8 Best Sandwich Shops in Anderson

“I was so impressed with this little sub shop that I had to leave an exceptional review. The owner is also the person that will take your order and quite possibly be the person making your sub or salad. You can taste the love and pride that this sub shop owner has for his business. He hands you a clip board with everything he has available and all you do is just circle what you want. There are all kinds of meats, cheeses, vegetables and sauces for an infinite amount of combinations. This is a must stop shop.“

“Good food had no complaints of any kind“

“The service is great. The staff is always friendly and helpful. They make the sandwiches fresh when you order. They slice the meat and cheese when you order. The toppings look way better than other sub places. And they give you plenty of toppings. The restaurant is clean.“

“We long awaited McAlister’s coming to Anderson, and I’m excited they are here. After a few opening glitches, all taken care of by competent management, they’re now the quality I’ve come to expect from other locations. Consistent menu with so many options, especially the pick two 1/2s where you can make an almost limitless variety of options. A bit pricier than than other fast food but worth it for homemade taste and generous portions. My only complaint about this store’s layout is there are only two single-person bathrooms, so there is usually an awkward wait. Maybe they expected Anderson to be mostly carry out business?“

“Stopped in for sandwiches today. I got it to go cause my husbands in a wheelchair so we just ate in the car. The staff was super nice and made me the best BLT I've ever had. 😋They suggested a get the 9 grain bread which was delicious and even ask me if I wanted my bacon extra crispy 👍 I had to go back in after we ate and let them know how great it was😃“

“We walked in after the entire Anderson soccer camp staff came in for lunch. The staff handled the rush so quickly! They even had to make fresh bread bc they ran out! They were amazing bc we had to wait and the fresh bread was super good. The staff really made our visit great. Thank you guys!“

“Hello just to let you know that you have two exceptional employees at this location they are polite and very efficient any time they are working the restaurant is always spotless and they keep everything fresh they deserve a raise or a bonus their names are sam and dhura and because of them this is my favorite subway this is at the
Main street subway in Anderson indiana“

“There's always the same two young, female employees when we go in, and intermittently an older gentleman with a hilariously surly disposition. He's not the one you want to build your sandwich... Think saucy bread sandwich with meat and veggie accents. The other two however...They're awesome. They're sandwich artistry conjures the likes of Mozart, Julia Child, and Chevy Chase. The food is always spot on. There's never any other customers in there when we go. Awesome job ladies.“