7 Best American Restaurants near Nappanee

“Outstanding homemade food and friendly staff! In town for business, my colleagues and I stopped for lunch. We were pleasantly surprised by the generous portions, outstanding taste and quality and great price! Our sever was wonderful, as were all of their staff. Another great place to add to our list when we’re in the area!“

“Good food and staff are so sweet to young kids.“

“Shout out to Hunters Hideaway Bar and Grill for hosting our 15 year class high school reunion! The Manager was so accommodating through the planning process. The staff and service was great and so organized the day of! Drinks and food were on point. Very pleased and grateful for such a fun day had by this Nappanee restaurant! Definitely recommend!“

“Chicken Marsala was 🔥last night! Perfect w Palenta and asparagus“

“Small Amish restaurant, but everything I've gotten so far has been the best I've eaten in a long while. Everything is made from scratch. There's a general store run by them too. It's right across the street. It has really good baked goods and fresh cheeses. Lots of bulk food too. The French toast is really stand out and even the breakfast sandwich was good. They are busy on weekends closed Sundays. But worth the wait.“

“My company ordered in lunch for us on Friday. Pizzas from Shortstop. Words can not adequately describe how good these pizzas were. Our area is really devoid of ANY good pizza. THIS is the pizza I've been looking for since we moved to the area years ago! I will be ordering regularly from this place. We also plan to go for dinner one day very soon. If the service is slow, we will be fine with it, as good help is VERY hard to find today. Learn to be patient with people doing their best under difficult circumstances.“

“My son and I like to try small locally owned restaurants and he suggested this one. So glad he did. The food was so good, very tasty! And the service was excellent. Fast, courteous, attentive. We ordered the bacon cheeseburger and a patty melt which came with chicken enchilada soup (the best we have ever had) and fries. We also ordered the potato bombs which were spicy and delicious. My son ordered the banana split waffle for dessert and the picture on the menu does not do it justice! He said it was just amazing. We will definitely be back! 5/5 stars!“