Home
GA
Atlanta
Custom Cakes

Custom Cakes in Atlanta, GA

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes in Atlanta.

Showing 14 of 15 restaurants

Ice Cream Shop · $$
1 Ben & Jerry’s

4.7 Superb 607 Reviews

312 North Highland Avenue Northeast Suite A, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- 3 Scoop Bourbon Brown Butter Ice Cream
- Snackable Cookie Dough Chunks
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
- Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
“The staff is extremely friendly! It’s one of my favorite stops for ice cream! It’s a clean establishment and the employees demonstrate real pride in their work! They greet you with a warm hello! Ben & Jerry’s Inman Park is my dessert go-to!”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $$$$
2 Virginia Marie Cake Boutique

4.8 Superb 88 Reviews

5160 Erin Rd SW, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Dipped Rice Krispie Treats
- Baker's Choice Four Pack
- Your Choice Four Pack
- Peanut Butter Cookies
“I just love the cupcakes: they are moist, not too sweet, and have a very mouth-watering taste!!! You can't just eat one!!!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
3 Sweet Red Peach

4.7 Superb 137 Reviews

1020 White Street Southwest, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Yellow Cake w Chocolate Buttercream Slice
- Red Velvet Cake Slice and Strawberry Cake
- Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake
- Red Velvet Cheesecake Slice
“I came for a vanilla cupcake and got it and a banana pudding. The banana pudding was absolutely delicious!!! I was going to eat just a little and be able to eat it over the next few days. Well, I devoured it in one sitting! I couldn’t stop! It was perfect. I’ll definitely be going back to get another soon. If you like banana pudding you’ll love it! I’ll have to come back and rate the cupcake. Gave it to my daughter so I’ll have to ask her what she thinks. Lisa, one of the owners, was kind and welcoming.”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $
4 Morelli’s Gourmet Ice Cream and Desserts

4.6 Superb 113 Reviews

1002 North Highland Avenue Northeast, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Extra Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream 6 Oz
- One Scoop Ice Cream Sundae
- Blondie Sundae
- Brownie Sundae
“Absolutely delicious strawberry ice cream i’m waffle cone 👌🏾”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
5 Cold Stone Creamery

4.6 Superb 260 Reviews

1270 Ashford Crossing, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand
- Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
- Brownie a La Cold Stone
- Banana Caramel Crunch
“I think the size I order is considered a pint. I got butter pecan with extra, extra, extra pecans! The man who took my order was so kind and had the most pleasant smile. He was so considerate with asking how far did I have to travel and when I told him the distance, he wrapped my container of ice cream up nicely in Saran wrap and advised me to put it in the freezer as soon as I reached home. I should have left a tip, but I usually don’t leave tips for to go service. I will be back there again and if he’s there I will leave a tip, because of all the times I’ve ordered my ice cream, no one has gone above and beyond like he did. Thank you for your thoughtfulness!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
6 Sweet as Heaven Goodies

4.8 Superb 61 Reviews

4300 Paces Ferry Rd SE #4008, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Oatmeal Cream Pie Cookie
- Strawberry Gooie
- Butter Gooie
“Cutest little bakery for a fresh sweet treat while you take a break from shopping at Vinings Jubilee!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$$$
7 Cakes by Niecy, LLC

4.6 Superb 67 Reviews

400 Fairburn Road, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Cake
- Wedding Cake
- Cake Pop
- Cupcake
“The cake was spectacular and the details of the Princess Tiana cake was detailed diwn to the braids in her hair to the flowees on her dress. And to top it off she squeezed me in her schedule and still delivered as promised. Thank you Niecy, forever grateful & she was shocked and elated for her special day!👌🏽💞❣”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes
8 Fashionably Kaked

3.9 Good 14 Reviews

3150 East Shadowlawn Avenue Northeast, Atlanta
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Cake
- Wedding Cake
- Red Velvet
“My dad absolutely loved this cake! It was moist and delicious. The customer service was A1 and the design was spot on for what I asked for! I will definitely book her every time I have an event or a birthday etc. - in absolute love ! Thank you!”
Menu
Bakery · $$$$
9 Kimberly Sweet Shoppe

4.6 Superb 54 Reviews

3300 Marjan Dr, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“She has great customer service. She delivered what I ordered. my daughter loved her cake!!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$
10 The Cake Hag

4.3 Superb 118 Reviews

880 Glenwood Ave SE, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“Cake Hag has done my daughter’s bday cakes for the past 2 years. Looks and tastes amazing and got lots of compliments from guests. Very happy!”
Menu
Bakery · $
11 Hebrew Bakes

4.3 Superb 95 Reviews

879 Ralph David Abernathy Boulevard Southwest, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake Slice
- Carrot Cake Cupcakes
- Key Lime Cupcakes
- Vegan Cupcakes
“love love love this bakery! if you are thinking about you should definitely check them out! Everything they make is delicious and you can taste the love they put into it! 💗”
Menu Order
Cupcake shop · $
12 Smallcakes Cupcakery

4.0 Good 165 Reviews

2566 Briarcliff Road Northeast Suite 103, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cookies & Cream Cupcakes
- Lemon Meringue Cupcakes
- 12-Cupcake Box Assorted
- Strawberry Cupcake
“When I tell you Sean the owner was so nice. I placed an order on Uber eats but called before to get specific kind of cupcake. They made a mistake but when I called Sean he said just come up here we will replace them for free. When I came and the lady there was so nice and professional. When I tell you their cupcakes is so moist and dense not light. I have places 4 orders there and when I tell you I keep them in my car because how much I paid and how good they are I’m not sharing with anyone. Thank you Sean for being to nice and understanding about my order. Will definitely be back. Leaving to go to Ghana wish I could ship them there but I will stock up on them before I leave. Thanks Christina L. Mensah”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $
13 Baskin-Robbins

3.7 Good 108 Reviews

2335 Peachtree Road Northeast, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
“Amazing!! This location is the best place to bring your family and friends for an ICE CREAM FUN DAY! This is my favorite go to location after a long day. Today, was exceptionally awesome! WHY? Well, JORDAN gave the best customer service performance. Literally! She has the brightest smile and greeted us with excitement. Her attitude led me to try many NEW Flavors… What a difference she made in my day of exhaustion. I would like to commend JORDAN FOR HER EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE and BRIGHT SMILE.😊”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
14 Cold Stone Creamery

3.2 Average 203 Reviews

2850 Paces Ferry Road Southeast Ste 420, Atlanta
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Strawberry Ice Cream and Cheesecake Ice Cream with Dipped Cone
- Mix & Go Create Your Own Creation
- Brownie a La Cold Stone
- Cheesecake Fantasy
“OhhhhEmmmmmGeeeeee!!!! I haven’t had Coldstone in foreverrrrrrrrrr and today was the day to finally get my fix of the homemade goodness. As I was in the Vinings area, I stopped into this location and it was all smiles from the door. The staff was super warm and inviting. The store was very clean and best of all, it smelled like fresh ice cream, waffle cones, and pure happiness. LoL!!!! There are soooooooo many flavors to choose from and their creativity is beyond amazing when it comes to creating paired options. However, as soon as I looked on the board, I knew I had to go for my classic favorite. The Oreo Overload with a Sweet Cream base!!!! As I sit here and type I’m having flashbacks about how good the ice cream was. LoL!!! The sweet cream base is a favorite of mine. It has a great texture and a nice creamy flavor that pairs well with anything. The classic Oreo cookie blends so well with the creamy taste of the sweet cream that it seems to enhance the flavor profile of the cookie as a whole. Being the foodie creative that I am, I decided not to get fudge on my overload and to add some graham cracker crust to the mix. Whew! I hit the best kept secret ever. The crust pieces add a layer of texture that heightens every bite. Furthermore, the buttery crumbles go soooooooo well with the crushed Oreo. It almost puts you in the mindset of an Oreo cheesecake. Ummmmm!!! As I was placing my order I had the chance to interact with Claire and Erika and they are amazing. They were very knowledgeable about the flavor profiles. They had great recommendations and their overall service itself was above standard. Super nice. Super engaging, and best of all, full of smiles. Today was a good day, but after my trip to Coldstone… it was Ahhhhhhhhmazinggggg.”
Menu Order