12 Best Sandwich Shops in Noblesville

“My experience here today was wonderful! From the moment I walked in the staff was very friendly, unhurried and pleasantly speaking. The facility was very clean and organized and let me tell you the sandwich was just as ordered hot and delicious! I would highly recommend this restaurant if you’re in the mood for something special make it this Jersey Mike’s! ❤️“

“Had lunch there yesterday…food, service and atmosphere fantastic …such a warm hug of nostalgia and great food . The waitresses could not have been nicer!!!! We will be back🥰“

“McAlister’s has been nothing but a blessing for our family since 2012.

For 13 years, we have been at this restaurant sharing fellowship with friends over sweet teas, playing board games on their four-chair flattop tables late into the evening on date nights, grading homework and writing lessons, and getting to know the people who serve at McAlister’s.

It’s become a second home for us, and I felt the need to write a small review on Google to share the joy it is to be a part of a company that cares and commits to high quality service in all they do.

When my wife and I were backpacking Europe, we loved the cafes to sit and eat and enjoy the areas we were exploring. In the States, cafes are not really a staple in communities like they are in places like London or France. I can still remember walking to a café on a Sunday night full of crowded people still having a merry time with family and friends. Our culture isn’t in the same sort of social capital, but man, we ache for those experiences.

McAlister’s provides that sense of nostalgia for our traveling in the sense that it brings great crowds of people after church on Sundays, opens its door until late in the evening, and always has a caring staff to connect and share life with. We always found a space each week to connect with the people who serve in this establishment, and it’s the reason why we’ve been going for so many years.

From Brendan Shupe, the current general manager, sharing tips to his employees in personal finance or celebrating the birth of Chris’s son, Henry, there are people there who are deeply rooted to serving others the sweet tea goodness, laughs, and a simply ‘hug’ in food.

I know that there are so many places we can try and experience in this very competitive market and world in the States, but McAlister’s has done something truly unique for us.

They set a high standard of an atmosphere that transcends restaurant into a place of comfort and feeling of home.

For that, we’ll be entertaining ourselves in their ‘café’ for unforeseeable future!

Highly recommend for family, community, and a sense of great joy!“

“Customer service outstanding!“

“Very nice staff“

“great food fresh salad fun atmosphere 😋“

“Clean. The food was delicious. My steak and cheese was not cooked all the way (seemed raw) and I took it up. They apologizes and remade it right away. It was perfect even though lots of other had just come in. Well handled. Would eat again.“

“What a change from prior years. This place has really improved with Great seating and bright atmosphere. The Food is prepared by the super friendly staff who really engage with the customers.

Parking: Pull in front of the store or at the many other spaces..“

“I was just so glad to eat this awesome sub this big fella made me. I think his name wasdrew(Andrew page, 6’4 1/2 330 LB’s) made me a meaty 12 incher and I enjoyed every last bite of it. God bless you drew, never been so full of meat like that in my life!“

“Food is good... the Walmart Subway location in Noblesville is meant to only be a carryout only location with the lack of indoor seating. But it is convenient if you are doing your grocery shopping at Walmart anyway. If you are wanting to dine in, you're better off going over to the Retail Center location just around the corner from Walmart... other than that service is great and food is good!“

“The sandwiches are typically consistent and good here. The soda from the fountain is actually great. I order through the app and the food is always ready when I get there. Unfortunately, the app has some hiccups and for several orders I have not been able to receive my rewards points.“

“This location is always very fast. However, in the past 6 months, seemingly, each time I pick up sandwiches, I end up with at least one sandwich being completely wrong. I'm not certain what has caused the change but it leaves much to be desired.“