17 Best Bakeries in Peoria

“These cookies are always good. Some flavors are overly sweet though. I suggest buying the cookie cutter they sell, see as 1/4 of a cookie is the recommended serving size. It is that way for good reason. More than that can be sweet overkill. My spouse and I usually go every couple weeks and share a new cookie flavor together. It is very fun to try all the new flavors that they switch out weekly.
This location has workers that are a little less friendly than the East Peoria location. But it's not too bad.“

“The best sourdough I’ve ever had, hands down. Going to the Sheridan market to get my sourdough every Wednesday is now the highlight of my week. Super sweet, friendly people. Out of this world bread! Can’t wait to try my bagels and my jam 😍“

“As a parent, nothing hits quite like watching your child feel left out. 💔 My daughter has a severe egg allergy — and for a long time, that meant no cupcakes at parties, no random bakery treats, no “just grab a donut” moments. And then there’s Riley’s. Because of you, she gets to walk into a bakery and pick something out like every other kid. She gets donuts. She gets joy. She gets normal. You have no idea what that means to allergy parents. It’s not “just” baked goods — it’s inclusion. She LOVES your donuts. And we love you for making safe magic. 💜🍩“

“Panadería Ortiz Bakery in Peoria, Illinois is a true local gem offering an authentic taste of Mexico through both its traditional bakery items and savory homemade dishes. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the warm aroma of freshly baked pan dulce, bolillos, conchas, and other classic Mexican pastries that taste just like they came straight from a family kitchen. Their selection is wide, fresh, and full of flavor perfectly soft, sweet, and comforting. Beyond the bakery case, they serve delicious Mexican food including tacos, burritos, tamales, and hearty soups that are generously portioned and made with rich, authentic seasoning. The atmosphere feels welcoming and community-oriented, with friendly staff who make you feel right at home. Prices are affordable for the quality and quantity you receive, making it a great spot for breakfast, lunch, or picking up pastries to share with family. Overall, Panadería Ortiz Bakery stands out as a must-visit place in Peoria for anyone craving genuine Mexican food and baked goods made with care and tradition.“

“Had a great birthday dinner and drinks. Worth every penny. Will be back for sure!“

“I custom ordered a birthday cake and I got the exact design I requested! It actually exceeded my expectations, the attention to detail was perfect and all add ons (flowers, glitter etc) 100% edible, not too mention great taste 🩵 Great customer service, speedy response, will continue to shop with them and recommend to everyone ✨“

“My husband and I had these donuts as our “cake”for our wedding almost a year ago. Since our one year anniversary is tomorrow, we celebrated this morning with donuts and was reminded why we choose this place. They’re soft, the frosting is perfect and they’re delicious. No donut compares to these!

Only advice I can give is to get there early. We got there just after 9 on a Saturday and they appeared like they were already running a bit low!

I was also happy to see they had gluten free options which they didn’t have as an option for our wedding!“

“These are the best cakes I’ve ever had. Perfect for any occasion!!!“

“it's a good store I you don't have to worry about young peoples hanging out around the store good environment good prices friendly service“

“We celebrate as often about the big and little things, just so we have a reason to go in and eat our favorite goodies! As well as sweets, they have a lovely menu for a quick and healthy lunch while on the go or for a quaint sit and bite. Our family loves going here and is always welcomed by the great staff and wonderful owners. They did our wedding cake (the tiramisu) and several birthdays over the years!“

“We ordered chicken for a family gathering and it was excellent! Order was ready when we arrived and the service was prompt and efficient. We’ll definitely order again. Thank you!“

“How AMAZING is this cake?! I sent her two pictures of my vision and she exceeded my expectations!! I received SO many compliments on the cake and my daughter LOVED it. Thank you so much and absolutely recommend!“

“Great Harvest has yummy baked goods and delicious sandwiches for lunch! I highly recommend all of their locations! Excellent small business which has been around for many years!“

“Yummy frozen yogurt with so many toppings and friendly staff!“

“I work downtown and go here at least once a week. I order the same thing when I go, 16oz Fr Vanilla Latte with half and half. Depending who was working the counter I would get charged differently each time. $5.66 one day or $6.77 the next. I asked one day and was told I was being charged for the half and half. Ok fine, BUT today I go there and order the same drink and they wanted to charge me $7.00 for a 16oz??? Starbucks and Dunkin charge $4.49 for the same drink and size. I go to CXT to support local. But today was probably my last day. The gentleman today fixed me up and I was charged $5.00. I think you Managers better circle back because no one will pay $7.00 for a 16oz iced latte.“

“Cracked Pepper made our catering event so easy. Marla and Kate were great to get along and the food was simply outstanding. We ordered from their Bistro Boxed Lunch Menu and were more than satisfied. Thanks Cracked Pepper! We will be using you again when the need comes again.“

“This was our first time and we enjoyed it immensely. We had the chicken salad sandwich, a three cheese grilled cheese, and corn fritters. The corn fritters were great and we had never tried them with powdered sugar - so good. If they have it, I also highly recommend the fresh lemonade... YUM! Love the quaint atmosphere. 🩷“