15 Best Ice Cream Shops in Fishers

“My lovely bride and I stopped by for some delicious ice cream. She had PB chocolate chunk and I had the black cherry. She liked hers but thought it could use a touch more PB for her taste. I thought mine was fine. Quite a few people here but the staff was quick and efficient. Yeah a little pricey for ice cream but I figure it’s Fishers so their overhead has to be kinda high. We will be back.

Parking: Lots of parking available“

“Great ice cream and customer service!“

“Just a hot day and fancy popsicles in a very chic location. Just the right combo! I tried the vegan POG passion fruit, orange and guava and the Strawberry Rhubarb. Both the flavors were so different and extremely flavorful. Each lick was a different taste and summery vibes all along.The store is spacious and the lines go pretty quick. I, for one found the price pretty accurate. Service was really good where the server took the time out to share the ingredients, that was helpful since I wanted vegan only.“

“Normally I am a very big tipper. On their order screen inside the store it states that if they made me smile please tip or something similar to that. These young people at the Fishers, IN location have never greeted us, never smiled or made us smile, and have quit showing us the boxed cookies. Either they’re very unhappy, overworked, underpaid or just rude. There’s just a bad vibe inside the store and it’s really sad. It wasn’t like this last Fall/Winter. Something has changed and I won’t tip for that type of service.“

“Friendly service as always! Love all the flavor options!“

“This is our goto spot for ice cream cravings... I don't know what else to say? They are superior to all other shops... go and try it, tell me I'm wrong, I'll wait! :)“

“There are always tasty frozen treats to have here. Mix and match your favorite custard and Italian ice for the delicious "gelati" or add a topping and have it all mixed together for a blendini. Whatever you choose, it's a nice change up from your standard ice cream shops.“

“After passing this place by over the course of a month or so, we finally decided to step in to see what it was about. The decor is very “lounge”-like, but it’s comfortable. The place is clean, they seem very organized, and overall the environment is inviting. The ordering can be a little tricky since they have a menu to view but they encourage the QR Code to view the menu on your phone. So if you’re not tech-savvy or forget your phone, that’s something to be aware of.

The variety of options is decent - not too little, not too overwhelming. I picked the pistachio waffle with the scoop of pistachio gelato on top, and my friend picked one apple cinnamon crepe and then small scoop of vanilla gelato. The prices are a bit high but the portions are generous, I think. We spent almost $50 - one waffle, one crepe, one small scoop. When they brought it to our table, we were a bit overwhelmed with the amount of chocolate! It’s delicious but it is a bit too much. There isn’t an option to have less chocolate so if you’re diabetic, you’ll have a hard time enjoying the meal without worrying about your blood sugar. ? We both scooped more than half the chocolate from out/off our stuff.

Overall, the experience was great. The food was tasty! Just perhaps the option to have a light chocolate topping or even chocolate on the side?“

“Hot dog sauce is amazing. Service was fast and efficient. My Granddaughter and I enjoyed eating eating there. I would recommend this place to anyone that enjoys a great hot dog . The ice cream is delicious also

Kid-friendliness: The Tv has kid friendly channels playing to keep the younger kid’s occupied“

“Picked up birthday cakes for my kids. The manager was helpful and placed names on both cakes quickly and spelled correctly (I know that sounds weird, but it is a plus!). A bit pricey for the cakes, but inflation hit everywhere, so wasn't unexpected.“

“Tough location to see and get in and out of but a gem well worth it. Stopped in to get my birthday donuts. Love cake donuts and warm icing! The teens working were very nice and wished me a happy birthday! Donuts aren't just for breakfast :)“

“Stopped by on the way home from picking up the kid from school. I like that they have real onion rings and not that processed onion mash shaped like rings a lot of places serve. The burger were descent. Good, but not great. Totally worth the price though. A great product with solid bang for your buck. I don't have much experience with cheese curds, but these were good and I'd order them again. I also love the dilly bar and blizzards from here also, which is honestly 80% of my reason for stopping here.“

“I don't know why we don't go to Culver's more often, the food was got and quite good! We got the 3pc cod dinner, and it was almost too hot to eat right away (that's a good thing), and my husband got a concrete mixer, which was also delicious (don't recall the flavor). We will definitely be visiting more often!“

“Came to visit some family here, from Florida and we stopped by to eat here, place was clean, we ordered quick, the wait wasn't long, the staff was friendly and the food was fresh. The burger and the Oreo shake were really good. Overall good experience.“

“I hate to make a negative review, but why is it nearly every time I get boba here it's al dente in the worst way? It's like a mix of soft and mostly hard boba ?‍? like come on...it makes my stomach hurt..
I'm leaving a review bc once again...it happened. I have already had to complain previously about it and even some of the staff is aware of who is making bad boba.. and I promise you, it is not hard to make boba correctly lol. It used to not be this consecutively shiddy. I know this stuff will sell itself but please stop making hard boba..the recipe is right there lol

Anyways, staff is nice and knowledgeable of the menu. The Interior could be freshened up a bit. Drinks are good. My main concern is just the boba bc it's the most important thing.

Parking: Parking lot gets filled up but there is also some street parking“