“We visited Halyards during a recent family trip and can’t wait to come back. The staff was friendly, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the food and drinks were superb! We had a party of six and the variety available on the menu guaranteed that something appealed to everyone. The food was fresh and delicious!“
“Our second visit and it was great both times. I had the special--Grouper crusted crab and it was delicious. I had gotten a tossed salad that I sent back because it was wilted and rusty. The chef came out and apologized, removing the charge. My husband a Spinach salad with the crab cake that was tasty. We return again. Great and friendly service, cute place to eat“
“Dyna.iye calamari, and shrimp. Service was immediate, and thoughtful. Roland answered our questions before we asked them, and made sure we didn't forget about the free soft serve that comes with every meal.Don't miss this place when you're on the island.“
“Love this place. Consistently great food great service and wonderful atmosphere. Only downside is how popular it is and since they don't take reservations you often have have a long wait... But if you're not in a hurry it's a great opportunity to grab a cocktail and sit outside and take in the scenic views of the marsh and the beautiful sunsets“
“Good wine selection, appetizers were delicious. Entrees were very good. We were seated next to the servers station and the kitchen. It was a bit busy and nosiy and not as relaxing as we would have liked. Maybe our server was having a bad day, a bit short and acted like we may not be worth the time. We had to ask for bread and it seemed an imposition. I would definitely go back because I did enjoy the food.“
“LOVED the food, the price, the customer service! I’m currently dairy-free and they were accommodating and understanding. My family enjoyed the fried chicken, mac & cheese, french fries, corn on the cob & sweet tea. 10/10 would recommend! Thanks again for taking care of us.“
“We were able to get a seat immediately. Our server was pleasant. I ordered the shrimp and grits, dirty rice, and turnips which was delicious. My friend ordered the country fried steak, red beans and rice, and squash casserole. He said the steak was kind of salty, but everything else was good. I would recommend and visit again when in the area.“
“Great service! Everyone is very welcoming and proud of their establishment. The seafood is one of the FRESHEST I’ve seen in the coast southeast region! Great price point: appetizers under 18, market price for red snapper 22 (comes with a side dish, a bread loaf and salad)! This will be a new regular visit for us.“
“We were in town for a conference. My husband had a few drinks and he said they were good☺️. Everyone was so nice and friendly, our waiter was the best. The food was good, hot, big portions and the dessert was okay ( ice milk instead of ice cream).“
“We celebrated our seventh anniversary here on November 12th and had a wonderful evening. Several friends recommended this restaurant to us and it was great! We started with the shrimp dip appetizer. I ordered the shrimp and grits. My wife ordered the Shrimp Creole. Both were flavorful and served piping hot! The Creole dish had just the right amount of spice from its Andouille sausage. The grits were cheesy and mixed with grilled tomatoes and blackened shrimp for a filling dish. We tried a sample of the crab soup and will definitely order it next visit. We ended a perfect evening by sharing a piece of their homemade key lime pie. Finally, kudos to our great server and the manager for making us feel welcome.“
“We had the great pleasure of venturing forth into this little piece of heaven last weekend. My sister and I met two long-term customers who guided us to our order, which was PERFECTION! Prepared shrimp, homemade cocktail sauce, crab dip - are you kidding me? SO DELICIOUS! We're coming back to SSI this weekend and you can guess my first stop? St. Simons Seafood. It is truly out of this world. I'm excited to get the crab cakes this time. We were told that they're "out of this world". So grateful for all of the great reviews that prodded us to this magnificent place and the precious customers who guided us perfectly. What a jewel of an establishment. Cannot wait for Friday!!!“
“My favorite meal on the island and one I look forward to with every visit. Get the lobster nachos, the blackened redfish, and my personal favorite, the handmade lobster and crab ravioli. It is life changing! Oh and the key lime pie is pretty tasty too!“
“Wonderful food, well presented. We started with a Brussel Sprout salad which was light and tasty. Followed by a tasty and spicy octopus appetizer which was superb. Quite a delightful. My wife had Short Rib which she said was the best she had even eaten. I had the baked fish special,outstanding. Spicy with an East Asian feel. Having lived in the NYC area for 50 years I know great food and Dorothy's could compete with the best Can't wait to return!!“
“They did a great job with the space, the back deck has relaxing view. The food was good but not spectacular. We had two varieties for raw oysters which were good. I had blackened mahi over a Creole style risotto. The fish was overcooked, the risotto was delicious. One of the people in my party ordered a filet and I am 99% sure she received an over cooked sirloin. Our server was all business and didn't bring much personality to our dinner experience. I would go back for a 2nd visit. It would not be my top pick when I have limited time on the island. I would recommend people check it out and form their own opinion.“
“This restaurant is a quiet place that has absolutely delicious food. I ordered surf and turf and which they were able to accommodate instead of crab legs I was able to get scallops in which I got more than three, which was outstanding. Highly recommended if you are in St. Simons Island and you are looking for seafood . Space is limited on seating though.“
“You must go to Georgia Sea Grill if you're on St. Simon Island! The food is farm-to-table, the meal recipes are unique, and the customer service was phenomenal! I ordered market flounder with one of the side combos and the food was excellent. They even gave me a free dessert and card for my birthday. Shoutout to Landon and the entire staff!“