Old Mill Tasty Shop
$ • Sandwich Shops, Ice Cream, MexicanAbout Old Mill Tasty Shop
Customers' Favorites
Homemade Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing and Pecans
Chicken Salad Sandwich and Chips
Ruben Sandwich and Baked Beans
Chicken Fried Chicken
Hot Turkey Pastrami
Blue Plate Special
Smothered Burrito
Seafood Crab Salad
Chips & Salsa
Reuben Sandwich
Old Mill Tasty Shop Reviews
292 ratings
Share your opinion about Old Mill Tasty Shop
Wonderful atmosphere and service . Delicious old fashioned ice cream!!
WE had the lunch special on Monday. Best chicken enchildas WOW
foods are tasty there. comfortable place. had fun there.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 3PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Old Mill Tasty Shop is a charming restaurant steeped in history, with original features like a soda fountain and hutch. The aroma of food wafting from the door is tantalizing, and the menu offers a range of delicious options, including hot pastrami on marbled rye and open-faced seafood salad. The milkshakes are a standout, with plenty of flavors to choose from, and the servers are always friendly. Vegetarians will appreciate the variety of options, including a tasty pita stuffed with hummus. Visitors often enjoy the old-timey atmosphere, friendly staff, and great sodas. The food is excellent, with favorites like chicken fried chicken and crab salad sandwich. Many customers praise the gluten-free bread and the delicious carrot cake, considering the place a fun, old-fashioned soda shop where the food tastes like good home cooking.