50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Indianapolis

“I am not usually inclined to leave a review, but I feel as tonight's visit warrants a call out. As a parent that has a child with a gluten allergy we know the struggles of finding places out to eat. We have had Azzip a few times, but have always ordered ahead of time online then drove to the store to pick it up. This evening, we found ourselves out on errands and in the area and decided Azzip had been a safe choice in the past so we made our way there. The store was not busy, but there people ahead of us and behind us and I felt the protocol followed didn't slow the process terribly but I want to commend the staff for taking it seriously. What I witnessed: 2 people working the line making the pizza on the "ingredients" side of the oven. my kid informed them of the gluten free need and they asked if it was preference or allergy. my kid informed them of allergy. they cleared the line of the previous pizza being made once cleared, they stripped their gloves and cleaned the work space and the sauce bottle my kid wanted on their pizza a cooking mat from a separate area was produced and the cauliflower crust requested was added all the toppings requested were added then the pizza was placed in the oven. there was communication to the receiving team member that an allergen pizza was coming afterwards, my other kid and my pizza were started only after the 1st was placed in the oven. after the gluten free pizza came out of the oven, I noticed the cutting instrument was different than what was used for the other pizzas we ordered. Our experiences thus far is many people don't understand what Celiac disease is and how gluten can harm the body of those affected. It is more than just the ingredients consumed; cross contamination is the true problem. Seeing the team execute the procedure with care warmed my heart as I know it takes a lot of effort to create the process, then train to it and then to follow it. My appreciation to the team! We will definitely be back!“

“Everything was perfect wings were good and crispy. And pizza was A-1“

“I love Giordano’s, their deep dish is one of my favorites. The service is always good but our server, Tiffany, outdid herself tonight! Highly recommend!“

“en dehors d un accueil toujours chaleureux des pizzas excellente et un tarif plus qu abordable !“

“Fantastic experience! Hostesses right off the bat, were so helpful in accommodating 2 more high chairs. Food was definitely delicious! Christopher, our server, was so attentive, outgoing and personable! He gave excellent suggestions and even better service! We were a large group, which isn't always easy. We will definitely go back!“

“The pizza was hot, freshly made and we were finally able to enjoy a meat lovers pizza! Typically the meat ingredients are made with pork which we do not eat, but to my surprise, this establishment offered beef options such as beef pepperoni , beef sausage and turkey ham. Looks like we have found our new pizza spot and look forward to trying more from the menu.“

“Sam's Square Pie is amazing. This is the best Detroit style pizza ever. The staff is amazing and food is wonderful. highly recommend to everyone.“

“Great food and unique menu that adds a bit of goodness to an already old style pizza.“

“Damn good pizza. I mean really really good. They have an amazing Gluten Free option crust . It’s delicious. There is counter service , you order , pay and then they text you when it’s ready.there is one table on the main floor and that’s wheel chair accessible.
Lots of seat upstairs. You bus your own stuff, . Get the pizza . It’s so good!“

“I got a pepperoni pizza and the garlic bread. First time trying it. Food was delivered and was hot and fresh. Pizza has a familiar classic flavor which is absolutely delicious and what I was craving. Excellent cheese sauce. I tried to find something to complain about but couldn’t. This is perfect. Don’t change a thing!“

“We had an early dinner here. First time at the Spicy Donor, and don’t have much experience with Indian food, but really enjoyed the chicken Marsala. The food was really good but a little pricey. However, we had lots of leftovers, so we’ll get more meals from it. We’ll be back and bring others!“

“Love this pizza, definitely one of my favorites. Delicious sauce. Great service.“

“I would wait longer for this! Tried a little bit of everything and nothing disappointed!“

“Love their breadsticks. Got the budzza(stuffed pizza) for the first time last night. Two slices and one breadstick and I was so full I could barely walk back to the car. Price isn’t bad either. I spent less on the pizza, full order of sticks and 3 drinks than I did at Taco Bell.“

“I’m so happy we chose this spot for dinner. The vegan supreme is to die for. Order it with extra sauce! Their red sauce is INCREDIBLE — probably my favorite I’ve ever had. It’s really clear they make it fresh in-house. Highly recommend! The garlic bread is really good too.“

“Great pizza! So many memories, and the food is still wonderful! Thanks so much!“

“the pizza 🍕 is excellent and ALL Staff was very friendly and helpful“

“Great food. Stopped through while I was in town because you could smell the food from outside.“

“Amazing. Just like NY pizza 🍕“

“We ate at New Bethel Ordinary last Sunday after attending the IU/PU game. What a fabulous finish to a great day. The meat lovers pizza was over the top. Highly recommend....wish we could find a place like this in SWFL!!! Great place, TY!“

“Great food and great customer experience“

“We were looking for a place after shopping. Wonderful pizza & really good beer!“

“Went there yesterday, food was good, the server was good, but the problem being that the waitress decided to add in her own tip, I always put 000’s for the tip because I leave cash on the table, I happen to be looking on my bank info to see if the money had been taken out only to find out that she added an xtra $10, on my receipt, called the restaurant, the manager said it should be fixed in a couple of days, we shall see, make sure to check your receipt with your bank, no doubt this has happened before to someone else and they didn’t catch it“

“A Hidden Gem in Indy – The Pizza Palace California Style! If you haven’t tried The Pizza Palace California Style in Indianapolis, you’re seriously missing out! This 100% halal, Muslim- and Black-owned spot is doing some amazing things with pizza, and my husband and I are already planning our next visit. As a pescatarian, I was so excited to see their Shrimp Curry Pizza on the menu – something you definitely don’t see every day. My husband ordered the Jerk Chicken Pizza, and let me tell you, the food was beyond delicious. The shrimp was perfectly cooked, the curry flavor was on point, and the portions? Hearty and satisfying! By my third slice, I was full – which is rare for most pizza spots. We couldn’t even wait to get home. We parked and enjoyed the pizza in the car (it’s that good). The customer service was top-notch too. The young lady who helped us was super kind, fun, and informative – a total pleasure to chat with. The place was spotless, and the food came out fast. This is the kind of local small business you absolutely need to support. They’re doing something unique, and the quality is exceptional. If you're in the area or ordering on DoorDash, GrubHub, or UberEats, do yourself a favor and check them out at least once. Trust me, you won’t regret it! 🍕✨“

“Best pizza in Indy in my opinion. I live 25 miles away and it’s worth the drive“

“I don’t know who answers the phone at the Downtown location. But she is so nice and so professional. She helped me with the situation and was as kind as I would ever want to expect from somebody. Thank you so much. Also, we found this place by accident recently and we have fallen in love with Pizza so we really do enjoy going here.“

“good food dine in good prices“

“shout out to marco's pizza on Pendleton pike for awesome customer service an all I really appreciate you all Pierre Pearson“

“We have been buying pizzas here almost every week for the past couple of years and have never been disappointed with the taste or service. They know my order when I call and recognize me and greet me by name. And the 2 for 1 deal can't be beat!“

“Every time we eat at jets, we always get the barbecue chicken pizza, sometimes with the pineapple, but they are both wonderful and we get the detroit deep disvariation, and they are always very good, very filling. This time, we tossed in some breadsticks, which were really good and we enjoyed our meal immensely. Like a lot of bigger pizza places, the prices are always relatively expensive. And it can cost you a little bit to get one large pizza. Put some breadsticks l, and we got some wings. I forgot about that.The whole meal cost us about $60, I believe.“

“My favorite place to go before a Pacers game. Pizza is amazing and the staff always are top notch“

“Kaira with Offline - My Dad and I ate lunch here. The smoked wings were delicious. They do have a chili BBQ sauce on them. We weren't expecting the pickled veggies, but I enjoyed them also.

My Dad had the smoked pork chop. It was a good size and came with 2 sides. My Dad said it wasn't as tender as he would of liked. He has some partials in his mouth, so take that info as you may. 😆 Overall, he said it was good.

I had the pulled pork sandwich and fries. The seasoned fries were delicious. The pulled pork was alright. I felt it could of been seasoned more. I put bbq on it to help it along. Lol 😄 Overall it was decent.

I would return to try more menu items.“

“Really great food! Their pizza and chopped salad were wonderful! Good wine and great pumpkin goat cheesecake!“

“Their food is awesome ! If you walk away still hungry it's not their fault . It's a good place to go .“

“the pizza 🍕 is excellent and ALL Staff was very friendly and helpful“

“worst Marco's experience ever this evening. phoned in a delivery order at 605 pm. took over 10 minutes to take my order correctly. confirmed correct delivery address. was told about an hour for delivery. paid by card over the phone. hour and a half go by so I called to check on the order. was told they had the wrong address. I said it is the correct address, my home, was confirmed when ordering. was told then that I could come pick it up. was told they do not have delivery anymore tonight. asked if they were going to comp anything and was told no. said I could get a refund. no apology from mgmt. was told manager on duty's name was Mercedes. WORST experience at this location EVER“

“great service, food is amazing!“

“Hadn't been to Bazbeaux in quite a while. We decided to eat here on the way to an event at IU Indy and wanted to avoid the Taylor Swift crowds downtown. All three of us loved our pizzas and we all got something different. I would highly recommend the Mexican pizza. A 10" is enough to fill you up and have some to take home. The garlic cheese bread was incredibly good. Will definitely return in the future.

Parking: There's a lot outside. It was pretty full but we did manage to find a space our first trip through the lot.“

“This is a very convenient place to get pizza when my wife gets her hair done next door. And the pizza is very good. They will take an order to pick up later and it is always ready. They have lunch specials which we haven’t used yet, but they seem popular. Good variety of pizzas, reasonably priced.“

“Where to begin? You already know,the pizza is awesome. We are lucky enough to have Tony and his crew in Broadripple. We had a pizza that we were not happy with and Tony went out of his way to make things right. He personally greeted us and even made our pizza. It was perfect. Great pizza,great service, great experience. If you're not eating Goodfellas,there is a void in your life.

UPDATE:If Tony isn't there...leave. Last 3 orders have all been meh. The young light skin guy is nice but be majes a terrible pie. The young lady with the tattoos, super nice...makes a crap pie. Make sure Tony is there and I give them a 5,but the young/evening crew...zero.“

“I ordered a big order, with them around 8:30pm I went and picked the order up from the time I entered the building and until I left I was treated very well and they were very communicative with me. The manger on duty was top notch very respectful and polite and cared about you, and you can tell he loves his job I’m very thankful for people like him who run a good crew cause the crew was all kind as well and very positive and polite and professional than you all for you great work.“

“5⭐️ Very friendly & accommodating staff“

“Great place. Never disappoints.

9/15/24- Service was a little slow, but I heard there was only one server. Prices are high for basic pizza. I brought 2 kids and a large, one topping pizza with 8 bread sticks and 3 drinks was $46. So about $56, with tip. I feel like I could get a lot better pizza for that price. Prices seem to have just about doubled since COVID. I wish they offered some type of meal deal. I can get a large pizza and 2 liter from Jack's for half that. Obviously, the experience adds value, but there should be a more economical option.“

“Food was delicious, had the biscuits and gravy with fried potato's and bacon. Great atmosphere, very friendly patrons and staff.“

“We ordered ahead for a work function that we needed 3 of the 30” pizzas for. Due to our schedule of events we needed to pick the pizzas up around 10:30. They don’t open until 11 but because of our situation they opened early. I got there at 10:30 to pick up the pizza and as promised, they were all ready. Got them to work and they were delicious. Fed 33 people on 3 pizzas and still had leftovers. It was my first time having Cuginos but because of the excellent service and pizza, won’t be my last.“

“We order here at least monthly! Always so good and exactly what we want!“

“Today we had the best service we have had in a long time , We also enjoyed the nice atmosphere of the restaurant,
The employees were very helpful and the employee Amanda was the best we will be back every chance we are in Indianapolis“

“Folks- best fresh pizza I've had in years!
Deep dish the bomb! Perfect amount of ingredients and sauce Im a trucker I see a lot of states with pizza- this ranks #1!
Sad I don't live closer...... give this place a try will not dissapoint! Hot & fresh & tasty!!“

“By far one of my favorite places to eat from. I'm in love ❤️ with their pepperoni-stuffed breadsticks.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of salads ect. To pick from.

Dietary restrictions: If there were any restrictions I didn't see or notice them.

Parking: The parking is located in the back of the building. There are plenty of spots to park and it's safe.

Kid-friendliness: It's definitely kid friendly. They have a little coloring book & crayons for the smaller children.

Wheelchair accessibility: I'm almost positive I saw this there. Thank you.“

“Great food, fast service and super friendly employees!👏🏻🍕“