12 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sheridan

“This was definitely one of the best Dairy Queens I have ever been to! The staff was so friendly, fast service , and the most delicious food! Also, this establishment was immaculate! I recommend this Dairy Queen in Sheridan, IN, highly and will be eating there a lot!“

“We here a Twin Kiss are not running this site nor are we affiliated with Google in any way please see our page on facebook because things posted here are not always accurate. We post our openings and closings on facebook and Sheridan Chatter not on Google.“

“always great desserts Customer focused workers According to Nyx, the BEST pup cups“

“We went to a concert at The Nickel District Amphitheatre in Fishers and I have to say how impressive it was to see the very young girl working this truck take orders, make sales, and deliver food to waiting customers like it was nothing. She sets a fine example for the youth of today. The food was delicious and we went back several times. Worth every penny! Highly Recommend😊“

“The girls were so polite today 7-31-25 I had the Founders favorite and I switched only the ice cre to banana pudding OMG IT WAS SOOOOO GOOD! I THIBK THIS WILL BE MY GO TO. Very clean and fast service! I will return. My daughter had the Oreo overload with M&m in it she loved it!! Nice dessert date. Great tasty icecream.“

“I absolutely love Crumbl cookie so much so that we are having them catered for our wedding! I will say though, the manager for this location was quite rude to my fiance and I when we came in to place our 200+ catering order. We ended up working very closely with one of the bakers - so incredible nice - she deserves a promotion in my opinion!“

“Great place to go for a delicious meal. I had the single paty butter burger dress the way I like it. Definitely a good value for the money. I ordered the basket to complete my order. This includes a drink and fry.
Check out this place soon.“

“I recently visited Culver’s and was impressed from start to finish. The food was outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and served piping hot. Their famous ButterBurgers were juicy and perfectly seasoned, and the custard was as creamy and rich as everyone says.

The customer service was just as memorable. Every team member I encountered was friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. They checked in to make sure everything was right without being intrusive, which made the meal feel special.

Speed was another highlight. Even though the restaurant was busy, my order was prepared quickly and accurately. It never felt rushed, just efficiently handled.

Finally, the cost is more than fair for the quality you receive. The portions are generous, and you truly get excellent value for your money.

Overall: Culver’s delivers a winning combination of delicious food, top-notch service, quick turnaround, and reasonable prices. It’s an easy five stars and a place I’ll happily return to again and again.“

“good food, great staff!!!“

“Great customer service for Ava’s 1st ever ice cream cone. Ava loved it and has since asked about the “ice cream store”. 🤗“

“I have been in several of these places and have always been pleased. The service was great, the food was good, and the root beer is always good. We were in a rush to get to Bible class, and they got our food out quickly, correctly, and tasted good!“

“I love sonic and will go get a twisted flamingo here and there which is not on the menu so i get a cherry limeade and add sweet cream its amazing. However, they tend to always leave out the sweet cream, most of the time I just leave it alone and drive away cause mistakes happen and i dont mind a regular cherry limeade, this time i went back through the drive thru asked for a small cup of sweet cream for two RT44 drinks and i get half of like a kids cup to spilt between two drinks. Didnt want to sound like I was complaining about it so i just drove away. Just be mindful of what customers are ordering since this has been a consistent issue with my order:(“