12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fair Oaks

Farmhouse Restaurant American • $$
754 N 600 E, Fair Oaks

Customers` Favorites

Fair Oaks Farm's Mac N Cheese
Fair Oaks Farms' Cheese Board
Short Rib & Brisket Sandwich
BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
Chocolate Frenzy Brownie
Farmhouse Bacon Sampler
Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf
Smoked Baby Back Ribs
Classic Fried Chicken

“Best tenderloin stop on the way to Chicago

We stop here every time we’re on our way to Chicago and it never disappoints.

What we love:
- Tenderloin: They have the best tenderloin, hands down. Huge, hand-breaded, crispy outside and juicy inside. Bigger than the bun like a proper Indiana tenderloin should be.

- Atmosphere: Cozy farmhouse vibe with rustic wood and warm lighting. Super clean and welcoming. Great spot to relax and stretch your legs after I-65.

- Location: Easy off the highway near Indianapolis. Big parking lot, even for larger vehicles. Perfect midpoint break on a Chicago road trip.

- Service: Tammy was friendly and quick. They treat you like family.

If you’re heading to Chicago, plan to stop here. Order the tenderloin and you won’t regret it. Feels like a true Midwest hidden gem.

Tip: Get there hungry because the portions are big. The fries are great with it too.“

3.8 Good765 Reviews
Marcella's Pizzeria Inc. Pizza • $
3854 IN-10, Wheatfield - 10.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza with Extra Cheese Pepperoni and Italian Sausage
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza
Hot Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Garlic Shrimp Alfredo Pizza
Marcella’S Garlic Rolls
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
12 Inch Pepperoni Calzone
Spinach Specialty Pizza
Marcellas Garlic Rolls
Garlic Mashed Potatoes

“Came for the first time on Sat. Drove 45 min to try this place out and we were not disappointed. It was VERY busy but all the workers worked quick and efficiently. We ordered a deep dish with low expectations (as the further from Chicago we get the pizza usually isn’t as good in our opinion) but we were very pleasantly surprised with everything about our pizza. The dough was delicious and cooked perfectly, fresh mushrooms, huge chunks of sausage and a perfectly balanced sweet sauce. The garlic rolls were a nice touch and SO good! We will most definitely be back!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
eMbers Station Bistro & Bar Cocktail Bar • $$
230 W Washington St, Rensselaer - 11.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Portabella Mushroom Sandwich
Veggie Garden Artisan Pizza
The Oink Flatbread Pizza
Brick Oven Fired Pizza
Chicken Bacon Sandwich
Pulled Pork Nachos
Chips and Sandwich
Embers Side Salad
S'Mores Dessert
Pretzel Sticks

“Very nice place and super cozy! Wood fired pizza was amazing.“

4.7 Superb95 Reviews
Rick's Pizza Pizza • $
494 N Van Rensselaer St, Rensselaer - 10.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Three Topping Pizza
Two Topping Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“Great Pizza! loaded toppings and perfect sauce.“

4.5 Superb40 Reviews
Pizza King | DeMotte, IN Pizza • $
527 N Halleck St, De Motte - 9.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Marinara \u0026 brdstck
Spaghetti Marinara & brdstck
Tossed Salad \u0026 brdstck
Chicken Bacon Ranch Whole
Chicken Bacon Ranch Half
Cinnamon Pretzel Bites
Philly Cheese Steak
Italian Beef Whole
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Italian Dressing

“The best pizza by far! Great environment and phenomenal service. The owners are awesome!“

4.4 Superb54 Reviews
J&J's Pizza Pizza • $
11920 IN-10, De Motte - 4.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Small Thick Crust Supreme Delivered Hot
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Beef Sandwich with Fries
Small Supreme Pizza
Stuffed Crust Pizza
Beef Sandwich Large
The Kitchen Sink
Buffalo Wings
Taco Pizza
Onion Ring

“my salad today was delicious!“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
707 N McKinley Ave, Rensselaer - 10.71 miles

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

5 Superb6 Reviews
Pizza King Pizza • $
227 S College Ave, Rensselaer - 11.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Piece Chicken & 2 Tater Wedges
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Pretzel Bread Stix
Hot Ham & Cheese
Chicken Strip
Garlic Bread
Baked Beans
Taco Salad
Breast
Olives

“Don't know about the pizza. Saw the sign for fresh fried chicken and stopped on the way to Valparaiso. Everyone was super helpful. Chicken was fried while I waited, so it was extreemly hot and had to wait for it to cool down. 3 pieces with 2 big fried potato wedges for under $7 is a pretty good deal to me!“

4 Good39 Reviews
Miracle’s Neighborhood Bar Bar & Grill • $
11988 IN-55, Thayer - 7.87 miles

“100 % would come again 🥰 it was my first time ever at the bar n it was a great experience i definitely love that place“

4.5 Superb29 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
11747 IN-10, De Motte - 4.85 miles

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Smoke Stack Pizza Shack Food Trucks • $$
10411 N 1000 W, De Motte - 6.37 miles

“Awesome Pizza! Awesome Prices! Awesome Service!! 👍👍🍕🍕“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
425 N Halleck St, De Motte - 9.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza with Breadsticks
Supreme Pizza Hand Tossed Sausage Added
Potato Bites with Cheese and Jalapenos
16 Breaded Bone-Out Wings
Backyard BBQ Chicken Pizza
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Stuffed Crust Pizza
12 Supreme Pizza
Cinnamon Sticks
Boneless Wings

“I dont care what anyone says, I'll always love pizza hut pizza. Their veggies are always fresh and their original pan is delicious. This specific one seems to take a little longer than others. Dining in takes a while as well. There seems to only be 1 serve ever for many tables. So have time to dine in if doing so.“

3.5 Good93 Reviews

You May Also Like