Ice Cream Shops near Fortville

“Great local ice cream shop. I've tried several flavors in a dish and they are all good. I usually get a sundae though. Libby's makes THE BEST! Don't forget to check the freezer too. The ice cream sandwiches and brownies are good too.“

“The place was good and very fairly priced. We just had ice cream, but they also have fudge, caramels, and other assorted chocolate goods. It's in a huge, weird building that clearly used to be something else (maybe an old movie theater?). There's a cool 50s-style bar ice cream bar in the center, but rest of the decor/environment is bad. The AC is incredibly loud and the whole place has a warehouse/Costco feel.“

“Oh my! Our new fave ice cream spot! Our old favorite went out of business in Anderson so now we're thrilled to drive another 10 minutes to cute downtown Pendleton for their awesome ice cream. They have some wonderful and unique flavors (Exhausted Parent, really? LOL)My only wish is that they can upgrade their two little outside cafe tables, kind of rickety, but there is a sturdy bench close by. There is plenty of inside seating if you go in inclement weather.“

“Love this place! So convenient in the Hamilton Town Center shopping area. The bowls and smoothies are always made fresh and super tasty. I’ve tried almost all the items on the menu and never disappointed! One of my favorites is the Apple Up bowl!“

“We’ve been to this location probably more times than I should share lol BUT for Christmas we ordered Ohanalulu donuts and 3 quarts of ice cream for my oldest son’s physical therapy team. He’s had a long 3 months with several more to go in his recovery and I couldn’t think of a better way to share a little Christmas joy. The employee that prepared it all was so amazing and then actually gifting it all just went above and beyond my expectations. Thank you, Ohanalulu for being a huge part of sharing some joy in a place that fights to help people win back their joy every day!! We will continue to support your business!!“

“Absolutely delicious! I was blown away at how amazing these all were - gs cookie tagalong, maple bacon, reese's pieces, sprinkles & raspberry malasadas's. Loved the donut wall in the dining room & the fast friendly service as well.“

“My wife has become an ice cream snob after discovering this gem of a shop. The Mint Avalanche cannot be topped by any other ice cream store in greater Indianapolis by her standards. She's not ashamed to admit that she makes noises while consuming this delightful confection.The owners are sweet (wink, wink....) people who are friendly and helpful, always ready to offer up suggestions on new flavors. Oh, don't turn down the malted milk ball at the bottom of your waffle cone, nice touch!!“

“My first time here was today, 09/15 around noon. I asked the kind man behind the counter what he recommends. The said everything was vegan and the brownies and chocolate chip cookies are great. He also stated that the cupcake is good too. I went with his first suggestion and I'm glad I did. The brownie was very good. I only wish I could have warmed it up. If I'm ever in the area again, I definitely give them another visit.“

“Always my favorite place and my kiddos, but today we call to make a order and the person that answer the phone state he don’t warranty the ice cream that I consumed before was dairy free . I was like what??? , been buying ice cream and never any reaction and just call because want to know what flavor they have today. The call was made at 2:58 pm.Hope the employees be aware about how they will manage allergies and the importance of give the right information to clients.Again, never ever have a reaction after eating there dairy free products and always my best choice for Ice cream, just the employee was not helpful.“

“Mmmmm. Brusters is very good! I would say it's a little much expensive than some of the other shops around but it's good! My favorite flavor so far has been a seasonal one that was a almond wedding cake flavor with black raspberry jam in it. Please bring it back and I will come daily!!“

“Thanks to the woman working at the counter (Michelle) today for being such a kind person and going out of her way to make sure my pickup order was perfect and easy for me to take home. Made such a big difference in my day and I appreciate it so “