Italian Restaurants near Gary

Mama Mia's Ristorante Italiano Italian •
4121 Cleveland St, Gary

“Delicious freshly prepared Italian food from a wonderful family! You can't go wrong woth anything on the menu the beef and sausage combo is delicious. The pasta dishes are all family recipes passed on generations and fantastic. Everyone for their favorite special and it sells out practically before it's made in pre-orders LOL! the market itself that you can find Mama Mia's in is bustling with energy and has tons of great deals. You can eat in or carry out and you won't be disappointed! Don't forget to get an Italian ice and then we'll even give you a sample“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Rico's Pizza Pizza • $
5404 W 25th Ave D, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Sausge and Cheese Pizza
Meat Lovers 5
Italian Beef
Hot Wings

“I hadn't been to Rico's in 20 years. I was nervous to try them again. The entrance is routed through the liquor store door due to a truck driving through the front, so that was a bit awkward. There was also an issue with my total. It took about 15 minutes, but they fixed it. The pizza was just as delicious as I had remembered. The toppings were a bit skimpy (one pepperoni per square), but the flavor was still there. Also, the employees were pleasant. I interacted with two young ladies and an older gentleman. Everyone was friendly. I definitely will return!“

3.1 Average36 Reviews
Gamba Ristorante Italian • $$
455 E 84th Dr, Merrillville - 8.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Cocktail with Cognac and Cocktail Sauces
Choclate Hazelnut Cheesecake
Oven Roasted Brussels
Pan Seared Swordfish
Marinated Pork Chop
House Made Tiramisu
Short Rib Ravioli
House Salad
Duck Breast
Rack of Lamb

“The food, every course, was simply excellent. My wife often orders duck and the Gamba duck was the best she has ever had, very tender, perfect medium rare. Our polenta appetizer and my braised pork shoulder were also excellent. Portions were generous. We dined on Thursday, half-price wine night, and Gamba's wine list has many moderately priced but very good wines to have with dinner. The staff can help diners choose menu items and wines that best meet their tastes. Ample parking.“

4.6 Superb183 Reviews
Ammirato's Meatball Cafe Salad •
126 N Griffith Blvd, Griffith - 6.44 miles

“Will definitely be going back again! We had the meatball bowl, pizza tots, and meatball panini and all were amazing. I had the spicy meatball in my panini and it was delicious. Not overly spicy, just the right amount. Pizza tots were a fun and different appetizer and it did not disappoint. We also had the lemon cake which was very good too. Great customer service as well!“

4.8 Superb34 Reviews
Amici Grill and Pizzeria Pizza • $$
3808 Ridge Rd, Highland - 5.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Cajun Chicken Pasta
Salmon Burger
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Bread
French Fries
Caesar Salad
Cheese Pizza
Steak Hoagie
Pita Pizza

“Most of the time it seems just a little bit underdone and by the next time we eat it, it tastes fine. This time.... Perfectly cooked!! Thought my fingers were a little dark but the ?it's self tasted?, and the garlic bread knots..?loved them!“

4.6 Superb49 Reviews
Giuseppe's Pizza Italian • $
1000 Eagle Ridge Dr, Schererville - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza with Cherry Tomatoes
Pizza Napoletana Wood Fired
Chicken Parmigiana
Neapolitan Pizzas
Thin Crust Pizza
Fried Calamari
Lasagna Pasta
Tiramisu Cake
Garlic Bread
Penne Pasta

“I called for carry out. I asked if they were Neapolitan pizza? I was told yes. So I ordered a medium, Neapolitan pizza and what I recieved was not Neapolitan. This would have been a 5 star review had the crust been Neapolitan or had I just wanted a thin crust pizza. My issue is this is not Neapolitan pizza, even if it's very tasty pizza.“

4.4 Superb95 Reviews
T's Pizza & Family Restaurant Pizza • $
840 E 3rd St, Hobart - 6.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dill Pickle Pizza 7 69 10 69 13 79 17 59 21 29
Stuffed Green Pepper Soup
Broasted Potato Wedges
Make Your Own Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
T's Meat Pizza
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Pierogi Pizza
Small 10 Pizza

“Craving a slice of heaven? Look no further than T’s Pizza! ? From classic pizza pies to mouthwatering wings, they've got it all. Plus, have you tried their famous potato slices? They're like a flavor explosion in your mouth! ? The vibe inside is all about celebrating local pride, with nods to the Hobart High School Brickies everywhere you look. But the real stars of the show? The exceptional staff who always greet you with a smile and make you feel right at home. It's not just a pizza joint; it's a family-friendly haven where everyone feels welcome. Five stars all the way! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

4.4 Superb71 Reviews
Romano's Pizza • $
1927 W Glen Park Ave, Griffith - 6.63 miles

“Our food was great. Romano's has been a fixture in Highland since we moved there.I had the chicken parmesan sandwich, others had the roast beef and onion rings, chicken tenders and fries.They were all very good.Next time I will have the ham and mozzarella hoagie.I didn't have the hoagie this time because I had made hoagie's at home a couple days before. They were good but not quite the same as Romano's.I haven't had the roman burger lately but plan to another time.We have not tried the steak and cheese hoagie.“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
49 US-41, Schererville - 8.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Four-Cheese & Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Tomato Caprese with Fresh Burrata
Grilled Asparagus with Prosciutto
Carrabba's Italian Classics
Fettuccine Carrabba
Mozzarella Sticks
Fettuccine Weesie
Chicken Parmesan
Lobster Ravioli

“Candace served us this evening. There was a large birthday party and they did an amazing job accommodating everybody. Food was beyond phenomenal, and Candace’s service was incredible. She was very thorough with our orders and ensured our drinks were refilled before we reached the bottom. We will be back.“

4.2 Good104 Reviews
Pepino's Restaurant Italian • $
2410 Ontario, Schererville - 10.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepinos Favorite Ital Saus on Garlic Bread with Peppers Marinara Sauce
Combo Beef and Sausage Sandwich
Italian Meatball Sandwich
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Italian Beef Sandwich
Combination Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza
Fresh Cut Fries
Hand Cut Fries

“People ask me what I look forward to about coming home to Indiana and Italian beef sandwiches sit near the top of that list. I don't think people get it until they've tried one from northwest Indiana and Pepinos does it well! You can choose from Italian beef, Italian sausage or both. Your choice of cheese, mozzarella is standard. And then your choice of topping. I do giardiniera. Next time I might also try a side of red sauce. This shop was straight forward, clean, friendly, and delicious! Would happily return when back in town. Thank you!“

4.1 Good93 Reviews
Buona - Schererville Italian • $
324 Indianapolis Blvd #41, Schererville - 8.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Sandwich and Potato Salad
Italian Beef and Sausage Bowl
Italian Beef Sandwich
Italian Sausage Bowl
Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
Kids Buona Beef
Cheese Fries
French Fries
Beef Bites

“We fell in love with this place last year, so when we are in the area, we always come back. Ŵell it's starting to go downhill. Everytime we order, we always ask for them to not dip it and to put it on the side. Everytime they have dipped it, and my bread was soggy. That's a no go for me!! I may have to found another Italian beef shop instead. So sad :(“

4 Good71 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $
5504 E Lincoln Hwy, Schererville - 8.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Sausag Pepperoni Mushrooms Cheese Thin Crust
Pepperon and Sausage Pizza Slice
Meatball Parmigiana
The Chief Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Alfredo
Grilled Chicken
Boneless Wings
Italian Beef
Chopped Salad

“I asked Google what was my nearest pizza place with good pizza, Rosati's came up as #1. I did not have high expectations because as a Chicagoan I noticed food places don't taste the same as in the city. The lady that took my order was very friendly and happy to take my order. I got extra pizza sauce the way I ordered, unlike some pizza places, they charge but don't give it. Rosati's made my pizza just the way we love it. The cheese was a little extra cooked because of the extra sauce, the crust was crispy NOT burnt. Yuuuuumy! The wings were very meaty, and saucy. The price doesn't and shouldn't matter if the food is so worth it. I wish the blue cheese dip was made from scratch but everything else was perfect! Just moved in near by, so for sure we will be regulars! Thank you, you all should be proud of yourselves!“

4 Good66 Reviews
Bugatti's Steak and Pasta Steak House • $$$
777 Aldis Ave, East Chicago - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

18oz Prime Rib and Chicken Alfredo
Spicy Shrimp
Rack of Lamb
Onion Soup

“This restaurant has become one of my favorites restaurants. Tunc has been our waiter twice now and he is friendly, efficent and has gone above and beyond both times! We started with the Brushetta which was made beautifully, the olives are the staple of this appetizer. Main course we moved onto Prime - Rib Eye cooked medium (perfecto!) Mashed potatoes paired well Creamed spinach and had lemon miraigne cheesecake to finish off a delicious dinner! Pistachio chocolate mousse is a tasty too! Will be back again!“

4.1 Good14 Reviews
Livio's Restaurant Italian • $$
8267 Wicker Ave, St John - 10.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Sandwich and Onion Rings
Baked Stuffed Shrimp
Chicken Ceasar Salad
Linguine Ala Livio's
Double Baked Potato
Stuffed Pork Chops
Sausage and Peppers
Rigatoni Al Forno
Chicken Parmesan
Homemade Lasagna

“Livio's is the charming neighborhood restaurant we need. My husband and I have always had enjoyable experiences with the very sweet waitresses and we always have a filling and affordable meal. The ambiance is "old school", and I think that's what makes it feel a little special when we go there for date night. His favorite is the special steak with the dipping butter, (even though he's a porterhouse guy, this steak is his go-to at Livios), and the dish I can't get enough of is the mushroom ravioli. Bread and salad to start with a generous meal has always left us pleased. Whether you're sitting on the bar side or in the dimly lit dining room, you'll be comfortable and probably have a great time!“

3.9 Good73 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
1900 Southlake Mall, Merrillville - 8.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Seafood Fettuccine Alfredo
Never-Ending Soup Salad
Create Your Own Pasta
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Chicken Gnocchi Soup
Salad & Breadsticks
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana

“Been to this location many times and never really had an issue before. Today my special lady and I had a dinner date. And the lady with the purple hair (Chass?) was our waitress. She gave us the absolute best experience you could have at an Olive Garden. Friendly, very attentive, was NOT scared to spend some time grading cheese for our food, and definitely made us to want to come back soon! Thank you for giving us a good dinner date.“

3.9 Good107 Reviews
Windy City Pizza Kitchen Pizza • $
6208 Kennedy Ave, Hammond - 5.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Onion Ring Basket
Meatball Hero Calzone
Cheese Pocket Combo
Breaded Mushrooms
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Waffle Fries
Turkey Melt
blt Club

“I came in for a medium pepperoni and sausage pizza last night for a byop(pizza) party. I wasn't expecting much because I was unfamiliar with the area. I wasn't sure where the front was or where exactly to park but in the parking lot there was an area for pick up. So I parked there. When I walked in I got excited because it looked like a bar due to the lighting and full out bar stand. I thought I could get a drink and watch the game while I waited but the bar was definitely closed. Like they definitely don't serve alcohol there. The screens were nice to watch the football game on. There is a little service counter in the back and all of the staff were so excited and fun. My pizza was the star of the party. Everyone that had mine said it was their favorite. The pizza wasn't greasy. Or too meaty. The medium I ordered was enough for everyone and I don't believe I spend a full $20. Everyone who was familiar with the area said it tasted like Coaches Corner's pizza and later confirmed that that is where the sports bar was before it rebranded as a full blown pizza place. I'm not mad at it.“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
Jose's Family Restaurant Peruvian • $
2934 Highway Ave, Highland - 6.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ceviche Y Chicharron De Pescado
Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Homemade Peruvian Tamale
Chicken Parmesan Pasta
Ceviche De Pescado
Pan Con Chicharron
Chaufa De Pollo
Lomo Saltado
Lasagne

“Decided to try it on a whim and we were pleasantly suprised! Great service, first time trying Peruvian food and we will definatly be going back! Portion sizes are a little on the large size so go hungry! Definitely ask for recommendations if you are unsure what to try!“

3.8 Good52 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $$
1411 S Lake Park Ave, Hobart - 7.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Large Sausage Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper Pizza
Gluten Free Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks
Dough Nuggets
Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread
French Fries
Lasagna

“I'm very upset with MYSELF! I had tried a pizza from this location about 4 years ago when I moved to Hobart. The pizza was horrible! I did see it was under new management but never gave them another chance until today! I wish I tried it again a lot sooner! OMG, I just ate a meatballs sandwich on garlic bread! It was so darn good! All these years missing out on great food because of one bad experience, and it wasn't even their fault! It was the last management that messed it up!I'm definitely going to be a regular customer from here on in! I can't wait to get another sandwich!Give them a try if you haven't yet! Also the staff was super friendly and fast!“

3.7 Good30 Reviews
Loading...
map Map