26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bethalto

“Drive all the way from Granite City for this pizza, it is THE BEST. They now have online ordering which is great, the only thing I would suggest is to have an online option to order extra cheese.“

“Still making pretty good pizza. Ordered the Ceasars salad but asked if I could leave off the chicken. Employee told me that they do not add meat to their salads. When I got home, salad said chicken Ceasars salad. But he was right, the chicken was in a separate cup from the lettuce. One note, Ken's dressing is very good but needs more anchovies.“

“I rarely write a review, however, I am writing to express my immense satisfaction with your restaurant. All I can say is, WOW. Your establishment truly goes above and beyond to provide exceptional food and service to your customers.

From the moment I stepped in, the atmosphere was incredibly warming and truly set a wonderful vibe. The food was remarkably fresh and incomparable to any other restaurant I've visited. The owners' dedication to providing top-tier service, along with the very attentive servers, made for an outstanding experience. If you want a taste of authentic Neapolitan pizza , this is definitely the place to go.

If anyone is in Edwardsville area , I would confidently argue that this restaurant is hands down the best to visit. Thank you for such a memorable dining experience, we will definitely be back!“

“Pizza and service is always good!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Pictured below is the Gonzo calzone- Salami, dates, spinach, garlic herb cheese, mozzarella, mascarpone-ricotta blend, and garlic oil with garlic butter on the side. My husband looked at me like I was crazy when I read off dates but the slight sweetness against all of that savory is what made it!! We also tried the Fatty B, Meat me in St Louie, Magic Carpet Ride, and the Gyro. They were all amazing but the Gonzo and the Gyro were my favorites. The Magic Carpet Ride is also a must try if you're into mushrooms.“

“I get delivery for pizza & salad, when I go to my sisters in Godfrey. Its delicious, can't wait for them to be closer to me👏👏“

“I was at Peel Wood Fired Pizza in O’Fallon, IL on June 13, 2025. I got a pepperoni pizza, and it was delicious! On top of that, all of the staff that I saw were very professional. I strongly recommend Peel Wood Fired Pizza to anyone who likes pizza.“

“Service is quick and accurate. They are giving a lot less meat sauce for the spaghetti family pack than before though. It is truly not enough.“

“We ordered a pizza online for Super Bowl to be picked up at 4:30 pm but things changed, so we called and asked if they could have it ready at 3:45 and they had it ready ahead of schedule

Kid-friendliness: We ordered a pizza online for Super Bowl to be picked up at 4:30 pm but things changed, so we called and asked if they could have it ready at 3:45 and they had it ready ahead of schedule“

“1-23-2025 @ 4:55 pm the employee with the tan beanie on actually read each line on the receipt and checked to make sure everything was there. I didn't have to ask her for the extra sauce cup that is stored separately from the hot food order!!
The only down side was the sauce cups seemed low. I would rather pay extra and have them filled at least 3/4 full. For now I'll just buy EXTRA EXTRA cups 😆“

“We stopped in today for an early dinner and everything was so lovely! The bread, the salad, the pasta, the atmosphere and the service were all perfection. Kayla was our server and I can't express how wonderful she was. We can't wait to go back!“

“Probably the best shake I have had in my entire life. Brownie Batter ice cream with oreo toppings, I highly recommend. Was there on the 4th of July in the evening, seemed like the family was there working rather than non-family staff, which I appreciate.“

“Place is like a time capsule stuck in the 80s, which is a good thing, been going here since I was a child and now it is my son's favorite pizza as well.. I drive out of my way to go here at least once a year, the atmosphere and pizza are the best.“

“Had the absolute best lunch. The special was delicious. Service was exceptional. We had Missy. Impressed with how friendly and helpful the owner was.“

“Went there for first time recently. Service was great. Quiet and nice environment. The calamari was not good, quite chewy. Otherwise the rest of the food was great !“

“Sage House is a “Top Shelf” stop. Threw a dart at the menu? You can’t go wrong. Why it’s only a 4.8 star rating is beyond me. Must do!“

“Awesome crowd last night at Wiggler's Bar and Grill for our 1st time there! 😊🎶🤘 Special thanks to everyone who came out and to the owners and staff for having us! 🎶☮️ 🙏 This place is definitely a hidden gem with great food and atmosphere, and the staff and patrons are great! 👍💎 We have no further dates scheduled here but hope to return soon! 😉“

“Build your own pies at a reasonable price? Say no more! I cannot get enough of this place. I drive 40 minutes just because I crave it. 11in pizza for less than 14$ with as many toppings I want?! Are you kidding!! It's cooked fresh everytime. Made in front of you like a Subway bar. Super awesome staff, comfy atmosphere and amazinggg za“

“This is a flashback to the 80's!!! Godfather's Pizza was THE BEST back in the day. This tastes exactly like it did back then. And from a gas station of all places. Well done!!! The staff is great to work with! The store was clean, well stocked and a fun experience!“

“I order carryout most times via the mobile app. The online/app specials make it worth while. So far, every time I've come in everyone is very friendly and attentive. The pizza has been made properly, it's fresh (I look at the tracker and arrive on time) & delicious!“

“Good place to eat, order occasionally. It’s frustrating they refuse to deliver to Hartford yet the deliver to south roxana. Then they say it was changed where they will deliver to Hartford if I call. I then called to order on March 14th and was told they aren’t supposed to and the manager said they’ve been doing against the bosses wishes the whole time. Make up your minds. Especially when Pizza Hut is my go to for pizza and I have to get out every time I want some. I don’t have a car at the moment to just get up and go.“

“Food was good WHEN I FINALLY GOT IT, but the service was bad.“

“I stopped eating pizza hut for a long time but since moving to Glen Carbon a couple years ago I finally decided to give this pizza hut a try. We first ordered months ago and have a few time since including today. An my food is always fresh hot and delicious! One of the best pizza huts in the metro area.“

“We had an amazing time with everyone during the grand opening! So happy to have Little Caesars back in our GlenEd Community! 🧡“

“Quiet, clean, modern atmosphere. Family friendly. Great spot to eat at for date night. The staff is accommodating and polite. Really nice and enjoyable restaurant.

Parking: Parking around in front and on side.

Kid-friendliness: Space, clean, and many food selections.“