50 Best Sandwich Shops near Blue Island

“The best thing about this place is its 24hrs. Oh yeah! So when yours not sure whom is open just head to subway, very kind people work there.So stop in ,eat there if you want,but not sure about delivery? So Blueisland and so.chicago eat early or late.“

“Found metal in my food and the staff was Very Rude about it!“

“I cannot say enough great things about Cafe 53! Not only is the service second to none, but they are extremely accommodating to allergies including a gluten allergy and someone in our party who was allergic to garlic. Absolutely 10/10, I wish I could give them more than 5 stars!!“

“good food good service. never any major problems“

“Peppo's came through for our unit when we needed to feed an entire squad! This was our first time with Peppo's and it was great! We definitely will be ordering from here again.“

“Great food and an awesome location!“

“Delish sandwiches 🥪 yes !!“

“Sam runs an amazing place! Super friendly, and the subs are PHENOMENAL!“

“This place is sooooo good. They're very accommodating to exactly how you want your food to be made. I get the Philly Cheesesteak dipped like an Italian Beef and it is sooo good! They're great and so nice anddd they stay open until 12am, super convenient. Worth it!“

“I visited Fitchy's Home of the Hogie yesterday. I purchased the impossible Hogie and fries. The food was absolutely delicious. Much shorter wait time and travel time then going to the Home Of the Hogie in Chicago.“

“Try the BNY..Best Sandwich ever“

“Mr.Sub is the best place to get sandwiches!!
Owner is great and always kind when ordering. Fries are always fresh and the king turkey paired with the free fries, sauce, mayo, turkey, cheese, tomato has a completely different taste to it. Great place and highly recommend!“

“Incredible food and service. If you get in the Midlothian one, Rosemarie is excellent.“

“I have ordered the party sub trays from here and the service and food are excellent! Last weekend I ordered 2 party trays for our 8th grade picnic and the kids and staff loved it! Some have never had Mr. Submarine before and really liked it! They were stuffing pieces in their sweaters to take home!“

“For fans of a messy, delicious sandwich, their famous Jim Shoe sandwich would satisfy. This sandwich was loaded with meat and flavors, making it hard to finish without any parts falling out. The food came out quickly, and the place is cash-only.“

“The buffalo wings were 🔥🔥🔥. I will return.“

“I work late and frequently order from this location on my way home. I order through the app and my sandwich is always perfect and ready by the time I arrive. The overnight guy is truly the best and always welcomes me with a smile. I appreciate being able to get something not greasy late at night and am glad this location is open 24 hours.“

“This establishment has quality food, amazing service with my food coming out in a short time, and amazing customer service as I was greeted with joyful workers who made me feel like I was welcomed. My sandwich was as advertised and delicious with the savory bread. Highly recommend and will be returning!“

“LOVE this place 😍...wish they would open one closer to me, I travel 3 hours to get my fix .. probably should move back to the area lol ..so much cheaper than the S-Way place ..and better, always crowded ..“

“I have been going to this subway for about two years now and I always smile before I even receive my food, 10/10 every time; I’ve never left dissatisfied! And very special shout out to Felicia! I haven’t came here for about 5 months and she remembered me, She really does care about her customers it’s not just an act for the moment I’m sure she enjoys her job as much as I enjoy coming in and if Felicia is reading I’m the little girl you call princess.“

“This restaurant is truly a gem in the south shore community. I go there every Sunday for breakfast after taking a walk. The owner is so incredibly kind and friendly, and they treat you like family. The food is good and reasonably priced but the lemonade is amazing. Highly recommend!“

“Great selection of food and it's all delicious. Reasonable prices and friendly staff and clean.“

“The food is tasty but I was shocked by the quantity of meat in my gyros plate. It was just a gyros sandwich in a container with fries and fixings. Everywhere else I get a gyros plate it has enough meat for 2 or 3 sandwiches.the subs seemed to be lacking meat as well. Again first time getting it there and was just surprised.“

“I ate at this Charleys location for the first time in a while and lemme tell you, this place is amazing!!! Seems like new management because the place is ten times better than when I had it before. I ordered a philly steak cheese fries boneless lemon pepper wings and a strawberry lemonade and everything was ON POINT! The service was great too, the manager i believe his name is Jay was really nice and helpful. I noticed they have milkshakes but i had no room for dessert the food is so filling and worth the money, definently want to try that cookies and cream milkshake next time tho :)

Vegetarian options: They have a grilled veggie sandwich that is delicious!

Parking: plenty of free parking“

“This is now my go to sub place. Super fresh meat and bread. Very clean and the owners are super friendly.“

“I rolled through the drive-up yesterday at 111th & Cicero with my dog in the backseat. When the guy working the window handed me my food, he also passed me a pup-cup and said "for my guy in the backseat", which made my dog very happy. Thanks for that!“

“Everything about this place is great! The food, and service is top notch. The atmosphere is what you would expect for a take out dine in restaurant. I ordered the California Turkey club wrap. Generous amount of ingredients and very fresh. Highly recommend trying from the wide assortment menus!“

“They are awesome. Great traditional old fashion filling sandwiches. And the fries are really good too OH the shakes are the tastiest around. The delivery service is top notch and they are so nice. Tip them well. They are very special people. 4stars.

Parking: Small“

“So excited to find this Pret A Manger in the US!! When will we start seeing them in Texas?! Houston needs one yesterday... 😂 I LOVE the organic and healthier focus. Pret is what Starbucks used to be until they decided $$ was more important than people.... Haven't been to one in years because of the shift to lie quality ingredients. Look forward to seeing Pret all over the US“

“First of all, the staff at this particular location need a raise, Because they actually understand customer service. I went to Subway and had no clue what I wanted to eat, And yet the staff was patient with me did not rush me can allow me to customize my sandwich. The way I wanted to. They had the footlong cookie too, which I wanted to try however, After the cookie went into the oven, I was expecting it to have a crispy exterior like a cookie, but it did not, it felt almost like a footlong piece of cake. Which was the only bad thing about it...“

“Great food and fun at Darla's!“

“Seriously one of the best turkey sandwiches I've had in a long time. The bread was perfect. The oil and seasonings mixed perfectly together with just the right amount of cheese. I will definitely be trying more of these delicious sammies!“

“Omg im being a back typing this but damn that was on another level“

“Muy delicioso lonche me encantan los bagel 🥯 Y un excelente servicio 👍“

“Absolutely amazing experience at Subway! My order was fresh, made perfectly, and exactly how I wanted it. Bhumi was so kind!!!! The bread was soft, the ingredients tasted super fresh, and the staff was friendly and fast. Everything was packaged neatly and tasted great. Definitely one of the best Subway orders I’ve had — I’ll be ordering again!“

“Delicious! Tried the club and dumpling soup.“

“Delicious. Clean and always perfect. Get you some garlic Fries, Holys Way.“

“Under normal circumstances, this location does a great job with the food and service. Please consider that customers should not be allowed to enter the store during standard lunch time and place an order for ten sandwiches. Large and/or catered orders should be forced to order ahead or on an app. The customer that was allowed to order ten sandwiches backed up the store line. He caused an additional twenty minute wait. Three people either walked in the store and immediately walked out or they were in line and left without ordering.“

“The food from this establishment looks to be very tasty and delicious. Also the establishment smells very terrific inside. Furthermore the employer female is a very great customer support. Very fast hard worker and very consistent. In addition I would highly recommend any individual that would want to eat some fast food to calm their appetite at this establishment.“

“Philly's Cheese Steak is Fye“

“Jay at the counter was amazing! We ordered online because there was a line but he made accommodations like mayo and mustard on the bread etc. half tomato on the nachos, as we were in store, and he didn’t make a fuss about us asking to edit the order. The atmosphere gets a 1 star because the people walking in were obnoxious and rude. Definitely would have eaten inside had there not been numerous people in there being rude to the employee. Thanks Jay!!“

“great sandwiches! I always get the "Wiseguy" ! Fast service and perfectly made subs!“

“The Subway Steak Philly was delicious tender steak, melty cheese, and perfectly cooked peppers and onions. Warm, fresh bread tied it all together. Super flavorful and definitely worth ordering!
I always come every day it's worth visiting.“

“Bought a chicken sandwich, made me sick, tore up my stomach. Nothing else to eat that day but their sandwich. Had to be spoiled chicken.“

“This was my first visit to Charlie’s cheesesteaks restaurant. Didn’t know what to order so I ordered a hoagie sandwich mixed with different lunch meats and a Philly steak and cheese. It was delicious. I ate half of one and half of the other. I will be back for more.“

“Recently tired Jersey Mike's Subs and all I can say is OMG!! Delicious!!“

“I had a gyro melt on rye and I’ll definitely get it again. The only thing is one of the fries was rotten, so they need to do a better job of eyeballing them before they drop them in the grease.

Parking: They share the parking lot with Spotless Laundry and SS BBQ & Jerk.“

“I had to share an incredible experience we had at Subway at 14704 Cicero ave in Midlothian recently. As a high school teacher, I brought in a group of my English learner students to practice real-world language skills, and the two sandwich artists working today absolutely blew me away.

From the moment we walked in, Hemil and Akra were patient, encouraging, and genuinely invested in helping my students succeed. Instead of rushing them, they took the time to ask thoughtful questions, gently encourage them to speak louder, and even gave them the space to practice, even when it took a little extra time.

What could have been an overwhelming experience for my students turned into something empowering and joyful, all because of the kindness and understanding that Hemil and Akra showed. They didn’t just make sandwiches, they created a safe, supportive environment where my students felt confident using their voices.

It’s not every day you see that level of care and humanity in a busy setting. I’m so grateful for their warmth and professionalism. They made a lasting impact on my students (and on me). Thank you for going above and beyond! And thank you for the DELICIOUS sandwiches! We will be back 😄“

“After having a challenging experience, I spoke with a beautiful lady named Markia and her coworker Mark.
Markia is heaven sent not only did she take time out of her busy day to accommodate me but she heard me out I spent a lot of money here and my order wasn’t fulfilled but after speaking to her, she turned my experience to 10 stars. Thank you Markia“