11 Best American Restaurants in New Albany

“Being a teacher, it's sometimes hard to make it to our favorite place due to the hours. But, it's summer now, so all bets are off! We made it in yesterday and it was fantastic, as always. Don't leave without grabbing a cookie. $5 for a fresh baked chocolate chip cookie that's the size of a small pizza and delicious when warm.“

“The best burger in the area. Super chill place to have a beer with friends.“

“Our waiter, Jeremy, was absolutely incredible!! He was such a fun personality (probably because he's a fellow Michigander 😉) and was full of great suggestions! He helped me secure the amazing skull glasses that I wanted to bring home by taking my side in my Valentine's Day argument with my husband. But truly, hands down, he was one of the best waiters we ever had!! The tacos were amazing! So many incredible combinations and the flight option allowed us to try multiple combos. The Filthy Fajita and the Gangsta were really good. And the margaritas were to die for. Highly, highly recommend! And make sure to ask for Jeremy! He will take amazing care of you!!“

“Love the shakes. You get your money’s worth and they are so good . I love the different flavos“

“I come to you're restaurant all the time, but today is a different story. I called to order and this is how it went. I told her what I wanted and she said ok bye and hung up. I was like really long story short i didnt pk up my food due to no time given to pk up and she never asked my name and was real short. Anyway I never pked it up, and I know she was someone new because this is not how they operate. Please hire better help until then I wont support.“

“Best Fish Sandwich Ever!!!!!“

“Was really good food and Abby was a sweetheart“

“would not let me use my gift card says that been hacked“

“Great .Steak n eggs!!Ut eas awesome!! yummy thank yoi my friend“

“We came and didn’t know what to expect. I had the fillet and John had the 20 oz. Ribeye. And they were melt in your mouth awesome. The salad bar is well stocked and has a wide assortment. The service was great and A big thank you goes to Rick for that. We will be back.“

“Great first experience. First off, my wife left her phone at the bar when we left and the Lady Bartender ran out to catch us and return it! Very much appreciated and we'll be sure to catch her again next time to show our thanks. The beer was good. Shakezilla was spot on for my wife's preferred flavor style. I had the Zombie Kombi and the Braun Jovi and both were good representations of their style. The Zucchini chips we excellent, very crisp. The Burger Slider and the Reuben sandwich were both very good and the fries were some of the best I've had anywhere. The only little negative was the 1000 Island Dressing, not sure if it was bottled or house made but it could be tarted up a bit...literally, I'd ad some lime juice or maybe a bit of Apple Cider Vinegar. It barely tasted like anything other than mayo. Oh, we finished with the Bread Pudding which was very good and not skimpy on the portion as we couldn't finish it and took it home for later. We're local, we'll be back.“