36 Best American Restaurants near St. Marys

“My family ate dinner here one night 2 years ago and it was the best dining experience I’ve ever had. We returned again tonight and it was still just as good as it was 2 years ago! The food was so flavorful and fresh, everything was served hot and it was amazing. The staff were friendly and atmosphere was so comfortable., I highly recommend this place 10 out of 10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ this place deserves an award!“

“Love this bar! Jess and Becca are the best. Quick service. Cold beer. Great atmosphere. My favorite spot!“

“Server was amazing. Can’t remember her name, but she mentioned she was a teacher. Had amazing energy and was super helpful and it seemed she was running the whole front of house solo.“

“We came for brunch but will definetly be back for dinner. Great wait staff and phenomenally tasting food!!! 5 star review“

“Our entire experience from beginning to end was amazing at Burlingame. The staff was professional, knowledgeable and attentive. The portions were a good size and delicious! We had a great time and enjoyed the resturant… It’s beautiful btw!“

“Absolutely amazing!! We had an amazing waitress and overall was super good.“

“Susan and I have enjoyed numerous breakfasts and lunches at Ms Carolyn’s Restaurant. Now, we have another reason to enjoy lunch: Wednesday-Only Special Fried Chicken. Chef Kerry and Ms. Carolyn have found the pot of gold. This is really good fried chicken with 2 sides. Thanks to servers Stacy and Kay for alerting us to this great Wednesday Fried Chicken meal.“

“Plus my seating staff and waitress was very nice helpful even though she was very busy. She still came to me a quarterly asked me if I needed help. She was very nice very helpful and the guy that seated me he came over to help and accommodate to see if she needed help/see if I needed help with anything the food was delicious. Whoever the cook was the food was great. My steak was made the right way, I drank tasted good. It was nice and peaceful and it wasn’t too cold and it wasn’t too hot.“

“Great!!“

“Delicious and great tots!!“

“Best food great service ! Great atmosphere“

“Excellent burger’s and good soup 🥣“

“Visited for the first time this weekend blown away by the hospitality owner and staff went above and beyond ! If you're looking for a great experience this is the place ! Will be back -Sydney“

“Best customer service ever! The food is great. It has a nice playground in the back for the kids. The owner is a great guy and is very involved in his business and helps lead his staff. We got exceptional customer service. The kids and the whole family love coming here!“

“The waitress Sam is absolutely amazing!! She is the best thing smoking..great personality, memory on point!!
I ordered the patty melt plate. Sandwich was good but my hashbrowns were a bit crispy and my cheese wasn't melted. Other than that my family and I had a nice experience.“

“Our server Lindsey was wonderful. The food & atmosphere were great also.“

“A thoroughly charming and popular spot. Great menu and excellent attention by staff. The food is ordinarily great. On this evening, the main courses (fish, chicken) were excellent, but the sides (carbs, veggies) were barely warm. Management was very considerate when billing. Definitely going back whenever we're in the area.“

“Always delicious. Please bring the Haddock back though. Biscuits and Cornbread delicious. Never have to wait long for table if we wait.“

“Do not walk away if you see a line to get in. The service is fast and the food is excellent! I definitely recommend having lunch there.“

“Highly recommend, this is our go to restaurant for breakfast. Biscuits and gravy are to die for the, lemon dream waffle also fantastic.“

“My daughter and I stopped in here for a girls night dinner. We ordered several items off of the small plates section and the food was phenomenal! Wish I could’ve eaten more. I’m not a beer drinker but cocktails were yummy also. Nice, clean environment and friendly staff! We will be back next trip!“

“Another great meal yesterday at Kitchen 251. We finally had a chance to sit outside and enjoy the scenery and or meal.“

“Super tasty burger. A local favorite“

“We have been enjoying, the snack foods and full meals, besides our drinks during( It's 5 o'clock somewhere classes)... every other Wednesday night. The Alley is a fantastic Host for our Art Classes... and a perfect location for a small party or gathering... TV, Music, own bar tender, plenty of seating... lovely atmosphere, great in-house Beer too!“

“Ordered $100 of food for take out. The mozzarella sticks are $10 for 6 small sticks, would not recommend. The shrimp entree is on the smaller side for the price, the French fries do not travel well.

Take out orders have an automatic gratuity of 10%, which I’ve never seen before. 👎 They originally forgot the cheese sticks and I had to go back in to get them.

We picked up the food at 930pm, so I appreciate it being ready on time and mostly correct. The workers were polite. I’d eat the wings again.

It was bingo night inside, seemed quite lively. Wednesday is all you can eat wings.“

“As always love the food I got at Waffle House - I will say ask what the definition of extra crispy hashbrowns is for them because they were EXTRA CRISPY but were still good. The only thing I would suggest improving is helping customers in the order of which you are asking them questions. I asked for a refill of coffee and there were other customers that were asked after us questions and helped before us. All in all great experience though“

“My kids say this is the one of the best restaurants in Florida. Food is consistently good and after multiple visits we have never had a less than stellar server. Today we had Ann and the kids loved her! Made them custom drinks and was super friendly, personable, and attentive.“

“Fantastic burgers, friendly staff, and very clean. The best freshly made milk shakes!“

“I’m not one to normally write reviews for LongHorn, but our server Ethan was exceptional tonight! He was so attentive, professional, and genuinely kind—it really stood out. I seriously hope LongHorn knows what a gem they have, because I’d totally hire him! Service like that is so rare these days. Great job, Ethan!“

“Erica is a very friendly server. Her professionalism and attention to detail is paramount. She is a great asset to your restaurant. She stands out among her peers because of her infectious personality. Her courteous demeanor and thoughtfulness makes it a pleasure to come to your restaurant. Not just one time but every time we are there. We noticed she is the same with all the patrons. Erica is 5 stars.
Kudos, keep up the good work.“

“1st try at this pick-up thing. Using the ap was easier than expected. We had to get home but had hankering for a good reasonably priced steak. Chili's is the only place in this area. Everywhere else is $$$. We live in a condo. So we can't grill our own. This was a perfect option. Our steaks were cooked to perfection. And we got free chips and salsa on top of it all.“

“Went here with 8 adults and 10 kids on their Karaoke night, food came out fast, the service was friendly and helpful, and they even had the Olympics and the Jags preseason game on. Food was relatively inexpensive and DELICIOUS! I highly recommend this hidden away spot for their effort to bring life to the place!“

“We ate there today food great our waitress Taylor was great.“

“Would like to see a different menu with some lighter options. Our food was greasy and unappealing. They're content to just be a bar that happens to serve some grub; not sure that will satisfy the locals.“

“Great place to work as well“

“Nice way to keep going at 5:00am“