23 Best Italian Restaurants near Collinsville

“The service was friendly and efficient. Their portions were very generous and reasonably priced. Everything was delicious.“

“AMAZING place! Love the food & the staff. Always will go back.“

“Had an awesome server today Chelsea! She was friendly, and responsive. She did an amazing job when some extremely unkind patrons were abusive towards her, and disturbed my elderly father. The food was awesome as always. Coming back often!“

“I went there with friends to celebrate my birthday. The food is exceptional as was the service. I think it's my new favorite Italian ristorante!“

“Dined in tonight and had phenomenal service. Food was amazing as well! I could go on and on about how great our waiter was.“

“The food was delicious. We had reservations for later but they were able to accommodate us when we arrived early. Mitch, our server, was very helpful.“

“Went there for first time recently. Service was great. Quiet and nice environment. The calamari was not good, quite chewy. Otherwise the rest of the food was great !“

“We stopped in today for an early dinner and everything was so lovely! The bread, the salad, the pasta, the atmosphere and the service were all perfection. Kayla was our server and I can't express how wonderful she was. We can't wait to go back!“

“Not only do they serve delicious food, but they also have a commendable mission of employing and supporting people with autism. It's heartwarming to see a local business making such a positive impact in the community.

I recently used their catering service for an event, and I couldn't be happier. The food was fantastic, and the service was top-notch. If you're looking for great food and a business that gives back to the community, I highly recommend Pasta Fare!“

“The food and service was beyond excellent! The smothered mushrooms And vegetarian options were on point.“

“LITERALLY SO AMAZING. Top tier atmosphere and the best waitress ive ever had. Even on a super busy night they were fast, responsive, and the food was amazing. It can be a little pricey, but if you look there are some great deals and you get a TON of food with those prices. Couldn’t recommend enough, great place. Also btw if your meal came with breadsticks you can request some to go which is awesome.“

“Over the years, Bella Milano has been a favorite restaurant for me and my wife. We love the food, service and atmosphere. I have also done dozens of business seminars there and utilized their catering. My wife recently celebrated her birthday, and she was craving Bella Milano's Lasagna. Our visit started well as our reservation was on time and we were waited on by a friendly waitress in a timely manner. Our appetizers came out quickly also. However, there was a much longer than normal delay in our entrees coming out. The waitress did stop by to apologize for our wait twice which we appreciated, but the wait was becoming an issue. A gentleman whom we later found out was Tom the owner, stopped by to apologize and then gave us free appetizer cards, comped a portion of our bill and even included desserts. He was very friendly, but more importantly, very sincere in wanting us to leave happy. He let us know that our food would be out in a minute. We were really impressed and it felt great to be appreciated by the owner and his commitment to giving us a great dining experience. Well, Tom came back a minute later and told us "You can't make this up, but when they were taking your lasagna out of the oven it fell on the floor". I can only imagine what was going through his mind as he came back to tell us this news! He said it would take 20+ minutes for another, which really didn't sit well with us at this point. The worst part was that was what my wife really wanted for her birthday dinner. Tom immediately asked my wife if there was anything else he could make for her quickly and at no cost to us, but that he would make a new lasagna for her to take home as well. I simply can't say how impressed we were with Tom's dedication and sincerity to turn a potentially very negative experience into a positive one. There are a lot of restaurants we can go to, and thanks to Tom's efforts, Bella Milano will remain one of our favorites! If you want to go to a restaurant where you know your business is actually appreciated, think Bella Milano's!“

“Everything good , expect the restroom need more attention“

“Stopped in for lunch January 15th 2026 had one of the best experiences. there in a long time! Service was the best it had ever been! Patty was the name of the server which waited my table! She was on top of everything and had things faster than anyone I'd ever had serve us there ! Best service ever..This lady not only needs employee of the month she needs a raise!..Its been a while since Ive seen this kind of service and I love to review those who give their job this kind of service! Great Job Patty!...“

“Great food!! Fast and friendly service!!“

“awesome waitress and very friendly“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Pictured below is the Gonzo calzone- Salami, dates, spinach, garlic herb cheese, mozzarella, mascarpone-ricotta blend, and garlic oil with garlic butter on the side. My husband looked at me like I was crazy when I read off dates but the slight sweetness against all of that savory is what made it!! We also tried the Fatty B, Meat me in St Louie, Magic Carpet Ride, and the Gyro. They were all amazing but the Gonzo and the Gyro were my favorites. The Magic Carpet Ride is also a must try if you're into mushrooms.“

“I get delivery for pizza & salad, when I go to my sisters in Godfrey. Its delicious, can't wait for them to be closer to me👏👏“

“I always order online. I've been getting the Pretty Pizza for the entire 5/6 years I've lived here. maybe in the past year, I've intermittently ordered a 1/2 PP and 1/2 BBQ. Somehow my order didn't come out right today. Is the app glitchy? Staff said the second half wasn't even selected, so THEY chose cheese pizza for me. not really happy. My number was available. Couldn't someone have CALLED me before making this? I'm taking a break from your establishment.“

“Kayla was our server and she had great recommendations since it was our first time. They have several home made salad dressings and the caesar was great! The hand tossed pizzas were good too.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I don’t know what kind of wizardry Marcos Pizza is practicing, but this was the hottest, freshest pizza I’ve ever had delivered in my life. Not “oh it’s still warm” hot. I mean “did this pizza teleport straight from the oven into my hands?” hot. The cheese was still bubbling like it was alive. The crust had that perfect crisp-but-soft situation going on. Every bite tasted like it had just been introduced to heat five seconds ago. I half expected the delivery driver to be wearing oven mitts. 10/10. Will absolutely burn my mouth again. Worth it. 🍕🔥“

“Great service! Great food also!“

“went w pops it’s was gas. all i gotta say, and they got dr pepper win win“