18 Best Sandwich Shops near Chesterton

“Jimmy John's boxed lunches came through like true MVPs at our tailgate party. The Beach Club sandwich was stacked with fresh, vibrant flavors, the pickle and chips brought that essential sideline crunch, and the oatmeal cookie closed it out like a winning play in overtime.

Convenient, delicious, and tailgate-ready—Jimmy John’s knows how to keep the whole team fueled. Highly recommended for any gameday lineup.“

“I gotta send a shout out and a lot of praise to Nick and the crew here. My main issue with Subways in the past, is how hit or miss it can be. However that’s not the case here. Me and my manager order lunch from her about once a week and both the food as well as the service are consistently excellent. My go to is the BMT and I like a lot of toppings, as well as I am one to get some sauces. That can lead to a messy and sometimes straight unmanageable sandwich. Here though, they thoughtfully assemble ingredients in reasonable proportions and adequate amount of sauce. That along with firm yet full bread which is never overly toasted, avoiding that scattering of crumbs with every bite. This all makes for a sandwich I can enjoy as opposed to just trying to keep it from fall apart.
The service is also always pleasant and the team accommodating. I prefer giardiniera on my sandwich but the app doesn’t have that as an option and often I forget to ask for a side in the special instruction. But the crew is alway quick to oblige me, even when they’re hard at work on multiple sandwiches.
All in all, as one who really looks forward to my lunches, it is a relief and a comfort to know that the food is gonna always be satisfactory and often the solace on a particular rough day. Too often these forums are used to berate or complain, so I wanted to take the time to acknowledge and show appreciation for people who seeming put a lot of caring into what they do . Thank yall and keep up the great work!! ☺️🙏🏼“

“We stopped here on a road trip. I tried to place an online order and use a promo for bogo subs, but the Subway website kept giving me an error when I tried using 2 different payment methods. 😡 So I went into this Subway location & they agreed to apply my discount. There was 3 employees there & they were friendly & accommodating. Our subs were made correctly and the portions were adequate. The store was clean. They could use better signage for the road, as it was a little tricky to find (as it's around the corner of a building). But otherwise a good experience.“

“Today valpo has many power outages. I came in today with 15 different orders on sticky notes to feed my coworkers who don’t have power at home. The team at firehouse made the food quickly with smiles on their faces. The store was busy and they kept everything running smoothly! Will be back soon! They were so nice and easy going.“

“Pretty typical Firehouse Subs. If you are in a hurry call ahead. Everyone except me ordered ahead. I had a 15 minute wait. If I wasn't on my way to work it wouldn't have mattered. The quality of ingredients they use is good and the sandwiches were filling ( 1 for nightshift breakfast and 1 for lunch).“

“This is seriously the best sandwich spot in town.“

“Great subs. Not too cheap but totally worth it. My mom was brought here as a kid and it's stayed a family favorite for over 50 years now.“

“Jimmy John's in valpo has to get the delivery drivers to roll some better dice 😂 TheDM“

“me and my sister came in there about an hour ago she got the Thai food , I got the mac n cheese double smash burger with bacon and it was delicious definitely will come back for more“

“Customer Service and hospitality is through the roof. The food is as good as the Service. Sliced/grilled fresh right in front so you know what you're getting is top quality foods!“

“Food is great, delivery is always fast, but I wish they would ring the darn doorbell when they deliver!! My husband's surprise birthday lunch sat on the porch for 3 hours while I was at work because he had no idea it was there.“

“I used to work at a Subway because I would crave it while I was pregnant. With that being said I know how a subway is ran through and through. THIS Subway here is One Of Thee Best Subway locations I have been to!! The employees were helpful, kind, and very attentive. This manager (whomever it may be) is doing a WONDERFUL job.
The FOOD is Very Fresh. The meats and vegetables were all full. I like a lot of veggies so usually the sandwich artist will make a mess of my sandwich But Not Here Buddy. This you Gentleman with blue eyes and blond hair deserves the Title of a true sandwich artist!! The way he took great care into making the perfect sandwich for myself and my daughter is admirable!!! I'm not sure if I ever want anyone else to make my Subway sandwich for me, as of yesterday.
Hats off to this Subway!!
P.S. no pictures due to being in a hurry but rest assured I will be one of my favorite places as long as he is working.“

“I am currently battling cancer and have been in chemo and radiation for the last four weeks. I haven’t been able to eat much if anything, but they found out that lemon rice soup sounded good to me, they took it upon themselves to bring it to me . These kind of blessings will not be forgotten. Thank you so much for your kindness“

“Easy to find location. Drive thru available. Team members are friendly, quick, and accurate, especially the older female who prepared my order. Kudos to her and her ability to smile while performing her job.
Not only was she please, but my sandwich was delicious.“

“Good service and great food“

“Every time I go to this subway they are very polite. My order is always right they're very friendly the bread is always fresh ,the employee at the drive-thru window that waited on me not just this time every time thank you for your customer service“

“What a shame they make employees prep, make sandwiches and check them out by themselves..
There was only 1 employee at the lunch hour rush.. She was FABULOUS, however, unacceptable from a business standpoint.. There is NO WAY 1 person should EVER be alone in a store..Subway you can do better!!!“

“Had a mishap yesterday with the lulu I ordered but the ladies that work 2nd shift made it all good! Best customer service I’ve had at a fast food place in years, best jimmy johns as well! This is the one you want to go to hands down. Thanks again ladies!“