11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pendleton

Yummerful Ice Cream Shop • $
125 W State St, Pendleton

“Oh my! Our new fave ice cream spot! Our old favorite went out of business in Anderson so now we're thrilled to drive another 10 minutes to cute downtown Pendleton for their awesome ice cream. They have some wonderful and unique flavors (Exhausted Parent, really? LOL)My only wish is that they can upgrade their two little outside cafe tables, kind of rickety, but there is a sturdy bench close by. There is plenty of inside seating if you go in inclement weather.“

4.9 Superb27 Reviews
Ohanalulu Donut Shops •
106 W State St, Pendleton

Customers` Favorites

Donut Breakfast
Pinapple Whip

“We’ve been to this location probably more times than I should share lol BUT for Christmas we ordered Ohanalulu donuts and 3 quarts of ice cream for my oldest son’s physical therapy team. He’s had a long 3 months with several more to go in his recovery and I couldn’t think of a better way to share a little Christmas joy. The employee that prepared it all was so amazing and then actually gifting it all just went above and beyond my expectations. Thank you, Ohanalulu for being a huge part of sharing some joy in a place that fights to help people win back their joy every day!! We will continue to support your business!!“

4.5 Superb50 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
3001 US-36, Pendleton

Customers` Favorites

Heath Blizzard Treat

“Love the chicken strip basket with gravy! You have to dunk the chicken strips and the fries in the gravy. ALL of the ice cream is great also but it's really hard for ice cream to not be great.Parking: Parking lot is small but Needlers parking lot is huge and basically connected to DQ.Kid-friendliness: They have a normal kids menu. Hamburger, hot dog and chicken fingers along with a few other kid friendly items.Wheelchair accessibility: I'm in a wheelchair myself and I am able to get around the parking lot. They do have handicap parking and wheelchair ramps. Inside is a little cramped but I am still able to wheel around. The bathroom is also tight but it is usable.“

3.6 Good27 Reviews
Jimmie's Dairy Bar Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
Pendleton

Customers` Favorites

Tangerine Soft Serve Ice Cream
Fried Mushrooms & Onion Rings
Soft Serve Ice Cream Cones
Twist Ice Cream Cone
Tenderloin Sandwich
BBQ Sandwich
Steakburger
Coney Dog
Fries

“Tangerine soft serve ice cream was (and I don’t mean to be dramatic here) the missing piece of my life. I could share the story of the day that led to my first TangerinExperience, but instead I’ve come up with further reasons to enjoy this delicacy and would like to share them with you.Here, then, is an incomplete list of occasions that deserve Tangerine Soft Serve from Jimmie’s Dairy Bar:- The Sunday Scaries- Weather is too hot- Weather is too cold- Weather is perfect- Just got paid- Ten minutes after getting paid and bank account has $8 balance- Feeling a little sick- Feeling great- You need a Dole Whip but are actually quite far from a Disney parkCelebrations, such as:- Second cousin’s half birthday- Boss is on vacation- Sneezed to completion when you had a nose tickle and thought you were only gonna get halfway through the sneeze and then get left hangingWhat you need to know:- Pictured is a “large” Tangerine Soft Serve in a cup. This is the smallest acceptable size if you love yourself. I did have a lil taste before taking this picture, my apologies.- Drive through is faster than you expect, even if you order food.- They do take Visa & Mastercard, though you’ll have to order at least two Tangerine Soft Serves to get to the $5 minimum. This is not a problem, and you don’t even need to pretend that you’re taking the other one to someone who isn’t with you. You’re allowed to get as much as you want, just for yourself.- The building is painted with a tangerine orange accent color and I appreciate the continuity of the theme, giving me the full Tangerine Experience.In addition to Tangerine Soft Serve, there is a larger menu. I suggest reviewing this in advance, the menu at the drive through is not comprehensive and you’ll be in a full panic to order. ProTip: obsessively practice saying your order in your head and out loud numerous times as you approach the drive through.I’ve had the tenderloin and the chicken sandwich. Visually these are identical so pay attention when you receive your food. They were on toasted buns but they were otherwise barren so you might ask for condiments if you require such things. I don’t care to dirty up my fried food with fresh vegetables but you do you.Making your sandwich a platter will add fries and your choice of slaw OR baked beans. Again, review this in advance as it’s not a decision to be taken lightly. The slaw complements a fully deep fried meal with a satisfyingly sweet and tangy crunch, while the beans are presented in a rather soupy format with sauce to spare for your sandwich. I think next time I’ll try the BBQ sandwich with slaw - the sign out front said it’s the best BBQ in Indiana, and though that seems very ambitious one does have to trust Jimmie as he hasn’t let me down so far.Wherever you’re coming from, this is worth the drive to enjoy a delicious piece of history in beautiful Pendleton. Grab some food and head to nearby Falls Park for the picnic you’ve been dreaming of, or just shovel it all in your face on your way home. However you choose to enjoy it, you’ll be glad you did.“

3.5 Good55 Reviews
Uranus Indiana Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt •
1423 W 53rd St, Anderson - 5 miles

“Definitely worth the drive. Got my fudge pad ked so good the first time, I came back for another packing! Hilarious and friendly staff, on theme everything, and the music really make this a place worth visiting. You'll have a ton of fun poking around Uranus for sure!“

4.6 Superb119 Reviews
Frazier's Dairy Maid Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
3311 Main St, Anderson - 6.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lil Bit of Heaven Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
Orange Sherbet Vanilla Twist Ice Cream
Lemon Strawberry Twist Cone
Blue Moon Vanilla Twist
Upsidedown Banana Split
Cherry Cordial Flurry
Small Turtle Sundae
Mozzarella Sticks
Hot Fudge Sundae
Ice Cream Cone

“The service there is great the food an icecream is great. It's super busy so there is a wait . They have a few outside tables an picnic tables to sit on to eat outside , no inside eating no bathrooms to public. It's really close to a busy road so hold on to your children. It's a great family owned place ... Everyone loves it plus they have blue moon icecream witch no other place does so that's a major bonus.. lol.“

4.4 Superb55 Reviews
Libby’s Ice Cream & Gifts Ice Cream Shop • $
11 S Main St, Fortville - 6.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Flight

“Great local ice cream shop. I've tried several flavors in a dish and they are all good. I usually get a sundae though. Libby's makes THE BEST! Don't forget to check the freezer too. The ice cream sandwiches and brownies are good too.“

4.7 Superb26 Reviews
La Michoacana Coco Ice Cream Shop • $
320 E 14th St, Anderson - 6.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak Taco

“I came here with my husband and kids, plenty of food and it was FABULOUS! It was very clean. The lady was very nice too, great customer service. I ordered the piña loka and my husband ordered the mangonada. My kids both got ice cream pops and they loved them too. All around great experience! I urge everyone to try it!“

4.6 Superb24 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
6386 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson - 6.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double Butterburger with Onion Rings
Pretzel Bites & Cheese Sauce
Butter Burger and Fries
Broccoli Cheese Soup
Single Butter Burger
Tenderloin Sandwich
Chicken Strip Basket
Cod Fish Sandwiche
Cheesecake Pieces
Crinkle Cut Fries

“A group of 6 friends met & ate @ Anderson Culver's. (Kind of centrally located for the group.) We met @ 11a and stayed & "talked/ visited" till about 3p. The food was good and three different employees came (@ different times) and offered any assistance needed. They each encouraged us all to fill out the surveys on each receipt. Each were very friendly. DAVID checked on us several time & even stopped a moment to thank one of our ladies for her service in the military. Manager Chris also stopped by & introduced himself.“

4 Good101 Reviews
Gene's Root Beer and Hot Dogs Hot Dogs • $
640 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson - 9.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spanish Dog with Fries and a Bag of Onion Rings
Fried Mushrooms Tenderloin Sandwich
Coney Dog with Shredded Cheese
Spanish Dog and Onion Rings
Spanish Dog with Onions
Spanish Dog with Cheese
Coney Dog with Onions
Breaded Cheeseburger
Chicken Sandwich
Spanish Sauce

“I've reviewed Gene's before but it's worth another mention. This is a classic drive in with NO indoor seating. The food is terrific and, despite recent increases, it's very reasonably priced. Drive in, make sure you get a mug of root beer. Specialties are the Spanish dogs but the slaw dogs and fried mushrooms are great too. Whenever I'm in Anderson, this is one of about four places I try to get to.“

4 Good90 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
501 S Scatterfield Rd, Anderson - 9.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Royal Ultimate Choco Brownie Blizzard Treat
Small Chocolate Brownie Extreme Blizzard
Choco Brownie Extreme Blizzard Treat
Chicken Strip Basket
Grilled Chicken blt
Double Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Chicken Fingers
Side of Fries
Galaxy Cake

“Love love love DQ. They once had a cook named Shaun I believe he was really good but we haven't seen him in a while regardless it Ice cream at it best . Can't go wrong there!!!!Parking: Lots of room. Drive-thru is kinda crowded but still worth the wait definitely!“

3.6 Good55 Reviews
Loading...
map Map