11 Best Italian Restaurants in The Villages

1 Redsauce American - Italian Restaurant

4.3 Superb 656 Reviews

1000 Canal Street, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We gave our name and were told, “30 minutes.” After one hour checked and were told, “7 ahead of you.” After one hour and 15 minutes were told, “2 ahead of you.” After watching 4 go ahead of us checked again. Manager said, “ thousands are checking in every day. We’re doing what we can.” After one hour and 45 minutes, and harassment from us, we were finally seated. Very poor experience.”

2 Mezza Luna at The Villages

4.2 Good 425 Reviews

243 Colony Boulevard, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our first time eating at this restaurant. The food was delicious. Will be making this a regular place for Italian food. Waitress was great also.”

3 Prima Italian Steakhouse

4.4 Superb 413 Reviews

3660 Kiessel Road, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had lunch on Monday. 5 stars not enough. Food, Service, and Atmosphere great. Special shout out to our waitress Lisa. You were amazing.”

4 Havana Country Club Restaurant

4.4 Superb 389 Reviews

2484 Odell Cir, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“food poisoning? I ate the fishermans platter on October 10th and got very sick. Has anyone else experience this?”

5 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.1 Good 482 Reviews

3680 Wedgewood Lane, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Outstanding food and service. Great value. Best salad and breadsticks anywhere local and the entrees are always delicious and fairly priced.”

6 Carrabba's Italian Grill

4.1 Good 571 Reviews

650 US-441, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Very good service and food!”

7 Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Lake Deaton

4.4 Superb 583 Reviews

729 Kristine Way, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Held a Pizza Party on Monday June 13 for Vietnam Veteran’s “Volunteer’s” and Everything was GREAT! From the Management and Staff, we couldn’t have been Happier and The Pizza’s were Excellent! Thank You, Sonny Baker, VVA Chapter 1036”

8 Sammy Joe's Pizzeria Cafe

4.4 Superb 241 Reviews

8760 SE 165th Mulberry Ln, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It was our first time at Sammy Joe's. We tried their Sammy's pizza tonight and absolutely delicious. Fluffy crust with a special seasoning. Just perfect 👌 My toddler also approved the pizza. Will be going back to try other things in the menu.”

9 Bravo Pizza!!!

4.3 Superb 296 Reviews

1080 Lake Sumter Landing, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great people at Bravo, we are always more than satisfied with everything they serve. I’m a New York Pizza guy and find Bravo to be close to some of my favorites back home. The complementary Garlic Knots with my first draft beer the best!!”

10 Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace

4.3 Superb 80 Reviews

3539 Wedgewood Lane, The Villages

“They have great food. If you love meat you will not be disappointed. I would've preferred less. I did appreciate the sausage on my pizza being sliced vice crumbled. One of the most impressive items served was the complimentary rolls. They were soooo good. The use of italian dressing as a drizzle over garlic butter and parmesean crusted rolls was such a tasty combination. Don't knock it til you try it. A new stop on my visit to Tallahassee.”

11 Marco's Pizza

4.0 Good 117 Reviews

2196 Everglades Lane, The Villages

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Quality pizza at great prices.”