23 Best Italian Restaurants near Collinsville

“The service was friendly and efficient. Their portions were very generous and reasonably priced. Everything was delicious.“

“AMAZING place! Love the food & the staff. Always will go back.“

“To whom ever you are treating this young lady the way you did you. Should all be ashamed of yourselves...today around 1130am. You all deserve a dose of your own medicine. To the owner of this place please know she was not in anyway wrong. Now there threatening bad reviews to try and get her fired. Shame on them.“

“I went there with friends to celebrate my birthday. The food is exceptional as was the service. I think it's my new favorite Italian ristorante!“

“The food was delicious. We had reservations for later but they were able to accommodate us when we arrived early. Mitch, our server, was very helpful.“

“We stopped in today for an early dinner and everything was so lovely! The bread, the salad, the pasta, the atmosphere and the service were all perfection. Kayla was our server and I can't express how wonderful she was. We can't wait to go back!“

“Happened upon this friendly great restaurant in Troy, IL while traveling home from OK to OH. Oh my! What a gem. This was some of the best Italian food we have eaten. Brian got a half a pizza that was full of toppings and much too big to eat. I got the the spaghetti and meatballs. The red sauce was like the Italian mother's made and the meatball was the owner's grandmother's recipe. Holy Meatballs! It was delicious. We will definitely be back on pur way through when we travel. We talked to the owner for quite a while. So friendly, kind and appreciative of our patronage.“

“Everything good , expect the restroom need more attention“

“Went there for first time recently. Service was great. Quiet and nice environment. The calamari was not good, quite chewy. Otherwise the rest of the food was great !“

“Not only do they serve delicious food, but they also have a commendable mission of employing and supporting people with autism. It's heartwarming to see a local business making such a positive impact in the community.

I recently used their catering service for an event, and I couldn't be happier. The food was fantastic, and the service was top-notch. If you're looking for great food and a business that gives back to the community, I highly recommend Pasta Fare!“

“The food and service was beyond excellent! The smothered mushrooms And vegetarian options were on point.“

“I want to give the biggest shout out to are waitress Danielle Duncan for being the most on it waitress I've ever met. her hospitality skills were out of this world.everything that I thought I would need she was always 2 steps ahead of me. she was fast and the most caring warm hearted person. after decompressing from the hoilday weekend meeting her was such a blessing. me my husband and my family come to the Edwardsville location a few times a month and I will be asking for Danielle every single time. people like her deserve a raise!“

“Our waitress seemed like she was too busy to take our order. Did not get a drink refill til we were about to leave even though we asked. Food was great ofcourse. Confusion when we went to pay the bill because 2 families were at the table but its was 5 people 3 and 2. Bill was undeniably mixed and we are best friends we said by the time she LET US help her with fixing it we could be out and about our day, so we left and let it be.“

“Great food!! Fast and friendly service!!“

“awesome waitress and very friendly“

“We had dinner here tonight and it was fantastic! Our server was great and the manager (Brittany) was so kind! We highly recommend this place- Grade A customer service!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Pictured below is the Gonzo calzone- Salami, dates, spinach, garlic herb cheese, mozzarella, mascarpone-ricotta blend, and garlic oil with garlic butter on the side. My husband looked at me like I was crazy when I read off dates but the slight sweetness against all of that savory is what made it!! We also tried the Fatty B, Meat me in St Louie, Magic Carpet Ride, and the Gyro. They were all amazing but the Gonzo and the Gyro were my favorites. The Magic Carpet Ride is also a must try if you're into mushrooms.“

“I get delivery for pizza & salad, when I go to my sisters in Godfrey. Its delicious, can't wait for them to be closer to me👏👏“

“The pizza was delicious, the garlic cheese bread was really good. Loved the fresh garlic on the bread!“

“Great service! Great food also!“

“I always order online. I've been getting the Pretty Pizza for the entire 5/6 years I've lived here. maybe in the past year, I've intermittently ordered a 1/2 PP and 1/2 BBQ. Somehow my order didn't come out right today. Is the app glitchy? Staff said the second half wasn't even selected, so THEY chose cheese pizza for me. not really happy. My number was available. Couldn't someone have CALLED me before making this? I'm taking a break from your establishment.“

“We order from here way more than we should and food is consistently delicious! Cheesy bread is a regular in our house, as well as the buffalo wings. Delivery times insane which is understandable if not enough help, so we tend to DoorDash when we are feaning for Marcos pizza. It literally never disappoints. I did pick up once and the wait was long, but the ladies behind the counter were awesome! The guys working prep and boxing were literally amazing because it was obvious they were slammed but they put extreme care into each order prepared so the wait didn’t bother me. Keep it Marcos at Central Plaza!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The chicken parmesan was kinda of good. I don't understand Italian cuisine in the USA. Tomato sauce with no spices and always the same taste, so I will say, it tasted like any chaine restaurant in the USA. Has for the service, well the waitress was nice, but more clients started to arrive, so she was nervous. We weren't finish and she already gave us the bill. I told her that we were not finished and that we wanted dessert. So, she came back for our desserts, but she didn't take our empty plates on the table. We add to push them in a corner to eat our desserts.“