10 Best American Restaurants near New Carlisle

Monroes Crossing Inc American • $
7038 N Chicago Rd, New Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Mushroom Olive Pizza
Beer Battered Mushrooms
Friday Night Fish Fry

“Delicious fish fry! Good service and hospitable hosts. We enjoyed all you can eat fish fry in the dining room overlooking Hudson Lake.“

4.6 Superb47 Reviews
Billy Goat 9 & Dine American • $
755 W Michigan St, New Carlisle

Customers` Favorites

Supreme Pizza with 3 Times the Cheese
Reuben Sandwich with Onion Rings
Boneless Rib Tips and Fries
Side Winder Fries
Massive Calzone
Pepperoni Pizza
Protein Platter

“First time there last night - plan on returning ! The waitress was very attentive, patient and all around great ! The food was good , the atmosphere is small home town - there was 4 of us , we all got different entries and enjoyed them very much. Portion sizes are big ! We will be back to try the pretzel that covered a large plate ! Another table ordered it as we were eating our main entrees but it looked amazing“

3.9 Good144 Reviews
Froehlich's Kitchen & Pantry American • $
Recommended
19 N Elm St, Three Oaks - 8.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Colleen's Stuffed Brioche Brunch Toast Kit
Grilled Chicken Peanut Noodle Salad
Colleen's Pickled Chicken Sandwich
Sweet and Savory French Toast
Deconstructed Cinnamon Roll
Trifecta Pepper Burger
Three Oaks Opera Torte
Colleen' Clasic Combo
Beer Battered Walleye
Crispy Pan Spaghetti

“This is our first time visiting Three Oaks, and first time at Froehlichs. It’s a wonderful eclectic interior, and you can also buy all sorts of coffees, jams, candles etc in the back area. The foods was really good! We had the pepper burger and a corn elote salad with salmon. For dessert we had a mixed fruit mini pie (so fresh!) and the chocolate cake. Both delicious! Our server Jane was very nice and attentive as well. We will be back for breakfast!“

4.1 Good117 Reviews
Pejza's Lydick Patio Bar & Grill • $
26444 Edison Rd, South Bend - 6.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Avocado Bacon Club and Parmesan Fries
Chicken Avocado and Bacon Club Sandwich
Patty Melt Sandwich and Potato Salad
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
Mushroom and Swiss Burger
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Loaded Potato Pierogi
Tequila Pickleback
Smothered Chicken
Meatloaf Sandwich

“They have a wonderful staff and their cooking is amazing. It is a step above. We go there all the time and are always happy with food and service. Great place.“

4.7 Superb169 Reviews
Cameron's Restaurant American • $
1021 W Front St, Buchanan - 10.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Swiss Burger and Fries
1 2lb Bacon \u0026 Bleu Burger
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
Bacon and Bleu Cheese Burger
Mushroom Bacon Swiss Burger
Brisket and Mac and Cheese
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Philly Sandwich
Camerons Ham Sandwich
Blueberry Cheesecake

“Had a wonderful dinner with friends on the deck. Service was great, food was great and we had a wonderful time!“

4.1 Good85 Reviews
Staymaker Restaurant at Journeyman Distillery Pizza • $$
109 Generations Dr, Three Oaks - 8.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Featherbone Bourbon Hickory BBQ Sauce 12oz
Detroit-Style Breakfast Pizza
Heritage Angus Cheese Burger
Fig Old Fashioned Cocktail
Fried Brussels Sprouts GF
Hand-Cut Seasoned Fries
House-Made Pub Pretzel
The Journeyman Burger
Detroit Meets Italy V
House-Made Pretzel V

“This was our first visit to the Staymaker, which is the restaurant within the Journeyman Distillery. We are visiting from Chicago and this was recommended and we were not disappointed! Everything was really excellent! From our charming and attentive server Hailey, to the amazing smoked trout spread app to the Trout entree and the brisket meatloaf. It was all so delicious! We will be back!“

4.5 Superb160 Reviews
Bob's 19th Hole Restaurant and Bar Bar • $
26582 US-20, South Bend - 6.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black and Blue Burger with Fries and Side of Deep Fried Green Beans
Pollack Twice Baked Potato and Coleslaw
Steak Tips with Twice Baked Potatoes
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Fish and Chips Basket
Fried Pickle Spears
Smoked Pork Chops
19th Hole Nachos
Prime Rib Burger

“I’m here for work often, favorite place in the area by far. Highly recommend“

4.5 Superb123 Reviews
Little Tavern Bar • $
210 W Michigan St, Rolling Prairie - 6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Pork Mac and Cheese
Mushroom & Swiss Burger
Friday Night Fish Fry
Macaroni and Cheese
Baby Back Ribs
Fish Tacos
Craft Beer
Wings

“Tried here after being denied service at Nowhere in Rolling Prairie due to having my baby along for Father’s Day. So happy we did. This is a family friendly establishment with a very nice staff, excellent food, and a nice atmosphere. Will absolutely recommend and return.“

4.6 Superb73 Reviews
Twisted Tiki Sports Bar & Pizzeria Pizza • $
7954 E State Hwy 4, Fish Lake - 9.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Platter Waffle Fries and Mac and Cheese
Generous Portion of Meat Choices
Spare Rib \u0026 Smoked Sausage
Chopped Brisket Sliced Brisket
Spare Rib & Smoked Sausage
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Cheeseburger No Bun
Pizza Extra Cheese
Loaded Bloody Mary
Twisted Za Pizza

“We love visiting and getting takeout from Twisted Tiki. The service is always great and the food is tasty.“

4.4 Superb106 Reviews
Jennie Rae's Family • $
5201 US-20, Rolling Prairie - 4.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak
Breakfast Croissant
Biscuits and Gravy
French Toast
Homemade Jam
Cheeseburger
What a Mess
Hamburger
Pot Roast
Chicken

“This was my first time here. This is a quaint hometown breakfast and lunch restaurant in New Carlisle, Indiana. Our booth had comfortable seats and it was situated right over one of the heat ducts which made itnice and warm the entire time we were there!. Our server was polite and checked on us often enough to keep our drinks filled. I had the BLT club sandwich which was a triple decker! It was grilled with butter on the outside slices of bread and the tomatoes were nice and ripe and it had ample bacon slices. It was actually the best BTL I’ve ever had! My husband had the BBQ pork sandwich and said it was very delicious. I highly recommend Jennie Rae’s for hometown good cooking!“

4.2 Good116 Reviews

You May Also Like