50 Best American Restaurants near Bargersville

“We went to Our Table for our anniversary. We were seated by the fireplace, given champagne and macaroons accompanied by a note congratulating us. They went over the top to make us feel special. My husband’s steak was cooked perfectly and the Shrimp Bucatini Diablo was to die for.“

“We stumbled upon this place while out of town. Food and service were great! The atmosphere is fun and the kids loved it. 10/10“

“We had three (3) appetizers, calamari, shrimp and meat board - all were delicious. Then one had the blue crab cakes, filet medallions, 8oz filet mignon, and white cheese Bacon burger. We will return as the wait staff were excellent and provided enough service that we were impressed. Fished the meal off with cream Brule, carrot cake and chocolate something. Needless to say, they had to roll us outa the restaurant.“

“Absolutely love the pumpkin pancakes so much, that I get them every visit! And summer the lemon blueberry. We ask for Layla every time, she knows what we drink and brings them before we ever ask. She jokes with my husband which he loves. She's funny, super sweet and such a great waitress. We've been coming here for a few months now, after leaving another pancake place, because of the food and service here. We bring all of out out of town guests here and upon a return visit this is where they want to come. Layla makes each visit the best part of our day!“

“Was visiting a friend in Greenwood and Googled “Greenwood Tenderloin”one of the highest rated was “Shallos Antique Restaurant “. It was on our way home, so we tried it. We loved the quick seating (with a huge Friday night crowd) and Billie was a wonderful server for first time visitors. The breaded tenderloin was exceptional and so was the ribeye sandwich. We will be returning.“

“Great food. Pleasant, friendly staff...“

“Our family has been eating at the Greenwood, Indiana Ruby Tuesdays for lunch on Black Friday for a few years now. This location is great! We have always had wonderful service! The menu has a good variety and everything always tastes good! We showed up this year right as they opened with 13 adults, 7 small children and a baby and they were able to get us seated quickly. Our servers - Phil, Amber, and Chelsea were Rockstars! They quickly took orders, delivered meals, kept drinks refilled and even took pictures for us! Would give them 10 stars if we could! Thank you for making our lunch break on a busy day so nice and relaxing!“

“We've gone twice now, and it's been a great experience both times. Atmosphere is casual, prices are reasonable, and portions generous. Susan our waitress was fantastic! Food came out quickly, and everything was hot, fresh, and delicious. We'll be back!“

“Burgers are good but you forgot my fries 😡“

“Stopped in for lunch when we were exploring Franklin. Really nice; food was good; French toast sticks delivered upright in a cute boat and pancakes were huge! Quiche came with mmmmmm pumpkin bread. Nice bathroom too, tho it was a onesie, so had to wait a lot. Good choice!“

“The food was good but my boyfriends tea was cross contaminated with fruit from another customers drink the concern was brushed off as if it was no big deal. So if you have any allergies pay attention to your drinks or food.“

“Stephanie has done it again!!! Every time we come, she kills it with excellent service! Fast, effective, great personality! She never ceases to amaze me!! Ty for always making our visit wonderful!“

“Makayla was great! Definitely will return“

“Awesome food and service enjoyed lunch on a beautiful Friday afternoon in Greenwood had the double suds burger Strawberry Shake and drink very good taste and nice thick shake server was great“

“I work there it’s very nice“

“Wow this place is one of the best places out there to eat. We had their Breakfast called the Brandy, and wow it was really good. 100% better than the old Tom's that was there. Our family has found a good place to eat! 5 Stars all the way.“

“This is a very popular place to eat in downtown Franklin. The food and service is excellent. A few of us tried their breaded tenderloin sandwiches because we heard they were great and they did not disappoint! I like the indoor and covered outdoor seating options.“

“We enjoy eating here and have started to make it part of our regular rotation. We have had a (very) few hiccups with food over the past few years, but the staff is always excellent about addressing any issues and making sure we're happy when we leave. Cocktails and other drinks are always excellent. Absolutely recommend the daily specials and happy hour if it's convenient.“

“Not as good as usual given apparent kitchen staffing issues, but review is really prompted by wondering how anyone can choose or tolerate those cold white spot lights above the bar? My eyes can’t handle that. Ok for an operating room, but not a restaurant.“

“Austin (AJ) was an absolute gem! He was attentive, funny, and an exceptional server
Overall. As a veteran in the service industry (10 years bartender) I was beyond impressed with his level of service. Especially given he casually mentioned it was his 3rd day on the floor! You keep this man and value him Applebee's. This industry doesn't have people like AJ in abundance. So treasure him!“

“Stopped in on a whim and was glad we did. Our server was fantastic, and the manager even checked on our table. Food was cooked perfectly, and the warm rolls + Free Pie Wednesday were a nice bonus. Relaxed vibe, good food, and friendly staff — just a small sauce mix-up, but it was fixed right away.“

“Good burgers, great fries! I love their Ranch which is always a plus for me. Excellent server in a calm chill environment. Come check it out!“

“Loved the stromboli and the taco salad. Loaded tots are the bomb! Great service. Will be back.“

“Fantastic food. Definitely worth the money. Ingredients are fresh and the sauces they're paired with are amazing. We had the Brussel sprouts as an appetizer, filet and short rib as our main entrees. The sweet potato puree with the short rib was incredible (and I don't even like sweet potatoes usually). Service was ever so slightly sparse but the bartender was the one serving us in addition to tending the bar. They comped our dessert since we were celebrating my husbands promotion! I'm not one to leave a review so this says something!“

“Today was my 1st experience at Ann’s. We had Alexa as our server, she was outstanding. She was on top of it and made our experience well worth it and we will definitely be returning! Totally recommend Ann’s restaurant! 100/10!“

“Love this Denny’s location. Great atmosphere. Service and food are always great! Always clean! Will be back“

“Good Food , great service, always clean.“

“Mitchell was new but he did an amazing job and was so sweet“

“Great food and love their beer. Try the Red Velvet beer. Yummy!“

“It was a great night at Witt's Inn ! It was my first time here. Got to see Soul Stricken for the first time . They are amazing! out Waitress was great ! Thank you all for an AMAZING experience! We will definitely be back ! It was a win win for us !!; ♥️“

“Love this place. Great Food and Service“

“Love the bartender ,Stephenie is friendly and very nice to everyone..Great place to hang with friends and to relax after work .“

“The Cheesecake Factory at its Greenwood Park Mall location is an excellent choice for a special occasion. Its enchanting ambiance and beautiful setting create a magical atmosphere that makes it a memorable dining experience. We made our reservation online to celebrate a birthday and were pleasantly surprised to avoid the long lobby wait. I savored the Shrimp Scampi, which was not only delicious but also presented impressively. For dessert, I indulged in the Godiva Chocolate Brownie Sundae, which was simply divine. The waiter was friendly and attentive, making our dining experience truly enjoyable. I highly recommend this Cheesecake Factory for any special occasion.“

“Fun time for the kids and the food is very good“

“They just had over 25 violations by Department of Heath in Daily Journal Management needs to improve tremendously at this location, not only violations! another problem is they don't want to cook any white meat chicken.“

“Thank you for making my future daughter-in-law’s bridal shower so special!“

“The lovely people of hickory sticks golf course were super friendly and the corse and lobby was very clean and well kept. I would recommend anyone that wants to enjoy the sun and a friendly game of golf, they go to hickory sticks!“

“I’ve been coming to this City Barbecue for years and tonight I was truly blown away! Andrew and closing manager Deonte were two of the kindest and most hospitable guys I’ve ever met in the food industry! I ordered corn bread and it accidentally got sold so Andrew gave me a free banana pudding and when I went to use my $5 rewards coupon Deonte told me I could just keep it for the inconvenience! I will never not recommend this place thanks to the great food, service, memories, and these two guys I met here tonight! Thanks again gentlemen, and all of the City Barbecue staff!“

“Love this bar one of a kind staff very attentive wanting everyone to have a good time Dayshift you have the beautiful Tiffany Night Shift you have the incredible Dave, Graham, Fred and the beautiful Alena, Jackie, Gabby, Mia, Stormy, Courtney One of the best bars on the planet“

“I tried to go here once on a weekend, but it was far too packed. I see why! The service was great and the food was absolutely delicious. I tried the new Blazing Dragon Juice and a couple of items on the fall menu and loved them! I love how there was a whole separate seasonal menu.“

“I had not eaten at a Waffle House in 12+ years and my son asked to try it. We had breakfast for dinner and everything tasted amazing. I had the pecan waffle, scrambled eggs, sausage, hash browns and toast. Delicious! The waffle was crisp on the outside and fluffy inside. You could taste the vanilla too.“

“Stopped here last weekend traveling. Decided on the special of grilled beef and cheese sandwich with tomato basil soup. I didn’t have the bbq sauce on the sandwich because I don’t eat pork. We got the all around appetizer and that was great. Our server was very nice. Lots of what is on the menu is deep fried.“

“Fun atmosphere. Music bingo, games, karaoke is fun!“

“Great staff. Tabby Boyd is by far the best waitress I have ever come across in my travels. Polite friendly attentive and has a great personality. I appreciate all she does. From what I see she’s a great employee and liked by all. Thank you for the great service!!“

“We got the Mago Skillet with pancakes and the T-bone steak and eggs. Portions were great! Steak and eggs were cooked perfectly, and the steak had excellent flavor. Home fries were cooked perfectly, they just need a little bit of salt. But I would prefer not enough salt instead of too much salt. The pancakes had a slight metallic aftertaste, so I think that might be the batter. But the texture was nice and fluffy and good portions. We also ordered 10 pork and chicken tamales to go. The tamales were phenomenal. Great portion, plenty of filling, and just needed a little pinch of salt on top to make it perfect. We reheated them at home and ate them over the next few days. They were great. My family is from Mexico, and my dad said these reminded him of the tamales he had growing up. They are the best he’s had in the U.S. The prices were great. We got to speak to some of the people that work there, and they are all family. It was really cool to see them all working together. Portions, flavors, price, and service were great!“

“Local, southside pub with a friendly, casual atmosphere.

This was our first time checking out the place since we kept driving by it. Some aspects of the interior looked dated, but small pubs can be like that so we didn't feel put off. We were there for Thursday night dinner, and there was plenty of seating when we arrived and got busier during our time there.

? Burgers were BIG and served hot, really tasty. Server also kept our drinks refilled!

We also tried a half pound of the fried chicken liver appetizer and asked for honey mustard dipping sauce for it. Good if you like liver as the breading is seasoned well and has a hard crunch!

We also tried the potato skins but those were a bit disappointing. Cheese was not all melted and instead of crispy skins, it was more accurately baked, mini half potatoes.

Overall it was a decent time. I can see it being a spot for locals if you enjoy a casual place to drink and chill.

Parking: There is a large parking lot for the plaza but it can get busy during peak times due to the many businesses there. You will always be able to find a spot to park but it might not always be close.

Kid-friendliness: 21+ this is a bar for adults

Wheelchair accessibility: The doors are not wheelchair friendly so someone will likely need to provide assistance for entry and exiting.“

“We've been going here every Friday night for 7 years, and all of the staff are just like family. We miss our friend Juan, he really makes you feel at home.

Dietary restrictions: A friend of ours has a daughter who is gluten free, they know how to take care of her a make no fuss about it.“

“Small place packs a punch , I was torn between like 5 different burgers I wanted to try I was very intrigued! So I asked the young lady taking our order ( super sweet and friendly btw ) what her favorite burger was and she told me the Indy Burger. I took her word for it and was not disappointed in the least bit! It was so good! The fries remind me of a thinner potato wedge with great seasoning. We shared the loaded tots which were so crispy and not greasy , I honestly thought they were cooked in an air fryer. My only gripe was I’m a Coke drinker and they serve Pepsi lol! Over all great burger great experience! Will definitely be back have a few more burgers I wanna try!“

“Visited today for the first time and had a fantastic experience. Great service and atmosphere. We got the huevos divorciados and the Mexi Breakfast Tacos. Honestly the tacos were a very safe and vanilla choice and I regret it. It was fine, just not the flavor I was looking for. The huevos divorciados on the other hand…I wanted to lick the plate. So many incredible, traditionally and nontraditional breakfast items as well as cocktails, and a delectable selection of desserts brought in fresh from Chicago. Highly recommend!!! I know⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I only have 30 mins breaks at work & my to-gos have been very fast & food was fresh. Erin that works on to-gos has always been amazing. She recommended the potato soup & its my new favorite there!“