50 Best Sandwich Shops near Hickory Hills

“Had a great experience at Subway in Hickory Hills! Jay went above and beyond to take care of us. The food was fresh, well-made, and you could tell quality was a priority. I was there with my kids, and he even gave them a cookie on the house — such a kind gesture.

Jay was very friendly, professional, and genuinely welcoming. The restaurant itself was spotless — clean, neat, and no unpleasant smells at all.

Highly recommend this location. Excellent service and great food!“

“Freaky fast and freaky good.“

“I saw the Choula and Lime ad on social media and came into to have a Philly cheesesteak with that flavoring. Jack who was working during the freezing weather conditions let me know it was only used for a wings rub but said he could try to make it as a cheese steak by mixing butter instead! He was very friendly and accommodating, willing to go above and beyond to help me. They were also closing soon and I was going to take my meal to go but he insisted that my partner and i dined in so the food stayed warm. Absolutely made my night because I got exactly what I wanted and it was a delicious cheesesteak!“

“Found metal in my food and the staff was Very Rude about it!“

“The food there is delicious, fresh and well worth the money. I had ordered 5 meals from their and the price really was a wonderful surprise. It was a lot cheaper than I thought it was going to be. The staff there was very professional and the wait for my food was very fast and accurate. Great food, wonderful employees. I will definitely be eating there again real soon. I will take my son with me because he really loved the food.“

“just had dinner at this location, used the restroom and a cockroach came crawling under the door the size of a coin dollar & i have a video of it for those who dont believe me. i will not be coming back my stomach is turned upside down & i feel so sick right now.“

“good food good service. never any major problems“

“This place has pepper/egg sandwiches every day of the week during lent season. 👏👏👏😍😍😍“

“Peppo's came through for our unit when we needed to feed an entire squad! This was our first time with Peppo's and it was great! We definitely will be ordering from here again.“

“Sam runs an amazing place! Super friendly, and the subs are PHENOMENAL!“

“This place is sooooo good. They're very accommodating to exactly how you want your food to be made. I get the Philly Cheesesteak dipped like an Italian Beef and it is sooo good! They're great and so nice anddd they stay open until 12am, super convenient. Worth it!“

“the food is great service is very friendly and the place is clean“

“OMG, my sandwich was so good & so fresh. Love the bread! I went to Jimmy John's a couple of weeks ago & there was exactly 1 slice of turkey on my sandwich. Fontano's had 4 times the amount of meat on my sandwich for the same size sandwich.“

“I visited Fitchy's Home of the Hogie yesterday. I purchased the impossible Hogie and fries. The food was absolutely delicious. Much shorter wait time and travel time then going to the Home Of the Hogie in Chicago.“

“First time and customer service was great. Helped us figure out the process for ordering. It's different,lol. Sandwiches were great, maybe a little smaller piece of bread but they fill it up. We'll go back.“

“Love this place! Every sandwich is delicious! Plz update your website with a better quality menu. You can’t really read anything on it, your website is great besides that. Every time I’ve ordered it’s been a guessing game, but that’s how I know everything is great!“

“Mr.Sub is the best place to get sandwiches!!
Owner is great and always kind when ordering. Fries are always fresh and the king turkey paired with the free fries, sauce, mayo, turkey, cheese, tomato has a completely different taste to it. Great place and highly recommend!“

“The staff at the Homer Glen Jersey Mike's is fantastic! They are always friendly and helpful. They are as fast as they can be. Their business model does mean the food takes a little longer than say, subway, but it is definitely worth the extra 1-2 minutes.“

“I work late and frequently order from this location on my way home. I order through the app and my sandwich is always perfect and ready by the time I arrive. The overnight guy is truly the best and always welcomes me with a smile. I appreciate being able to get something not greasy late at night and am glad this location is open 24 hours.“

“I had to share an incredible experience we had at Subway at 14704 Cicero ave in Midlothian recently. As a high school teacher, I brought in a group of my English learner students to practice real-world language skills, and the two sandwich artists working today absolutely blew me away.

From the moment we walked in, Hemil and Akra were patient, encouraging, and genuinely invested in helping my students succeed. Instead of rushing them, they took the time to ask thoughtful questions, gently encourage them to speak louder, and even gave them the space to practice, even when it took a little extra time.

What could have been an overwhelming experience for my students turned into something empowering and joyful, all because of the kindness and understanding that Hemil and Akra showed. They didn’t just make sandwiches, they created a safe, supportive environment where my students felt confident using their voices.

It’s not every day you see that level of care and humanity in a busy setting. I’m so grateful for their warmth and professionalism. They made a lasting impact on my students (and on me). Thank you for going above and beyond! And thank you for the DELICIOUS sandwiches! We will be back 😄“

“The buffalo wings were 🔥🔥🔥. I will return.“

“This establishment has quality food, amazing service with my food coming out in a short time, and amazing customer service as I was greeted with joyful workers who made me feel like I was welcomed. My sandwich was as advertised and delicious with the savory bread. Highly recommend and will be returning!“

“just had dinner at this location, used the restroom and a cockroach came crawling under the door the size of a coin dollar & i have a video of it for those who dont believe me. i will not be coming back my stomach is turned upside down & i feel so sick right now.“

“LOVE this place 😍...wish they would open one closer to me, I travel 3 hours to get my fix .. probably should move back to the area lol ..so much cheaper than the S-Way place ..and better, always crowded ..“

“To be fair, it was about an hour before closing time. However, the older lady was very sweet and made our food very well and it was delicious. Her coworker on the other hand didn't seem to friendly. We wanted to add to our order and she couldn't even be bothered to stop sweeping to come and complete the transaction until the older lady had already finished making the 1st part of the order. I have worked in hospitality all my life. I know how she felt but if she want customers to return and ensure job security for her, she should be a little more friendly and willing to assist.“

“I won't go to any other sub place!
They are always so generous with their servings. Fresh and great taste.
Michael was super friendly.
Just had an overall happiness about him. It's really great to see happy workers makes you want to go back.
To that location.“

“Sure! I had an amazing experience at Mr. Submarine at 8542 Ogden Ave in Lyons, IL. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm, friendly service that made me feel truly welcomed. The staff was attentive, polite, and eager to make sure I had everything I needed, which really stood out.

I ordered a combo sub and a pizza puff, and I have to say, it was exactly what I needed. The food came out fast and fresh, which was a relief since it was the first thing I had eaten all day. The combo sub was packed with flavor, with perfectly sliced meats, fresh toppings, and just the right amount of seasoning. The bread was soft yet sturdy, holding everything together without getting soggy. The pizza puff was crispy, cheesy, and delicious, adding the perfect touch to my meal.

Not only was the food top-notch, but the overall experience was fantastic. The staff really goes the extra mile to ensure customers leave happy, and that level of service is rare to find these days. I left feeling completely satisfied and already looking forward to my next visit. If you’re in the area and looking for great food, quick service, and a welcoming atmosphere, Mr. Submarine is the place to go!“

“This is now my go to sub place. Super fresh meat and bread. Very clean and the owners are super friendly.“

“Had to change my review after yesterday’s dinner that we got I got the super loop which in my opinion was super dry. They didn’t put the dressing and for the price. They only gave me two slices of meat, one of each ham and roast beef Which I think they forgot the turkey. My fiancé got a double cheeseburger we had bacon each bacon strip was $1.47 but yet it seemed like they just grab one bacon strip and cut it in half instead of giving lots of two whole strips the food used to be good here, but I don’t know for what reason they Started lacking“

“They are awesome. Great traditional old fashion filling sandwiches. And the fries are really good too OH the shakes are the tastiest around. The delivery service is top notch and they are so nice. Tip them well. They are very special people. 4stars.

Parking: Small“

“This Subway is my go-to spot when everything else is closed. The guy on the late shift always hooks it up, super chill, remembers my order, and makes the subs fresh even when it’s close to closing time. Place is clean, quick, and honestly just reliable when you need it most. Appreciate the service every time.“

“Absolutely amazing experience at Subway! My order was fresh, made perfectly, and exactly how I wanted it. Bhumi was so kind!!!! The bread was soft, the ingredients tasted super fresh, and the staff was friendly and fast. Everything was packaged neatly and tasted great. Definitely one of the best Subway orders I’ve had — I’ll be ordering again!“

“Small ma and pa shop. Would love to give them 5stars have been coming here for years. They offer great classics and good food. However, I placed an order today and well it was disappointing. I order a total of two sandwiches somehow that turned into three. Mexican sandwich de asada delicious. Pier sandwich delicious and now an extra Mexican. Fine whatever I already paid. Then my Mexican sandwich is SUPPOSED to come with salsa… look in my bad no SALSA. No se si necesito ordinar en español o que pero el servicio no estaba a 100%. You can enjoy Chicago classics and twist here just double check your order.“

“Usually love it, but put Mayo & mustard on the 8 subs I bought when I specifically said NO.... TOO far away to return 😣😢😠“

“Philly's Cheese Steak is Fye“

“Always GREAT FOOD ! They were SUPER BUSY , The women running the register was GREAT !!! SHE WAS HAPPY , ACCURATE, HONEST AND SHOULD BE APPRECIATED for her hard work ! Its NOT often you get GREAT customer service these days she was an absolute 5 STAR !“

“Always fresh, always delicious! The subs here are packed with flavor & quality ingredients. The bread is soft & fresh, & they’re generous with the toppings. Definitely my go-to spot when I’m craving a good sandwich. I got my coworkers hooked on it & now my family too!“

“Asked for "everything except no mayo" on my sandwich. Poor lady started by putting mayo on it (probably out of habit since most folks want mayo) before realizing her mistake - even before I did. She apologized profusely and had them remake me a sandwich. It was literally the most minor inconvenience in the world that cost me a whopping 2 minutes of added wait time, but they still snuck a free chocolate chip cookie in my bag. Completely unnecessary but much appreciated! Yay for people who actually care about their customers (even though, again, in this case, it barely even qualified as an inconvenience to me, lol). Also the sandwich was delicious!“

“I love ordering great food from this specific Jimmy Johns because the ingredients taste so fresh and I have always had excellent customer service experiences there. The blonde tall guy with blue eyes who works the front counter has always been hella nice to me ever since i first stepped foot in there, and he's not too bad on the eyes as well, which is a plus ;) I wouldnt mind taking him for a ride on my Ninja 400 some time and maybe taking a trip to another Jimmy Johns store for food! X,D He likes my hat too! :3“

“The Subway Steak Philly was delicious tender steak, melty cheese, and perfectly cooked peppers and onions. Warm, fresh bread tied it all together. Super flavorful and definitely worth ordering!
I always come every day it's worth visiting.“

“First time here and the food was fantastic! I highly recommend the gyros my fiance had a sub and it seemed to be a popular choice cuz we heard like 3 other people order it. It was also very clean and all around nice restaurant we will be going back soon“

“This was my first visit to Charlie’s cheesesteaks restaurant. Didn’t know what to order so I ordered a hoagie sandwich mixed with different lunch meats and a Philly steak and cheese. It was delicious. I ate half of one and half of the other. I will be back for more.“

“Bought a chicken sandwich, made me sick, tore up my stomach. Nothing else to eat that day but their sandwich. Had to be spoiled chicken.“

“I order the largest Philly cheese steak with everything on it. My opinion of it was a solid 4.0/5, the meat lacked flavor imo, peppers weren't cooked long enough. However the sandwich overall was pretty tasty, far from the best, but for a nice change from the normal fast foods it hit nicely. Can't really judge anything else but the food since it's inside of Walmart. Employees were fine, and was quite clean. I'd recommend at least giving it a try if your already in Walmart, but probably not worth going into Walmart just for this food.“

“Recently tired Jersey Mike's Subs and all I can say is OMG!! Delicious!!“

“I order lunch from here often and I just wanted to take the time to say I appreciate how hard they make sure to get me my order in a timely manner each and every time. Even when they're short on delivery drivers and Uber cancels. Thank you!“

“Been here a few times since they opened. Staff is always friendly and the restaurant is generally clean and well kept. Haven't been disappointed with the quality of the sandwiches either, ingredients taste fresh and they don't skimp on toppings. I think my only complaint is that they are frequently out of certain kinds of cookies although that may be because I typically go here for a late-ish lunch.“

“Stopped for lunch, I had the bacon mac n cheese it was very good! The service was fine. The place was a mess, though! All the tables had dishes from the last people there and were unwashed.The thing is, they weren't busy!Other than that, the food was good.“

“Food is delicious Excellent service Mt Prospect Illinois“

“Clean, super hygienic, and friendly. What else do you need from a place to eat at? The employee attending me tried best to understand given my disabilities and that was the best part! I would totally skip close by subways to come here!

Parking: Spacious and safe parking

Wheelchair accessibility: as a customer with accessibility, I was treated with kindness and patience by employees.

Dietary restrictions: No cross contamination visible while employees worked at the counter.“