50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sugar Hill

“Great people! Food and staff! So happy I found this Buffalo Gem!“

“This place is amazing! Jose went above and beyond when I called to ask questions about having a friends birthday here. So kind and though he told me he couldn’t make reservations necessarily, when we walked in there was a reserved table. He made delectable birthday cannolis and delivered out to our table! The food was amazing from the garlic knots to the pizza to the cannolis. The staff was so kind and they let us stay and talk literally until closing time. This was our first time there and we will definitely go back! Highly recommend for great food and outstanding service!!“

“Update:
I’ve visited this location twice since my last review, with the most recent visit on 11/17/25, and both orders were excellent. I’m fortunate to have a Pizza Hut so close that consistently provides great food.

My wife and I have ordered from this location a few times over the past month or so. The food is always hot and fresh. Plus, it tastes good too. The staff is courteous, and the location is clean. I'm thankful to have a Pizza Hut so close to my house, and the food tastes good.“

“We had a delivery go bad about a month ago, It happens. But, boy did they make up for it. The professional on the other side of the phone then and tonight made sure our needs and credit was met. Not to mention the pizza was loaded and hot! We highly recommend our Sugar Hill Marco’s PIZZA.“

“5 stars!!!!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I have to share! Today is our niece’s 11th birthday and we can’t be there in person☹️ I’ve been racking my brain and stressing over how on earth we can make her day special all the way to GA during a viral outbreak with everything being closed or having restrictions😩 I’ve been quoted extremely high delivery fees over the past few days from local businesses to corporate companies.... 🤯 Saying I was over it is an understatement 😑 but as any Aunt I will come through!💪🏻 Then I had an idea and got creative🧐 I called Papa Johns and took a shot in the dark to see if they could help make our niece’s day and success!!!! WOW!! 🤩🥳 I only requested the number 11 (actually I lied, to not be a pain in the behind I didn’t even say eleven, I said “could you put two lines down the pizza, she’s eleven today” all because I didn’t want to be pushy...ugh nice educated statement right ?!🤦🏼‍♀️) in pepperoni but they took the extra mile with presentation, writing on the box and note🥰 How sweet !!!❤️ How special!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ This is more than a business deal, this is an act of kindness, a true moment in humanity that states we are ALL in this together and we can help each other pull through. Thank you Papa Johns for truly making our niece not only smile but making her 11th birthday memorable.“

“this is the best authentic neapolitan pizza anywhere around! The staff is amazing and very welcoming and always available to answer questions! Love it!“

“Great Pizza, by the slice, the bottom wasn't as crisp as I like it but the crust, tasted fantastic. Got a slice of cheese and Pepperoni and a Mr Pipp $12 with tip. Greeted as soon as I walked in and employee was friendly and helpful. Overall all great vist and food, I will come back.“

“We really enjoyed the pizza. Our first time here, and we ordered the Supreme. We also tried the crème brûlée for dessert - very good. Service was also great. Our server was Michael. We will be back!“

“Based on trying takeout, sit-down, and delivery service recently, I’m impressed with the consistency of the pizza. I’ve tried a total of four flavors and they’re all great. The triple threat is a unique mix of pepperoni—incredible unless you hate pepperoni. Salads also are large and surprisingly fresh.“

“Had the slicey bread for lunch today, soooo good with the garlic butter sauce too. Will be back for sure! Both the food and customer service were great, and they even gave my pup some treats on the outside patio❤️🍕🐕‍🦺“

“A lovely restaurant run by a lovely family. Great tasting food, excellent service and a chill ambience. A great friend introduced me to this gem and I will definitely return very soon.“

“Just had the new burger. It was delicious. The bun was made in house. Perfect burger“

“Such a good slice of pie! A must-stop when we are near Duluth!“

“Save your money….. conveyor belt oven on pre-made crust, flash frozen sausage like dominos. We were so hoping to have another option for a real NY style pizza. The place is real nice and the staff were all attentive. While eating our pie, the wife and I were discussing the appearance and taste when one of the managers visited the table. It was our first visit and I complemented them on the staff and atmosphere. While chatting, I asked about their ovens. I mentioned that I had been in the pizza business in the past and I recognized that the crust had not been cooked on a hot stone/pizza oven. The manager said yea we use the conveyor chain ovens to keep up with the volume. We then discussed the sausage that was revealed to be flash frozen. Upon further observance and looking at other pies coming out, it appeared that the crust may be pre made as well. We notice no bubbles or irregularities the are usually found while doing hand tossed. Conclusion. Atmosphere and staff are great, but the pies? If you want an inexpensive pie with frozen inexpensive ingredients settle for the dominos pizza and save yourself a good bit of money.“

“Christy catered our wedding reception and words cannot describe how satisfied we are! We told her the style of our wedding and she created a menu based on the price range we wanted and everybody loved it. The desserts were delicious as well and she did a great job with our cake too.“

“Everything we tried was DELICIOUS 👌 Definitely recommend! Vibe was nice, loud music, and the DJ was 🔥“

“Wings and more Wings!😎“

“waitress very efficient and pleasant. Food very good. They serve cauliflower crust pizza. yummy“

“I’ve been going to Pizza Di Folco for 25 years, and they’ve never let me down. This is a true New York–Italian, family-run spot — the kind you don’t come across often anymore.

I was first hooked on their Strombolis and Calzones — they’re huge, loaded with fresh ingredients, and still my go-to for lunch or dinner. The New York–style pizzas are magnificent, and they also bake killer stuffed pies, pastas, subs, and even fresh cannolis. Honestly, they offer the menu of a full-service Italian restaurant, just without the “fancy restaurant” prices.

It’s a humble, cozy space, but don’t let that fool you — the food is the real deal. If you’re craving authentic Italian pizza or the best calzones and strombolis around, this is the place. After 25 years of loyalty, I can gladly say: you won’t be disappointed.“

“Very good pizza's [Original] Very good pizza's“

“Always the absolute best service from our girl Kiara:)“

“we have been here twice and it has been excellent both times. servers are friendly, food is hot and delicious. restaurant is super clean. great job, mellow mushroom!“

“Our go to neighborhood pizzeria. We love the margarita pizza. Delicious! Staff is warm and friendly.“

“Honestly one of the more close to authentic Sicilian pies Ive had. Decent amount of sauce, but not drowning. The cheese pulls beautifully. The dough is the star though. Airy, firm and with a bottom so crisp that when you handle it you can hear it crunch like glass. The crust was snappy and firm. Everything about it exceeded expectations. Workers were also friendly. Get the garlic bread or the knots. You won't be disappointed.“

“We were in town visiting friends and got a gluten free pizza from here and would 100% recommend! My son has celiac disease and when I called ahead of time to ask how the pizza was prepared the woman on the phone was very helpful. They cannot guarantee no cross contamination but explained they would make it in the back separate from where other pizzas are prepared using ingredients that are separate from the ones they use on their main line. It’s cooked in a separate metal pan, glove change/washed hands, etc. She verified the toppings we wanted were all gluten free. I felt comfortable with these precautions and the pizza was delicious. Bbq Chicken Pizza w/o onions and cilantro. 💕“

“Love Marie's deli! The meatball subs, pizzas and all the salads are delicious! We visit every time we are in the area!“

“I just ate the best take out/delivery pizza in the world. it had a perfectly cooked thick crust and way more toppings than I expected. great job Marco's“

“I had such an amazing experience with Murray’s in a Hurry! Barbara was absolutely phenomenal — her customer service and attention to detail were truly next level. She handled our catering with so much care, and the personalized note she included was the sweetest touch.

The food itself exceeded every expectation — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. Our whole group loved it.

Overall, I couldn’t be happier. Murray’s in a Hurry has definitely earned a repeat customer!“

“This has been our Johnny’s for over 20 years. They know us by name and their food is great. Can’t say enough good things.“

“Went here for the first time on 10/15/25, food was great and pricing was reasonable and definitely cheaper then the competitors around my area. The young man working behind the counter was extremely nice and pleasant. Also low key love that they don't force you to tip, there's not even an option to do so lol. I liked it so much that I ordered some more to go to bring back to my family. Definitely will be back if I'm ever in the area.“

“We love this place! The pizza is the real deal. Giuseppi knows his sauce and his Margarita pizza is the best I’ve had since I left NY. Mile grazzi Guiseppi! 🍕“

“My family had a wonderful experience at Mellow Mushroom in Cumming. Our server, Ian, was delightful and efficient. We typically order a large pie with sausage, feta and Mellow Mushroom’s pesto swirl, but Ian recommended pepperoni,
as his favorite combination. So, we tried it and Ian’s suggestion added a next layer of spice. He made our experience even better. Just want to say, “Thanks Ian! You made it worth spending Friday night at Mellow Mushroom.”“

“Hunter and staff were awesome! Excellent food fresh & hot pizza and chicken parmigiana)and service this past week. Highly recommend stopping by and enjoy!“

“Riverside special pizza is our favorite ever!“

“Jocelyn our server and Yuri who prepared my carbonara pasta with blackened scallops were excellent! I recommend the pizza, penne ala vodka and lasagna! We have been coming for 9 years and have never had a bad meal! Their prices are awesome! Thank you all so much for your amazing customer service ,you all truly rock five million stars!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The eggplant on pizza is incredible!“

“My family and I visit this pizza place on a weekly basis, and for good reason. Not only is their food consistently delicious, but their kindness and customer service go far beyond anything I’ve experienced elsewhere. My son, who is on the spectrum and very particular about what he eats, absolutely loves their pizza. There was one day when my son suddenly stopped eating the pizza (totally normal for him), so I called with a question. The staff was incredibly patient, kind, and reassuring. We mainly utilize their drive thru, and for a drive thru, their customer service feels truly personal. Can’t recommend this place enough!“

“I had a great experience at this Pizza Hut and felt it was definitely worth leaving a five-star review. The food was hot, fresh, and exactly what you want when you’re craving pizza. The crust was perfectly baked, the cheese was melted just right, and the toppings were generous. What really stood out, though, was the customer service. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and made sure my order was correct and ready on time. The restaurant itself was clean and well organized, which always makes the experience better. Whether you’re picking up, or ordering for delivery, this location clearly cares about quality and customer satisfaction. It’s reliable, affordable, and consistently good. I’ll definitely be coming back and would recommend this Pizza Hut to anyone looking for a solid meal and great service.“

“Rice n' Pie impressed us with flavorful dishes, quick service, and a cozy vibe. Definitely worth a visit“

“Absolutely love this location! The food is always amazing, the atmosphere is great, and the staff is always attentive and friendly! Amazing customer service! We will be back with family and friends!“

“If I could rate less that 1 star, I would. The owner of this company doesn't care about anyone but himself. He takes advantage of teens and is rude to his customers. Besides underpaying his employees, he also doesn't pay them at all! He is unapologetic and does not know how to take ownership for his actions. Read your reviews before eating here. Don't waste your money on cardboard, undercooked food and terrible customer service. Do yourself a favor and STAY AWAY.“

“Out of towners. Met with family at Buford location. The customer service is unmatched.“

“Amazing food, great customer service and great atmosphere!!“

“I had been running errands all day and ran out of time to eat before most restaurants close in the area. I love pizza and had the idea to place a take out order before they close at 11p. It was after 10p and I was somewhat apprehensive about the service/quality I’d get picking up an order just prior to close.

I was so impressed when Even, the Manager, greeted me with a genuine and warm welcome. He didn’t appear frustrated that a customer was arriving so close to closing. Also, my husband ordered the pizza wrong and I was so disappointed because I only like thin-n-crispy. Evan kindly offered to make it right in spite of the fact that it was now 10 minutes ‘til close!

Hopefully, the owner of this place appreciates Evan and takes good care of him. We own multiple businesses and from experience can recognize a jewel of a Team Member!

My experience at this location was stellar and made a very LONG and exhausting day end with a perfectly cooked/delicious pizza served with lots of love 💜“

“Best pizza in town.
I’m a regular client.
They made me a pizza after closing.
They fired up the ovens & made me another EXCELLENT pizza.
They are good people, hard working & they give the best service, along with making the BEST Pizza’s around!! I’m thankful they are in our area of town, it was a long day at work & I was hoping to get here before they closed. After mopping they made me a pizza anyway. They’ll always have my business!!“

“There pizza is absolutely amazing and the price is just as reasonable as and the food taste better than pizza hut or papa johns. The toppings are of great proportion and well placed the atmosphere is perfect for family or couples dining. There staff was so polite and helpful. I personally won't order pizza from anywhere else in the future. I recommend them to anyone. Thank you for a great experience and some of the best pizza I've had in a long time.“

“Great food. Just know if you get the Chicago Style Stuffed Crust, it takes a while.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We tried this place with high expectations. I haven’t had a great NY style pizza in this area yet… and we have tried a bunch that advertise as such. I ordered a 14” Neopolitan with extra cheese. The only thing that disappointed us was the fact I didn’t order a bigger pie. When I picked it up it was fresh and piping hot. I sprinkled some Parmesan I saw on the tables and headed for the car. We didn’t make it out of the parking lot before digging in. The sauce is delicious and the cheese on point. The crust is thin and delicious. Perfect foldable goodness. We will be back!“

“The restaurant is very nice for a casual italian meal. The food is great and it has a nice peaceful ambiance. Enjoyed my visit while out of town today. Thank you!“