24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lawrenceville

“Delicious and Fast!! Great customer service as well.“

“Todo muy rico. siempre repito la pizza cubana muy buena y el sandwich cubano. también puedes comprar congelados para la casa todo al estilo cubano. Encontrarás oferta variada de jamón vicky,jamonada,croquetas de varios sabores,chorizos,pasta de bocadito,papa rellena,tamales,yogures entre otros muy sabrosos para nosotros los cubanos. También tienen postres y helados de frutas como mango guayaba y mamey y nuestro helado de mantecado q solo encontrarás aquí.“

“The lasagna my mom has was fantastic as usual and enough for two. The tagliatelle with sausage was ok. I was hoping for a thick sauce with ground sausage. But the sauce was a bit thin and the sausage was big chunks a but overcooked. Must be a fluke this time though because everything else I've eaten here in the past has been killer.“

“Some friends invited us to a celebratory dinner here. Boy what a great idea.
The food was all wonderful. Everything tasted great. The young people working there were gracious, helpful and super friendly and the owner was calmly making all the food while still able to be friendly and happy to accommodate.

So glad we were invited.“

“We had an opportunity to check this place out for the first time and in no way didn't disappoint. We held our monthly restaurant meetup here and it was the best idea! They have a nice semi private area in the back that is perfect for small gatherings and an outdoor space if you desire. The service was stellar from the time I walked in I felt welcomed. The young guy offered a drink and the woman behind the counter was more than accommodating. Then there was the food. Make sure you're hungry! The clasone and Stromboli were huge and from the reaction also delicious. Another person had the lasagna and was also pleased with the size and the taste. I had a small supreme pizza and it as everything I needed...and then some. Thank you Wendy for hosting and providing a great space and amazing food. I can't wait to come back and others felt the same. If you're crazing Italian whether pizza or otherwise, definitely give them a try. We weren't disappointed and I don't you will either!“

“One of my favorite go to meals delivered is a 9” pizza and their awesome salads. Never disappointed.“

“I have been to Cosmo’s on Crogan twice now. Heather took great care of us both times. She is an awesome bartender and the rest of the staff were very attentive as well. The food was great. First time I order off the menu and at Heather’s suggestion I ordered the special the second time. Atmosphere was relaxed and fun. Will definitely be back.“

“We ordered a deep dish pizza the other night and it was amazing. Today I discovered that they have a app and rewards program. It was a no-brainer to download and sign-up. You get a free small cheese thin crust free when you order an appetizer. I added pepperoni to my pizza and got garlic cheesebread as my appetizer. Both were amazing. I wish they had a sit-down restaurant nearby as I am sure the experience would be much with a hot pie being delivered fresh to a table would be much better than a 25-minute ride home to get to dig in. However, I highly recommend pick-up or delivery.“

“Been going to Johnny's New York Style Pizza for quite a while. I love their lunch menu, and their pizzas. The Margherita pizza is excellent!“

“This is hands down my favorite pizza spot since Cooley closed. The service here is horrible. They don't even acknowledge you. They make you wait. While waiting you see your order seating in the warmer. You want this pizza to be hot, fresh out the oven. They need to pay the staff more. The pizza is incredible though. It's hard to stop eating. Do yourself a favor and get the 8 corners vs 12 or look forward to more pounds being added to your weight. Horrible service, excellent pizza, so 4 stars from me. It is expensive though but I'll leave at 4 stars for now. Staff do better. Without customers the employer can't employ. Customers service is everything. We need more of it these days. The customer service needs improvement forsure.“

“Absolutely amazing. I’m from up north, and this pizza is way better than what I can get at home… I live in Lawrenceville now, and this is the only pizza I’ll eat after having tested like 10 other spots. I love that I can also buy slices. This pizza is the best around!“

“Ordered a Large Pepperoni Magnifico, with half pizza sauce and half white sauce. Instead though, the entire pizza has only white sauce and classic pepperoni. This is the 2nd time they messed up my order despite it being tasty. Getting frustrated at messing up my order.“

“Your Pie has great pizza. I love the lineage, and the past is very good as well. People are always very friendly. Highly recommended.“

“Me and my daughter had dinner for a father daughter night . Our first time. We loved the food . Definitely be back with family! Best chicken francese“

“Excellent food and service great for the family or any occasion.“

“The pizza was delicious and customer service was great!!!“

“Great food and great entertainment!!“

“August 30th, 2023-- It was the 20th anniversary of my mom's passing & she liked Papa John's. I ordered on my mobile app five pizzas & a garlic cheese bread in remembrance of her. When I walked into the store I was greeted very warmly by a person who was doing it all (don't know her name but she just came off a shift working at Dunkin' donuts). She told me it would be a few minutes; she was just putting in the garlic bread. Then she printed out my receipt, got my pizzas & garlic bread and offered to help me to my car. Not sure why she was all alone in the store but she was an energetic superstar who had a smile & happy demeanor. I wish there were more people like her working in the workforce. Please give that girl a raise! Oh and the pizzas & garlic bread were good.“

“My experience at this location brought back so many wonderful memories today. Papa John's was my 1st job as a young teen. I placed a online order today for the team the service was beyond exceptional. The pizzas were made in a timely manner. My biggest shout out goes to Rachel who's customer service alone with her vibrant small was outstanding. It's nice to see associates who still takes pride in their job!

Kid-friendliness: N/a

Parking: N/a“

“Good customer service. Limited parking. Call in orders/walk-in to place your order. Can had your food delivered by their own delivery or have it delivered to you through a delivery service such as Uber. Delivery services must go inside to pickup. Clean here. Employees appear to work really well together.“

“This place is honestly underrated. They have good pizza for decent prices. I recommend the deep dish pizza. It has a crispy thick pan crust with a large amount of cheese and sauce and it’s very flavorful. Only eat it if your not in a diet because it’s very greasy and will put you to sleep.

Parking: Space is small and parking is limited“

“Finally, a REAL pizzeria!!!! Best real slice around....“

“We have been wanting to try Gaetano's Kitchen for awhile now and finally had the opportunity. G's didn't disappoint at all. We went with the lasagna, penne catatonic, spaghetti, crab cakes, The Big Paul, shrimp, chicken, and desert. The wife said "Top Notch Cuisine"! I can't argue. If you want great and authentic Italian food to go or delivered to your door, then Gaetano's is a great choice.Would have added pics but it's already half eaten!“