared in the open kitchen concept. We started with an appetizer of calamari ~ grilled, not fried ~ complimented with mandolin vegetables and an amazing sauce. Then, we shared two of the entree's on the daily special menu: Braised short rib with calamarata pasta - it fell off the bone and melted in your mouth and mushroom ravioli with a brown butter sauce. Both dishes were bursting with flavor. Midway through dining, Chef Corricelli approached us to ask how our food was. He is clearly a passionate culinary expert. We finished with a delicious tiramisu for dessert - we were so full, but managed to finish every bite! We will be back, and highly recommend Osteria Celli!”

6 Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.6 Superb 509 Reviews

8841 College Parkway, Fort Myers · 10.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I hosted a Grand Opening event in town for my client, and since I’m not from the area, planning the food from a distance was a bit nerve-wracking. My client suggested pizza, so I reached out to several local spots for quotes and menu details. While everyone responded, Robin at Citrola’s on College immediately stood out. She provided great options and suggested we speak over the phone. ​From the moment we spoke, Robin put me at ease. She was incredibly helpful, using her knowledge of the local area and demographic to recommend a menu that would truly be a hit. She made the entire ordering process completely effortless and even offered to deliver the food personally to make sure everything was set up to perfection. ​To be honest, because she made it look so easy and my event was only a few days away, I was a little nervous and called the day before to follow up. Robin reassured me that everything was squared away and even offered to send staff to help serve my clients. ​When event day arrived, the order showed up right on time, and everything was absolutely perfect—even better than I had imagined! Robin personally helped with the setup and gave me great tips to ensure my guests had the best possible dining experience. ​Thank you so much, Robin, for your incredible service, attention to detail, and top-tier hospitality. You truly went above and beyond, and I look forward to working with you again in the future!”

7 Next Door

4.6 Superb 256 Reviews

5971 Silver King Boulevard Suite 114, Cape Coral · 6.41 miles

“Beautiful presentation and even more amazing food! What a wonderful little hidden spot at Tarpon Marina! We will always go again! Love, Love, Love!!!”

8 Two Meatballs in the Kitchen - Cape Coral

4.5 Superb 661 Reviews

1403 Cape Coral Parkway East, Cape Coral · 9.15 miles

• Delivery

“I had my bridal shower here.. so many things I love about this place . Atmosphere is cute,cozy, the food was delicious and large portions. THE STAFF WAS EXCEPTIONAL AND ACCOMMODATING ! I have never been in a restaurant that had such caring attentive people. The chef was amazing and kind and checked on us. I give this place 5 stars! Really does feel like your at a loving moms home ! Will be back”

9 Mastello Ristorante & Steakhouse

4.5 Superb 418 Reviews

7890 Summerlin Lakes Drive Suite 101, Fort Myers · 10.89 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Fantastic dining experience!”

10 Trattoria Ciao

4.5 Superb 357 Reviews

823 Southeast 47th Terrace, Cape Coral · 8.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I can't say enough about this restaurant. The food was amazing. The atmosphere and love was beyond what you would expect. I can't wait to go back. I want to try every single dish on the menu. I read the review about the vodka sauce and the recovering alcoholic. Why the f....k would you even consider ordering that dish in the first place??? You are playing games with yourself. Really, you cried at the table?? The owners are hard working people. There are erasers on pencils for a reason. Or maybe you don't know what an eraser is. I would have thrown your a** out wah wah wah!! And the other idiot with the chicken wings, you don't come to an Italian restaurant and ask for chicken wings. Go to Kentucky Fried chicken you arsh hole! Anyway I loved the gnocchi with cream sauce, which is what I had. I needed to sample the gravy, (yes we Italians can it gravy), so I had a meatball too! Totally recommend! Jill the owner is the sweetest person you will ever meet. Make a reservation it fills up real fast!”

11 Casablanca Café

4.7 Superb 66 Reviews

1400 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach · 4.2 miles

• Take-Out

“Ate here last night for my Aunt and Uncles anniversary dinner. We had a party of 7 and had no problem getting a reservation. The food was excellent, atmosphere was on point and the portions were great. Our server Michelle was fantastic and Sean was wonderful. Highly reccommend visiting here if youre looking for some good Italian food in Fort Myers.”

12 Ceno Grille

4.5 Superb 332 Reviews

1715 Cape Coral Parkway West, Cape Coral · 7.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Food and service was fantastic! Cannot wait to come back!!”

13 Caffé Toscano

4.6 Superb 108 Reviews

12901 McGregor Boulevard Suite 21, Fort Myers · 9.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’m still trying to process the experience I just had. One as good as this doesn’t come by very often. My wife and I while randomly driving around saw this restaurant and wanted to try it. I’d never heard of it prior to tonight. I had lasagna and my wife and a shrimp pasta dish. Both were the best we’ve ever had. The pasta was mind blowing. I don’t or can’t think of any other way of putting it. I had a lemon tart and wife had tiramisu. You guessed it, best we’ve ever had. Every bite spoke of the love and passion these folks have for their food and the guests inside. The atmosphere, calming music, knowledgeable server, friendly owners, and of course the food made this an experience I can’t wait to savor again. If you have the chance PLEASE check them out. You won’t regret it.”

14 Terra Nostra Ristorante

4.4 Superb 846 Reviews

15880 San Carlos Boulevard, Fort Myers · 6.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Lisa was so great! Awesome food and good atmosphere.”

15 Sicily Trattoria

4.4 Superb 290 Reviews

1211 Cape Coral Parkway East, Cape Coral · 9.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We are Sicilian decent wanted to try for my birthday. We ordered a Marguerita pie , eggplant parm, two seafood dishes and some soup. Staff was very nice and attentive. I liked that the food was not salty at all and you can add your own. My parents are hard to impress but my father loved it. He said “this is real pizza”. Set your expectations, this is not a brick oven pizzeria in Sicily. It’s a humble place in Florida , very clean and simple , reminds me of Nona’s food. Ohh the cannolis were 😚 yummy !! Crispy shell. I would go back just to have them !! You won’t be disappointed!!”

16 Citrola's Italian Restaurant on McGregor

4.3 Superb 316 Reviews

16740 McGregor Boulevard, Fort Myers · 4.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband & I throughly enjoyed our time this evening!! Joanie & Paige were awesome!!. The food was excellent!! Thank you so much for a very nice experience Joine & Paige!!”

17 Pizza Pub Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 384 Reviews

7050 Winkler Road Suite 102, Fort Myers · 9.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Loved everything . Food was really good loved the angle hair and sausage, it was a lot of food for being the smaller size. Our waitress Rachael was too much fun, she was ready joke with us as much as we did with her. A big shout out to Arlene who also was extra special and a really cheerful helper. Be nice to the whole staff, they work like crazy to take care of the crowds and get the food out quickly. I don’t think we as customers understand how stressful a job like that can be. Get your Oder ready, Enjoy your visit and delicious food😎”

18 Pizza Parma Cape Coral

4.2 Good 117 Reviews

4643 Coronado Parkway, Cape Coral · 8.96 miles

• Delivery

“had the best pizza I've had in a very long time...crust was phenomenal! Also tried the breakfast waffles and again they were outstanding! I love this place mainly for the food but also for the atmosphere. The chefs do their utmost to make their food memorable.”

19 Legno Italian Kitchen - Fort Myers Beach

4.2 Good 123 Reviews

7205 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach · 7.97 miles

• Delivery

“What can I say To start atmosphere was very nice laid back seat yourself then This Greg waiter guy comes buy and is absolutely the best. Great recommendations all the food was very good surf and turf was small but satisfying. Got a gluten free pizza to go. Greg was the best would definitely ask for him made our dining experience well worth it. W e will return next time in town”

20 Maria's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.2 Good 343 Reviews

1224 Southeast 46th Lane, Cape Coral · 9.23 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“baked ziti, excellent white pizza, excellent those garlic rolls.... incredible 🖤 Our new GO TO”

21 Il Pomodoro Italian Restaurant

4.2 Good 397 Reviews

9681 Gladiolus Drive, Fort Myers · 8.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just ate there recently, and the food was delicious! The service was great, too. We thoroughly enjoyed it & will go back soon! Best Italian food around!”

22 La Fontanella Ristorante

4.7 Superb 95 Reviews

7050 Winkler Road Ste 112, Fort Myers · 9.61 miles

• Take-Out

“Excellent food. The most authentic Italian food recipes. I highly recommend. It's our favorite restaurant.”

23 Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral

4.5 Superb 405 Reviews

842 Lafayette Street, Cape Coral · 8.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love this place.. it’s definitely my neighborhood go to. We especially love Brook!! She’s like family to us, she is professional, curious, and has a wonderful customer satisfaction rating.. the place was updated tasteful and didn’t skip a beat as the transition was flawless! Very proud to shout out praises!!!”

24 Starz Italian Restaurant - Gladiolus Dr

4.0 Good 213 Reviews

8750 Gladiolus Drive Suite 1, Fort Myers · 9.11 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent meatballs, Cabernet, and service. Spaghetti was good, too.”

25 Bada Bing Pizza Co.

4.5 Superb 237 Reviews

11600 Gladiolus Drive, Fort Myers · 6.87 miles

• Delivery

“Amazing food and top notch service!”

26 Wing Street

4.0 Good 11 Reviews

11581 Gladiolus Drive, Fort Myers · 6.76 miles

• Delivery

“This is not a sit down restaurant. It is take out or delivery only but if you are hungry for a very good, tasty pizza this is the place to go. I have gone here for years and have never been disappointed. The people are friendly who wait on you as you go in. Hungry for pizza? Try going here.”

27 Jet's Pizza

4.2 Good 262 Reviews

13550 Reflections Parkway, Fort Myers · 10.94 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just a couple tables available to sit at , but the pizza was delicious deep dish pepperoni and bacon. We enjoyed our dinner.”

28 Island View

4.2 Good 327 Reviews

1400 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach · 4.37 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just went after the renovation, and it was an awesome experience. The menu had plenty of great options and the food we chose came out very quickly and tasty. Plenty of sports on the surrounding TVs, atmosphere was great. Would definitely return.”

29 Jet's Pizza

4.1 Good 227 Reviews

821 Cape Coral Parkway West Ste 1, Cape Coral · 8.79 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We're visiting from Pennsylvania and have gotten pizza from here twice this past week. SOOO good!!! The 8 corner pizza is where it's at!!!!”

30 Rae's Real Italian at Pink Shell Beach Resort & Marina

4.1 Good 262 Reviews

275 Estero Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach · 3.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Mushroom Risotto with truffle oil. Iron Cast Beef Filet Medallions. Cioppino Excellent! Servers were excellent!! Shout out to Manager Sarah. very accommodating. Thank You!!!!!”

31 Bella Mozzarella Pizza & Grill

4.1 Good 361 Reviews

80 Old San Carlos Boulevard, Fort Myers Beach · 4.12 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My husband had the mango habanero wings and he said they were some of the best he’s ever had. Great service! Very reasonable prices!”