14 Best Ice Cream Shops in Fishers

“Visited Fishers location - so glad I did! Non-dairy lemon chill was pleasantly creamy (expected it to be tart like sorbet, but it was mild and delicious!) - and non-dairy caramel was amazing! So nice to have non-dairy flavors with flare! My son had cake batter and crazy cookie - loved them both! Our new go-to for ice cream - thanks, Eiffel Waffle!😎“

“I bought 12 minis, they were all pretty decent, my favorite was probably the cake batter one. My only complaint would be that because of how big a regular cookie is, I figured the minis would be a regular cookie size but it was smaller and a little on the hard side. Still love crumbl and am happy to stop in any chance I'm near one!!“

“Walk up counter service offering many varieties and flavors of high-quality homemade ice cream. There is usually a small wait because it is popular. During warmer months there is nearby outdoor seating. I usually visit Handel's when in Fishers.“

“The chocolate crepe was fantastic and tasted just as delicious as it looked. Alex was very kind and caring in helping me customize my crepe. Abdul, the manager I believe, brought out my food to me and checked if I needed anything else. Amazing service and food 100/10“

“Great ice cream and customer service!“

“One dark chocolate a day makes your day!“

“We love Nicey Treat popsicles and rented the cart for dessert at our wedding reception! Delicious and everyone loved it! Highly recommend!“

“This is our goto spot for ice cream cravings... I don't know what else to say? They are superior to all other shops... go and try it, tell me I'm wrong, I'll wait! :)“

“My brother and Mom finally got to try Rita's for the first time this Mother's Day. We had a hot fudge sundae and two different gelatis (one with vanilla custard and cherry ice and the other with pistachio custard and georgia peach ice). All of them were delicious. It was a great finish to the day. Order happiness here.“

“The best place to get ice cream in town!! I really enjoy the time i was there due to the great staff, especially Kam, the way he made my ice cream was so professional and beautiful. I could not have been more satisfied with my service and all at a reasonable price!!!“

“My wife and I drive from Greenfield to this D.Q. because there hamburgers literally look even better in real life than there pictures do and tastes as good as they look!!“

“-Absolutely Amazing 🥹
I grew up with the one in Fortville and saw it go out of business from really bad customer service and cleanliness. Who ever gives this less than 4 stars is on Crack and doesn't know how good they have it. I ordered online in the store because they were busy and received everything within 5 minutes. I used to run 2 Five Guys locations this food was definitely fresh, hot, and Amazing!!!!
Thank you Dairy Queen❤️ my tummy is full“

“Ordered food at the drive thru on 5/13/26 @ 9 pm, employee unchanged one of the orders, I said clearly one single butterburger combo, got the cheese right this time but entered a dbl butterburger instead. Topping and condiments were scarce, drink tasted watered down and very little carbonation in the Coke. Very disappointed. The last three times I've stopped at a Culvers they unchanged because they half listen or don't omit cheese when asked.“

“Excellent burgers 🍔 & shakes“