31 Best American Restaurants near Bargersville

“We went here this evening for the first time for our anniversary dinner hands-down as soon as you walk in sweet inviting warm, kind, friendly people. The food was absolutely delicious. I got the walleye my husband got the lasagna. We had a shrimp cocktail for an appetizer, I had a wedge salad he had a Caesar salad. They were huge and then we had the crème brûlée for dessert.“

“Knuckle Sandwich had delicious pizza. I don’t order their meals because they refuse to evenly substitute the fries for any other side. I think that could only hurt their business.“

“We always ask for Nick Owen to be our waiter cause he has a Great personality plus excellent servicer to bring us great food. We had a table of 8 and everyone loved him. Made for a special time to celebrate a graduation party. Good food and drinks everyone enjoyed.“

“Absolutely love the pumpkin pancakes so much, that I get them every visit! And summer the lemon blueberry. We ask for Layla every time, she knows what we drink and brings them before we ever ask. She jokes with my husband which he loves. She's funny, super sweet and such a great waitress. We've been coming here for a few months now, after leaving another pancake place, because of the food and service here. We bring all of out out of town guests here and upon a return visit this is where they want to come. Layla makes each visit the best part of our day!“

“We had three (3) appetizers, calamari, shrimp and meat board - all were delicious. Then one had the blue crab cakes, filet medallions, 8oz filet mignon, and white cheese Bacon burger. We will return as the wait staff were excellent and provided enough service that we were impressed. Fished the meal off with cream Brule, carrot cake and chocolate something. Needless to say, they had to roll us outa the restaurant.“

“Great food. Pleasant, friendly staff...“

“The staff here was super attentive. The food was good, but not really a wow factor. The restaurant was clean and the hostess kept up with the dirty tables expeditiously, promptly, and efficiently.

… BUT BABY! Phyllis! This lady was bartending and took the best care of us in the dining room. The server they sat us with was overwhelmed and Phyllis gave us excellent service. Y’all come see her and get you a piece of this salad bar!“

“Service was awesome. Our server was very friendly, and even helped me correct an error I made when ordering (do yourself a favor and don't confuse the hottest wing sauce with the Indiana sauce!!)

This is quickly becoming one of our favorites.“

“Always a never disappoints 30+ years met the owners daughter this evening when my and I had lunch! Very respectful , knowledgeable , inviting working behind the bar.“

“My wife and I like to try different mom and pop places and had yet to try this restaurant for breakfast. We made a good choice with the Court Street Café.
When we walked in, we noticed it was a little small, but we were seated right away. Our server was over a moment or two later and took our drink order. When she returned, we each ordered the Farmer's Breakfast, and I got an extra side of home fries (one of my vices).
Looking around, it was apparent that the owners put some effort into keeping a small-town vibe in here - nothing too extravagant and nice decor (we really like the ceiling fans). It is a nicely appointed restaurant!
Our food came out a short time later, and it was tasty. The eggs were perfectly sunny-side up and the biscuits and gravy were just the right amount of spicy. The pancake was fluffy and the home fries were a little mushy, but that is probably just how they do them. Seeing as how we got the same food, my wife's order was greatly appreciated as well, as she had nothing but compliments too.
Overall, we will be back, as it was a pretty great breakfast!“

“This has been my 2nd visit to this location. When I stopped in a week ago there was no licking chicken fried chicken. Today I stopped in ordered a bone in which was actually cooked properly and quite delicious.. BeBe was my waitress on today was absolutely amazing very attentive to her guest and very quick I love great service and both visits my service was great..“

“Burgers are good but you forgot my fries 😡“

“The food was good but my boyfriends tea was cross contaminated with fruit from another customers drink the concern was brushed off as if it was no big deal. So if you have any allergies pay attention to your drinks or food.“

“Awesome food and service enjoyed lunch on a beautiful Friday afternoon in Greenwood had the double suds burger Strawberry Shake and drink very good taste and nice thick shake server was great“

“Greatness it’s how I would describe the service of this establishment and the alluring waitress named Hailey. She was always very attentive to our needs, even went above and beyond with the language barrier. If you are planning to go and eat at this restaurant without hesitation I would recommend you ask for Hailey to be your waitress“

“Wow this place is one of the best places out there to eat. We had their Breakfast called the Brandy, and wow it was really good. 100% better than the old Tom's that was there. Our family has found a good place to eat! 5 Stars all the way.“

“I work there it’s very nice“

“The tenderloin won best tenderloin in Indiana one year. I've had it and it is incredible. It's very soft and never tough or chewy. I think they must pound the heck out of it before breading. The breading is golden brown and crispy. The servers there are always sweet and make you feel appreciated and act like they love their jobs. A fantastic experience every time we go.“

“I'm not a huge Applebee's fan. The food is pretty good, but not anything special and it's always been a mediocre experience to me BUT I went tonight and I have to say the service was great! We felt welcome and our server, Grace, was so kind and on top of everything! The food was not bad either.“

“I have been to the Revery 3 times in the last 2 months and it gets better every time. Service is spot on. Love that you can make reservations. Crab cake bruschetta was great each time. Short ribs are so tender, we had the Halibut special a week ago, this week we had the meatloaf and it was really good. We shared the last two meals and was plenty to share. Excellent restaurant for any occasion“

“Today was my 1st experience at Ann’s. We had Alexa as our server, she was outstanding. She was on top of it and made our experience well worth it and we will definitely be returning! Totally recommend Ann’s restaurant! 100/10!“

“Good Food , great service, always clean.“

“The food here is pretty good, but the staff make it an all-around great experience. Everyone is super friendly and attentive to your needs. My husband and I decided last-minute to make a visit today on our way home from traveling all day, and it just happened to be Free Pie Wednesday. We also had the pleasure of our server being a lovely fellow named Shane. The manager of the establishment also walked by our table and asked about our meal. Everything was great.“

“Packed restaurant, seated quickly, fast,
friendly service, fun atmosphere, team work at its finest. I'm very picky about my steaks.. I return 70% of the time because rare to medium rare is hard to get. MY STEAK WAS PERFECT! THANK YOU TO THE CHEF!“

“Good burgers, great fries! I love their Ranch which is always a plus for me. Excellent server in a calm chill environment. Come check it out!“

“Love this Denny’s location. Great atmosphere. Service and food are always great! Always clean! Will be back“

“Mitchell was new but he did an amazing job and was so sweet“

“The lovely people of hickory sticks golf course were super friendly and the corse and lobby was very clean and well kept. I would recommend anyone that wants to enjoy the sun and a friendly game of golf, they go to hickory sticks!“

“Very chill atmosphere, friendly service, and awesome food. I HIGHLY recommend!“

“Love this place. Great Food and Service“

“Love the bartender ,Stephenie is friendly and very nice to everyone..Great place to hang with friends and to relax after work .“