50 Best Italian Restaurants near Maywood

“Really good, cheap. Burgers used to be really good. Last couple of times I ordered the double burger the meat was really dry. I’m not sure what’s going on with that but the Italian beef and the fries are really good for a great price. ?“

“This was my first visit and I was a little overwhelmed. I came for a slice for lunch and was amazed by all the options. Fresh pasta, chicken parm, sandwiches, calzones and so much more all ready to go. I ordered my pizza and there was a cannoli in front of me in the case so I had to get that. While I was waiting for my pizza to be warmed up I admired the Gelato selection and ended up adding on a half pint of key lime pie Gelato. The slice, cannoli and Gelato came to $15. All of the food was amazingly delicious. I'll definitely go back soon to try more.“

“Was in the neighborhood and I stopped by. Italian beef sandwich is amazing. Loaded with beef. Only thing that happened was that I ordered an Italian combo and I got just a regular Italian beef. Giardiniera was not spicy at all and I do like spicy. Otherwise, will probably be back.Parking: There is a parking lot on the side of the building.“

“Made reservations on a Friday night for Saturday. No problem. We were a little early but were seated immediately and were given a choice of table. We starred with cocktails. I had a vodka martini, and she had campari and soda. They were good. We also had the Burrata Capresewith out cocktails. It was very good. Love the amount of balsamic vinegar they used. Perfect. For our entrees, she had the Gnocchi di Ricotta Ai Tartufo. The gnocchi consisted of ricotta, not potato. It was also good. I had the risotto with duck breast and mushrooms. I had a hard time choosing an entree, everything sounded so good. For dessert she had the specials. Mine was blueberry mousse she had a latte. The meal and the service was excellent. We will eat here again.“

“We were at a holiday/retirement party. Large group. We were well cared for. I highly recommend them for a date night, happy hour or a large party!“

“Was there for a birthday. We were seated inside not on the patio. When the monsoon type storm hit the staff did an amazing job accommodating those that were on the patio. The city-living branch of our family thinks it's well worth the trip out here to LGP. A wonderful restaurant.“

“Great food pizza was absolutely amazing BEST thin crust pizza I ever had, was worth the hour drive“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining again at Gaia's Italiano Ristorante and it was an excellent gastronomic experience. Owned by a Sicilian native, this restaurant promises authentic Italian flavors, and it certainly delivers. To start, we indulged in the bruschetta which was a burst of freshness, with ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil atop perfectly toasted bread. We also had the homemade tender meatballs paired with a rich marinara sauce that had just the right balance of tanginess and herbs. One of the highlights of the evening was the Cacio E Pepe prepared right in front of us in a Parmesan cheese wheel. The creamy pasta infused with the sharpness of Parmesan was a true delight for the senses. Moving on to the mains, the salmone alla griglia was impeccably cooked, paired with a side of perfectly grilled vegetables. The pork chops were another standout, juicy and flavorful, showcasing the expertise of the kitchen. To round off the evening, we couldn't resist trying the cheesecake with raspberry sauce for dessert, ending the meal on a high note. What truly elevated the dining experience was the outstanding service. Attentive and knowledgeable staff as, Executive Chef and owner Maurizio guided us through each course, enhancing our enjoyment of each dish.“

“Did not try the food here but the ice cream here was decent. I got the cookies and cream, didn’t taste like traditional cookies and cream, mostly chocolate and oreo ?.Restaurant smelled good, and pizza looked very appetizing. You should try it out if you’re looking for dessert or some italian food.“

“Classic high end American restaurant. Extensive wine list but not overwhelming or overpriced. Oysters rock and shrimp cocktail were just big enough. Duck was right up there with the best we've ever had. Fried leeks as garnish was unnecessary and distracting from meal. We also had then salmon and mahi mahi. Both were done perfectly. There's a reason classic recipes stand the test of time.“

“If you want true Italian cooking and a friendly atmosphere, then Mangia Napoli is the place. I cannot express enough how great the food is! Thank you to Fonz, Eddie & Vinnie for the excellence in food. Fonz the Zuppa you prepared for our anniversary was beyond excellent! Many thanks“

“We were a group of 8 to celebrate a big birthday. Our server, Carmen, was super good about checking on the timing of ordering the various courses. We were not rushed and the swank space contributed to making the meal very special. The lobster risotto is divine, definitely shareable after appetizers and the generous salads included with each entree. Other diners enjoyed the duck special, the whitefish, and a really good rib eye. Nice for a special occasion or any time you want to have a great meal.“

“This is an absolutely spectacular spot to stop. Quick service, terrific food and incredibly great prices. I wanted to get myself an italian beef while I was here in Chicago and Frannies helped me accomplish that goal in the best way possible. Thank you for the terrific experience and I will certainly be back.“

“Great food, great service, great atmosphere!“

“Food was scrumptious. Got the salad, cream of chicken and a sandwich, and a tiramisu.Everything came really fast. And the whole place was spotless. Verrrrrry happy with my visit.Wheelchair accessibility: The parking lot and store are on the same level. The curb allows wheels on the left hand side of the parking lot as well. The chairs are movable.“

“Great food, drink, atmosphere, people!“

“Fantastic food, fantastic service!“

“Visited Chicago and my best friend took me here because she said it was really good and she wanted to come again. She was not wrong. It was delicious. We got the burrata, the Caesar salad to share. Both were absolutely tasty. The Burrata came with peaches, which was the perfect pairing. I got the linguine with prosciutto and that was so good. I wish it had more cheese in it since it was melted in the wheel of cheese but it was still delicious.The owner even came over and checked in with us and I thought that was nice touch. The only critique I could give was that it was a bit loud in there and the waiter was a tad slow for us, but overall a really great experience.“

“Had dinner on 12/17/2023 service and food was excellent. Gluten free menu available.“

“Soups, pastas, sauces, meats, pizzas, arachini, meatballs, calzones, specialty foods and groceries, and catering and trays are the best! The staff is nice and always helpful!“

“Hands down the best dining experience we've had in a very long while. Food was exceptional, service was excellent and we enjoyed the whole experience start to finish. Our family of four dined the night before Mothers Day. We ordered lasagna, two pappardelle dishes and a fettuccine meal. We all agreed we love them all (and we all tried samples of each others). The service was very welcoming and felt familiar but gracious. We will definitely be back.“

“We purchase pizza from the one in countryside. Lots of cheese tasted very good vegetables was fresh. We will be back there again soon“

“We had my mom’s 85th Birthday dinner here and it was perfect. We had a private section in the back which made it extra special. The service is exceptional and the food is delicious! We have also eaten here many times and every meal has been so good! From the salads to the risotto to the chicken Marsala, the flavors are incredible!“

“every ting, they are the last bastion of Italian culture in Chicago.“

“This was our second time dining at Positano’s and it was just as fabulous! The food here is superb, the wait staff are very attentive and we love the photos on the wall! The Seabass was to die for and the grilled seafood appetizer was divine! Our only regret is that we live in New York and cannot be frequent patrons of this wonderful establishment! Mille Grazie!!“

“We visited for the first time yesterday and it was AMAZING! Great ambience, friendly staff, good music but the food was the star of the show. Absolutely delicious! Everything from the bread, salads, soups and entrees. We will definitely be back!!!“

“A hidden gem if you're looking for authentic Italian cuisine and hospitality. Definitely highly recommended!“

“First time here, amazing service and food was delicious. Owner or manager came to every table to check in and thank us for coming in and support this business. I will definitely be back. So good!!!“

“enjoyed a wonderful dinner last night, started off with the mezza platter which i highly recommend followed by the most tender octopus ive ever had then thoroughly enjoyed the scallops which were exquisite and also ordered the chicken thighs with a unique taste of its own; i was visiting from out of town but its worth the drive and i highly recommend a visit“

“Great food and tasty and good team work“

“I cannot visit Oakbrook without visiting Simon's ?Oh my goodness I just love this place. I am from Detroit and this is definitely one of my favorite spots to dine at, the owner and the staff are so friendly Thank you so much for keeping things the same year after year absolutely wonderful ♥️?“

“Excellent Deep Dish Pizza!“

“I have been shopping at Nottoli for 25+ years. Their Italian sausage is the best. Yesterday, I called in an order for a party tray of 40 mini sub sandwiches at 2:15 pm. They were ready at 3:15 for pick up. The sandwiches were “award winning”. My wife brought them to a rehearsal for her church choir. Their staff is top notch. If you have not visited the store please do, you will not be disappointed.“

“Very fresh ingredients, made to order, piping hot, great taste.“

“Everything about our experience was five stars. First off the ambiance was so nice, stylish but comfortable and cozy. My four year old spilled milk all over him, the booth and the floor. The staff, Claudia (server), Andres and Kristine (host) were so unbelievably kind, attentive and responsive I don't think I have ever experienced that before. Kristine was so helpful and concerned she even offered me a clean towel to help dry him off in the restroom. I haven't even mentioned the food! Everything we ordered was delicious. We had an assortment of small plates (focaccia, Brussel sprouts, calamari, farro) as well as pasta and the burger was enjoyed by all. We would definitely be regulars if we were local.“

“The Best food in Chicago,delicious food,good prices,and the nicest owner in the world,Franco“

“Phenomenal food great service“

“Food was delicious. Service was great and nice ambiance too. Lunch menu was reasonable & delish.“

“It is always a pleasure dining here. Wonderful service is always provided. Great food with large portions. The cocktails are amazing! Let’s not forget the tasty appetizers and scrumptious desserts!!! GA must try!! You will not be disappointed!!“

“Great service and always consistent food. They have a partnership until August 23 with @makeawish“

“This was such a pleasant surprise and hidden gem for the neighborhood. The whole meal was amazing, portions were good and the flavors were on point. Service was great and they even gave us the most amazing cheesy soft chewy hot out of the pizza oven bread on the house when we asked for extra bread to sop up the sauce in the mussels. Everything at this place is delicious and unique! We would highly recommend Buona Terra Ristorante for a genuinely next level, Italian dining experience.“

“I’ve had beef’s from Jay’s for years! They are the best!!!!!“

“BYG appears to be back to the ways they were before the pandemic of 2020. Their portions are generous again as before I felt there was major cutbacks in quality and quantity due to businesses suffering due to Covid. Loved the pork kebab (Souvlaki), tzatziki sauce along with the Greek potatoes and rice pilaf.“

“Friday pizza night review Came for the pizza would come back for the salad. Atmosphere and service is top notch here. And we will be back to try other things as well. The wedge salad was freaking amazing. They really elevated an old classic! Wine selection is very good here The pizza was good but not amazing. The tart was a nice lighter finish.“

“The service, food, and ambience are all consistently impeccable. I highly recommend the polenta with Ragu. Ours this time was pork shoulder Ragu, and it was unbelievably good! Get it with a side of bread for an extra treat! Plenty to share or a hearty entrée for one.“

“Cucina is a good Oak Park locale that you can get good food with good service at a reasonable price. We went for Easter Brunch and never been a fan of buffet food, but they did well. Can’t say that I would do another buffet there, but casual dining…yes!“

“Amazing staff and the food was literally so fresh and DELICIOUS!!!! Worth the trip & portions are HUGE! I had the Diablo shrimp pasta, so flavorful and the shrimp was cooked perfectly. Will be back again! :)“

“Excellent food, great service, knowledgeable waitress“

“I do love the Alpine shop in Elmwood Park, but I have to say I like this location much better. A very friendly staff & a few tables for outdoor eating. Don't get me wrong the staff is friendly at Elmwood Park but they have so much going on that a few times our orders were messed up. So, I think I will stick with the Westchester location. Alot of parking too which is a Big Plus. The sandwiches are very fresh. Delicious as well! The cookies look very good too & next time I will add that & even a packaged brownie to our order. I never knew this location existed until we took a trip to the Queen of Heaven Cemetery. My Husband & I wanted to eat lunch first. We were shocked to find out Alpine is in Westchester for 7 years!! I am very happy we found out! The best subs around!! I had turkey with cheddar cheese & Gerry had The Alpine.“

“We went to celebrate my 50th Birthday, the establishment was suggested to us by a family member. The service was excellent, the staff is very well trained. The food was affordable and delicious, on point !!! Highly recommend it. Besides everything been good, the highlight for me was seen how one of the owners was going table to table asking her guest how everything was and how she was engaging with everyone as if there were family members joining her for dinner.“