21 Best American Restaurants in Saint Simons Island

GEORGIA SEA GRILL Seafood • $$
407 Mallery St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Coconut Chocolate Chip Pie
Crab Stuffed Hushpuppies
Herb Crusted Lamb Racks
Bacon Poached Salmon
Seared Scallops
Key Lime Tart
Shrimp & Grits
Crab Beignets
Key Lime Pie

“You must go to Georgia Sea Grill if you're on St. Simon Island! The food is farm-to-table, the meal recipes are unique, and the customer service was phenomenal! I ordered market flounder with one of the side combos and the food was excellent. They even gave me a free dessert and card for my birthday. Shoutout to Landon and the entire staff!“

4.7 Superb546 Reviews
Barrier Island Brewing Brewpubs • $$
1226 Ocean Blvd STE 1, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Pretzel Charcuterie Board
Beignets with 3 Dipping Sauces
Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet
Chicken Caprese Sandwich
Barrier Island Beignets
Pub Burger with Fries
Potato Chip Skillet
Brussels Sprouts
Pineapple Express
Chicken Fingers

“We loved this place! Stayed here for a long weekend and went here everyday. The pretzel charcuterie board was super yummy and all the drinks were great! I didn’t take a picture of it but the skillet cookie dessert was my fav!? the service was very good too I definitely recommend this “

4.7 Superb129 Reviews
The Half Shell SSI Seafood • $$
504 Beachview Dr, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Mandarin Orange and Strawberry Salad
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Green Beans Wrapped in Bacon
Peel and Eat Georgia Shrimp
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Georgia Shrimp Ceviche
BBQ Shrimp and Grits
Open-Face Tuna Tacos
Steamed Oysters
Blue Crab Cakes

“Our second visit and it was great both times. I had the special--Grouper crusted crab and it was delicious. I had gotten a tossed salad that I sent back because it was wilted and rusty. The chef came out and apologized, removing the charge. My husband a Spinach salad with the crab cake that was tasty. We return again. Great and friendly service, cute place to eat“

4.6 Superb153 Reviews
Halyards Restaurant American • $$$
55 Cinema Ln, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken with Pimento Cheese
Halyards Shrimp & Grits
Georgia Shrimp & Grits
Seared Yellowfin Tuna
Catch of the Day
Brussels Sprouts
Halyards Burger
Creme Brulee
Crab Bisque

“We visited Halyards during a recent family trip and can’t wait to come back. The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the food and drinks were superb! We had a party of six and the variety available on the menu guaranteed that something appealed to everyone. The food was fresh and delicious!“

4.5 Superb263 Reviews
Palmer's Village Cafe American • $
223 Mallery St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Buddy's Banana Pudding Pancakes
Challah Bread French Toast
Maple Bacon French Toast
Build Your Own Biscuit
Cafe Shrimp & Grits
Biscuits and Gravy
Steak & Eggs
Surf Squared
The Local
Crab Cake

“Super friendly service and delicious food. I had the Vermont Cheddar and Ham Omelet and grits.we shared a Buscuit with Sausage Gravy. My wife ordered the Challah Bread French Toast. Everything was well prepared and delicious. The Sausage Gravy was so good with lots of chunks of sausage. Great little find right in the village.“

4.5 Superb142 Reviews
Barbara Jean's Southern • $
214 Mallery St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fried Steak
The Chocolate Stuff
Shrimp and Grits
Squash Casserole
Mashed Potatoes
Coconut Shrimp
She Crab Soup
Crab Cake
Dirty Rice
Cornbread

“We were able to get a seat immediately. Our server was pleasant. I ordered the shrimp and grits, dirty rice, and turnips which was delicious. My friend ordered the country fried steak, red beans and rice, and squash casserole. He said the steak was kind of salty, but everything else was good. I would recommend and visit again when in the area.“

4.4 Superb169 Reviews
Palm Coast American • $$
318 Mallery St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Wrap w Pasta Salad
Vanilla Cinnamon French Toast
Belgian Buttermilk Waffle
Palm Coast Granola Bowl
English Breakfast
Chicken Salad
Bagel & Lox
The Cubano

“Palm Coast is a quaint little coffeehouse & cafe / bakery. Serves breakfast and lunch and with beer and wine selections. The indoor seating is tight but the outdoor seating offers a bit more room. Breakfast was average however the bakery items looked very temping. Servers were stretched, slow, and appeared new to the service industry. We were seated promptly a little before 9am but there was a line when we left.“

4.4 Superb103 Reviews
Certified Burgers and Beverage American • $
44 Midway Sq, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

American Burger with Grilled Onions and Tater Tots
Chickpea Fritters
Pimento Cheese
Boiled Peanuts
Buffalo Tots
Fungi Town
Sandwich
Cold

“I really enjoyed eating here. The American cheeseburger was cooked the way I asked and the tots are also really good. My wife got the cheese tots and I got the buffalo tots and I ended up liking hers more because the bleu cheese dressing did end up getting the tots on the bottom kind of soggy after a while. Would absolutely come here again.“

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Cafe Frederica American • $
110 Sylvan Blvd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Ham and Cheese Omelette with a Side of Corned Beef Hash
Blueberry Stuffed French Toast
Blueberry Pancakes
Crab Cake Benedict
Cinnamon Roll
Eggs Benedict
Smoked Salmon
Grits

“Away from the island tourist area we noted that many were local 'regulars'. We waited 30 minutes to get a breakfast seating but was worth it. Really good food and service. Price is rated $ but with a few extras my bill is $60.00 for 3 adults. The seating is limited but they move customers in and out efficiently w/o feeling rushed.“

4.3 Superb80 Reviews
Hot Dog Alley American • $
533 Ocean Blvd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Grilled American Cheese Sandwich
Potato Salad
Hot Dog Combo
Sandwiches

“Great place to grab lunch on the island. Steady line of folks ordering mostly to go. They do have a few tables to eat at. I got the jumbo dog with kraut, ketchup, mustard, and onions. My wife got a regular dog with chili, cheese, onion and mayo. We tried to order the deviled eggs but they were out this day. Ended up getting pasta and potato salad. Both were very good. Had perfectly brewed sweet tea. Glad we finally ate lunch here.“

4.6 Superb21 Reviews
Mullet Bay Restaurant Seafood • $
512 Ocean Blvd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Mahi Reuben
Coconut Shrimp Tacos
Fried Pickle Basket
Fried Shrimp Basket
Grouper Fingers
Shrimp PO Boy
Clam Strips
Deep Fried
Burger
Salads

“We were in town for a conference. My husband had a few drinks and he said they were good☺️. Everyone was so nice and friendly, our waiter was the best. The food was good, hot, big portions and the dessert was okay ( ice milk instead of ice cream).“

4.2 Good115 Reviews

12
Zuzu's

Zuzu's American • $
119 Mallery St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Salad
Superman
Burger

“This was absolutely wonderful food! It was fresh an made to order. Very hot when served. Definitely recommend this restaurant. I had hot dog an sweet potato fries, husband had 007 Burger which you could tell the burger was hand pattied. The food is amazing! Service was great. The chili on the hotdog was delicious.“

4.2 Good56 Reviews
Brogen's South American • $$
200 Pier Aly, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Salad with Fried Chicken Breast
The Blue Ribbon Reuben
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Fried Green Tomatoes
Plantation Salad
Fried Mushrooms
Chicken Fingers
Zucchini Fries
Turkey Reuben
Shrimp PO Boy

“Great place! Peyton was our server, and no shortage of smiles or attention with her! Food was fresh and great tasting. And all the staff seemed to work very well together! Also, the bartender here can make a great "anything ", and we thank him! We will definitely be back!“

4.1 Good93 Reviews
Frederica House Seafood • $$
3611 Frederica Rd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Salmon Wit Mango Sauce
Shrimp and Scallops Pasta
Crab Cake and Shrimp
Ground Beef Steak
Catch of the Day
Shrimp an Grits
Hamburger Steak
Fried Scallops
Seafood Gumbo
Garlic Shrimp

“This restaurant is a quiet place that has absolutely delicious food. I ordered surf and turf and which they were able to accommodate instead of crab legs I was able to get scallops in which I got more than three, which was outstanding. Highly recommended if you are in St. Simons Island and you are looking for seafood . Space is limited on seating though.“

4 Good52 Reviews
Brogen's North American • $
3600 Frederica Rd STE 1, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Gouda Burger with Sweet Potato Fries
Cheeseburger and Slaw
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Salad with Chichen
Fried Pickle Chips
Chicken Sandwich
Hamburger Salad
Teriyaki Wings
Penne Pasta
Chef Salad

“Great hamburgers and delicious sandwiches. The atmosphere is loud and rowdy. Definitely not a kid’s place. We went expecting a restaurant vibe and it was much more of a sports bar. Our waitress was very nice and the restrooms were clean and roomy.“

4 Good52 Reviews
Waffle House Breakfast • $
2210 Demere Rd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Hashbrowns Scattered Smothered & Covered
2 Country Ham Biscuits
Hashbrown Bowl
Classic Waffle
Scrambled Eggs
Steak

“Staff was nice, there was only two people, the cook Thomas & the waitress.The food was excellent. (Both checked on the quality of our meals.) Thomas did a great job.They need a dedicated cleaning person, since the people who handles our food shouldn't be cleaning the floors. The whole place needs a good professional cleaning.“

3.8 Good37 Reviews
Gnat's Landing American • $
310 Redfern Village, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Fried Green Tomatoes
Vidalia Onion Pie
Blackened Redfish
Chicken Fingers
Cuban Sandwich
Grilled Veggies
Fish Sandwich
Fried Pickles
Chicken Wings
Fried Shrimp

“Had the grilled chicken sandwich with sweet potato fries. Was one of the best sandwiches I've had and they are dog friendly. Our dog sat on the booth with us outside. The lemonade was yummy and the staff were really friendly. We will be returning to this restaurant to eat again.“

3.8 Good103 Reviews
Catch 228 Bar & Grill • $$
228 Redfern Village # 100, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Oysters Rockefeller
Steamed Oysters
Steamed Shrimp
Shrimp & Grits
Fish and Chips
Seaweed Salad
Hush Puppies
House Salad
Crab Soup

“Me and my sister are dinner there. Got the fried shrimp. Was delicious. Got banana pudding for dessert was so good. Atmosphere was great. Service was great. Food was hot and great. Highly recommend this placeVegetarian options: A lot to offerParking: Shopping center plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Great“

3.7 Good77 Reviews
Sago at Sea Palms American • $$
515 N Windward Dr, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Steak Accompaniments
Smoked Gouda Grits
Key Lime Pie
Fries

“I have now had several excellent experiences at Safo with Reshada as our server. Anyone needing amazing service , especially for large groups, need look no further than Sago, especially if you call ahead and request Reshada. Reshada is a professional server through and through. She seems to inspire excellence from the rest of the staff as well, always appearing the instant you remember something you needed. Thank you for such a pleasant dining experience, Sago and Reshada!“

3.6 Good74 Reviews
ECHO St. Simons Seafood • $$
101 Downing St, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Wild Georgia Shrimp Tacos
Artisanal Cheese Board
Classic Eggs Benedict
The King and Prince
Roasted Vegetables
Hummus with Pita
Shrimp and Grits
Truffle Fries
Echo Burger
Wedge Salad

“Breakfast was amazing! Seafood omelette was loaded with crab and shrimp, Island Breakfast Scramble was full of flavor particularly the biscuit and sausage gravy, and the grits were the best we’ve ever had. Our server was sweet and perfectly attentive. And you can’t beat the view of the beach!“

3.8 Good253 Reviews
Bennie's Red Barn American • $$
5514 Frederica Rd, St Simons Island

Customers` Favorites

Peach Cobbler
Broiled Shrimp
Fried Oysters
Fried Chicken
Key Lime Pie
Baked Potato
Fried Shrimp
Onion Rings
House Salad
Lamb Chops

“I love the casual atmosphere. Bennies is an old barn with a huge fireplace. They recently discontinued Sunday brunch which in addition to Southern cooking included prime rib. I like how they will put a too rare piece on the griddle until it's perfect. Great place with wonderful people.Parking: Might avoid a wet day. The parking lot is not paved and walking in the mud is unavoidable.“

3.6 Good153 Reviews
Loading...
map Map