18 Best Seafood Restaurants near Algonquin

“I met former coworkers for dinner here and was my first time dining at this location. Our waitress Alane was fantastic and the manager Rob even stopped by to check on everything. We had appetizers, main courses and desserts. It was all fantastic! Alane made sure waters were filled regularly and other drinks were refilled promptly. The restaurant was busy, but felt cozy at the same time. We were seated in a booth and was absolutely perfect.“

“We celebrated our 27th Anniversary tonight at Port Edward with dinner on the boat. I grew up going here as a kid and had not been there for 30 years. It was as amazing as it has always been and exceeded my expectations with the fantastic service from April and the kindness of a sweet woman who had worked there for 50 years named Cynthia. They went above and beyond to make sure our night was one to never forget and all of the food was delicious. I highly recommend to everyone to come and enjoy this experience for yourself! Thank you to April and Cynthia for a perfect night!“

“I love this place! Hope yall aren’t closing! Went today and it was closed 😭😭“

“Clyde, our server, was delightful and accommodating. Two of us had the Wild-Caught Crunch-Fried Flounder which was amazing, quantity and quality; another had the NEW Sailor's Seafood Boil, which was delicious; others had the Admirals Feast, the Salmon, and the Parmesan Crusted Chicken. All meals were well enjoyed.“

“this place is absolutely by far my favorite seafood place <3 best ceviche and shrimp cocktail I’ve ever had no joke ! I’ve tried a lot of places and this is it right here ! my boyfriend was tired got off work late and was craving the ceviche and they did not have to go out of the way and prepare it when already closed but they did ! Wonderful people my boyfriend and I highly recommend this place ! Great size shrimps too and the flavor is unique of everything !

we had eaten most of our food before I took these photos hehe
La dueña es tan amable y buenisima onda y super Linda ❤️ gracias Maria ❤️“

“Fine food all the way. Great service. Charming decor and art work. Loud bar adjacent. Unfortunate name for a fine restaurant.“

“Great Fox river supper club with a bar next to their dock. We ate this evening and Rachael was our server. What a great server that added to our delicious food! We highly recommend Kiefs and ask for Rachael as your server. You won't be disappointed!“

“on our first visit 4/16/24- tried chicken fajitas and chicken taco meal. Both were delicious and huge portions. Waitress was attentive and friendly. We'll be back!👍“

“No l mejor lugar para venir a disfrutar de grandes voces en las noches de kareoke“

“I am a vegan, so the cook has no issues with non-dairy dishes“

“Last night's dinner was truly wonderful. The amazing food and exceptional staff made our anniversary celebration unforgettable. Special thanks to Armando, Pete, and Brennan for their outstanding service. We will definitely be back.“

“Oh so delicious!! Menu options galore. A true gem!!“

“My daughter took me here for my birthday🥳, as we love fine dining! Well, this place did not disappoint! The ambiance was beautiful, the service was impeccable (kudos April), and saving the absolute best for last, THE FOOD WAS TO DIE FOR!!!! 😍 We had the lobster tail, the lamb chops, stuffed chicken, alcoholic drinks, etc.“

“the best in food to enjoy a nice afternoon“

“Celebrated my birthday there the chocolate bomb was Awesome!!!“

“Come an eat at spankys really good food n nice service n friendly people“

“Awesome menu! They have some amazing Mexican seafood dishes plus all your regular Mexican favorites! Really nice service too. This will be a regular spot for us!“

“great food, good service, can't wait to go back. 👍👍“