32 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“2024 Update: Still a popular restaurant in Middletown. The entire staff are so nice & friendly & the food is yummy!!!Coals Artisan Pizza in Middletown is a favorite. The pizza are cooked in "coal-fired oven", which makes a uniquely lighter tasting crust. There are lots of great choices & many different toppings offered. The pizzas are regionally named for Louisville Metro area neighborhoods. Our favorite pizzas include the "Middletown, Crescent Hill & Brownsboro pizzas". There is a nice dining room, outdoor patio and a party room which can be reserved which has a large TV that accommodates up to 40 people. There is a nice wine list and excellent local draft beers choices as well.Highly recommend & as always the staff do a great job.“

“Wow--my son and his friends did a scavenger hunt for his birthday. Jet's was the lunch stop. Not only did the employees let me write a clue in the pizza box, they gave him a bonus dessert with the order. So kind, thoughtful, and special. Thank you!!Oh, and the pizza tasted great!“

“I was confused by the Italian name, but they do offer both Italian and Afghan food. Apparently the owners lived in Italy and also are from the Afghan region, so that helps it make more sense. Nice to be able to try some new food and it was very good. Family owned and run restaurant. We will be back!“

“The service was excellent & very personable, the food was delicious( especially the stuffed shells) Thanks to our server Sean & chef Michael! It was my first time, had the opportunity to dine “in the kitchen” GREAT experience & atmosphere.We will be back!“

“Absolutely delicious!! I had fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and broccoli, Cesar salad, and ended with Italian cream Cake. Recommend it highly. My hubby had linguini with calms and my daughter had the pork chop. Our meals were the bomb! Can’t wait to go back.“

“Was picking up some ingredients and decided to grab lunch. 4 stars solely because the chicken parm sandwich was not their best creation. It's a warm sandwich and the flavors just were not there for me. It got a little soggy and I think my picky eater gene just turned on. I think I'll stick with cold sandwiches from them. I did finally get to try their focaccia, and OH MY GOODNESS. Why did no one tell me that I would sell my soul for a piece of garlic-y bread?? Their garlic focaccia has got to be the best one. It does have large chunks of cooked garlic in it, so if you are not a garlic girl I would maybe try the plainer ones. Also picked up some cannolis-- I'm not sure how frozen cannolis manage to stay so crispy and crunchy but they do. I seriously love this place, whether I'm picking up individual ingredients or grabbing lunch, it's such an amazing spot to go to.“

“Let's start at the beginning. Gorgeous restaurant. Tables aren't set up with intimacy in mind though. My husband's drink was perfect. My maple bourbon drink tasted like bourbon only. No other flavors noted. We were offered free champagne for our celebration which was a nice touch. Calamari was pretty standard though I loved the lemon aoli with it. My special of the day Sea Bass was incredible. My husband's salmon was good, perfectly cooked. This will be unpopular opinion but I thought the lobster bisque was gross. It tasted like melted cheese with a few lobster pieces thrown in. Not bisque at all. I do tend to be a bit critical since I lived in Boston once. But I couldn't eat it. Overall though fantastic restaurant. Especially seafood in a location far from any sea. Well done.“

“Great pizza, wings, and sandwiches at a great price. I've been there a dozen times and Chef John is amazing. he sponsors countless kids and organizations and I've personally seen this man not charge people for their food. Brightens my day every time I go. Kudos sir!“

“Great pizza shop! Very thin crust, good quality cheese and a local place with an extremely friendly owner. It was a tad salty for my taste, but I also tend to be a bit sensitive with that.Overall I would definitely recommend it and get a takeout pizza again!“

“One of, if not the best bourbon bar in the country.It's a museum that you can drink with some of the best bartenders in the business. The food menu is spot on. The cocktails are all superb and the knowledge of the staff tops this place off.You can go to this incredible venue to just stare at the collection... or spend a bit and actually try it.I cant even remember all the drinks I've had here... but I've never had a bad experience.This is a must go to spot if you're in the Louisville area... or a bourbon aficionado.“

“The decor inside is amazing! You can look around all night and find something new to see! We went for a friend’s graduation party and the service was still great! The food was delicious as we’ve never ate here before. It would be great for a date night or anniversary!“

“We have been to both locations and the food is consistently so good! It’s always nice to get the opportunity to select different slices as opposed to having to get a whole pie. Tonight our 2.5 year old made her pizza, as kids get to go on Tuesday’s, and she absolutely loved it. The staff was so friendly; the gentleman who seemed like he was the manager was very friendly & helpful to both customers and his young staff - which is so important. We will definitely keep enjoying pies at both locations!“

“Red Hot Chicken!? Red Hot Chicken would be better described as a mediocre, beer, pub buffalo chicken wings. Today the chicken was chewy and overcooked. Buffalo sauce would've been more mirrored to a place where they wear Tight shorts and tight shirts. Overall fabulous experience. Wonderful menu, great staff and the crabcakes are to fight for. Biggest suggestion I could make would be that the restaurant provide a lunch menu so as not to confuse the guest with items that were not able to be purchased until after 5 PM. When I return, it will definitely be after 5 PM and I'm looking forward to trying the lamb and the spaghetti.“

“First visit me and my wife went on a Thursday evening. I ordered the cheese steak and they suggested getting it on their home made flatbread. Wow! Best cheese steak I have ever had, and I am 58 years old. The flatbread was also amazing, will go back many times, awesome food.“

“Some of the best pizza I've eaten came from Coals. The ambience is as good as the food! Their prices are in line with what you get and they have a good selection of beers, cocktails, wines, and sodas. We'll definitely recommend and return to Coals. Great food!Kid-friendliness: Great place to take behaved kids.“

“We came here after my daughter's wedding for a meal with all of the guests. Sandra had a beautiful, elegant table set for us and I can't remember having a more delicious meal. We were treated like royalty by Trent, Maria and Sandra herself. I highly recommend this restaurant!!“

“We visited on Monday, January 1st, and enjoyed the amazing food, particularly the thin crust and cheese bread appetizer. The waitress was fantastic, but the highlight was when I realized I lost a sentimental item – a "little people" doll I’ve had my whole life. I let my 1-year-old play with it briefly. After realizing it was missing, I returned to the restaurant, shared its importance, and the staff went above and beyond, even searching through the trash. The doll was found and I'm truly grateful for their exceptional service, and if I could, I would give both the food and staff a 20-star rating. Thank you for everything.“

“Has a fresh and tasty pizza. The wings are just as good with great sauces. If you like bourbon they also have a broad enough selection too.Vegetarian options: It's pizza and you can have a vegetarian option or build your own. For Italian style dishes it can be hard, but there are some other vegetarian options too.Kid-friendliness: They have pizza, how is that not kid friendly. Also there's enough seating for families.Wheelchair accessibility: It's all 1 level with low bumps so wheelchairs, walkers, etc can all have access.“

“Our recent trip to Olive Garden was nothing short of fantastic, earning a well-deserved 5-star rating! From the warm atmosphere to the delectable dishes, it was a truly enjoyable Italian dining experience.The food was the star of the show:Shrimp Fettuccine: The creamy Alfredo sauce perfectly coated the al dente fettuccine, and the succulent shrimp added a delightful texture and flavor.Chicken Marsala: The chicken was tender and juicy, bathed in a rich and flavorful Marsala sauce with a touch of sweetness. The accompanying mushrooms added a delightful earthy depth.Chocolate Cake: We couldn't resist ending the meal on a sweet note, and the decadent chocolate cake did not disappoint. Moist and flavorful, it was the perfect ending to a satisfying meal.The service was equally impressive. Our server was attentive and friendly, ensuring our needs were met throughout the evening. They offered helpful recommendations and made sure our experience was enjoyable.Overall, Olive Garden provided a delightful and affordable Italian dining experience. The delicious food, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere make it a perfect choice for a casual night out with friends or family. We highly recommend giving it a try!“

“Boy oh boy! These guys have some good, good pizza. I loved it. I took one home and I was very happy I did. Apparently, they sell pizza by the slice (which is right up my alley) and I do know it's 5.00. Which is ok but do you call first? Do you just have to hit it at a good time? I asked the guy and the best i cutlass get was that it takes about 8 mins. So i don't really know but. I'm going to find out and I'll let you know. I think pizza by the slice is the best idea ever and I'm glad to know we have one in Louisville. But smile.Dietary restrictions: They'll make it however you want it. Big smile“

“We was told a 20 to 25 min. Wait there was 8 people in our party after waiting an hour we ask what the delay was and was told the the was waiting for people to leave the table they was going to seat us at. We saw lots of people come in and be seated with 5 and 6 in their party we had 2 people with diabetes with us if your told 25min. It shouldn't be over an hour wait. When we was seated Margaret was our waitress and she was amazing one of the best waitresses we had. Our food was also good.“

“Great Italian restaurant with a fun atmosphere. The food is excellent and the portion sizes are ridiculously large. The calzone is huge. I love the chicken parmesan pizza style. The bread the serve too! I always leave this place stuffed! Service staff are very attentive. Great local restaurant.“

“Really a great spot. We were there in between lunch and 5pm so it wasn't busy. The beer was cold and the appetizers were hot. Really good toasted ravioli. And the service was perfect. Worth going out of your way to eat and kick back for.“

“Place was empty, except one table who already had their food, I walked in on my lunch break, and was wondering if they were closed. For about 5 minutes. Pizza was good. But 30 minutes for 1 pizza is a long wait, could only imagine what it's like when it's full of people.“

“First time customer from Mt. Washington looking for something different. We ordered the grilled buffalo on thin crust and meatball on hand tossed by pick up. Pizza was ready upon arrival and the staff was friendly. Good pizza with the right amount of sauce so it's not messy. We will be returning for dinner on the patio.“

“I love Martini's The food and company are spectacular. I have tried. a mixture of many dishes and they all have been wonderful. The wait staff is fabulous and friendly. Jason an s Kya are incredible. They make me feel like one of the family. It is worth every penny!!!“

“I went to the Jets pizza on Hubbards Lane & they never disappoint. The food was hot & fresh. The manager was absolutely amazing & polite. I am on Hurstbourne & have a Jets right across the street from me, but I choose to go out of my way to Hubbards Lane because the one by me is a downgrade for Jets Pizza establishments. The manager & all the employees are rude, and customer service is non-existent. The manager should lead by example to make sure his staff is fully trained. If you want good, fresh food with a smile & appreciation for your business, then Hubbards Lane is the one to go to.“

“This was mine and DH first time eating at the Hurstbourne Pkwy location. The food was lovely...DH particularly enjoyed the spicy chicken soup and I was delighted with the Johnny Rocco salad. I must say however, Akani our server was the real bright spot on a sunny Saturday afternoon. ? He was warm and outgoing. He was also attentive and observant to our needs without being pushy. I personally would give Akani a huge raise and all of his favorite snacks. ?Best regardsJana Craggs ?“

“Even though I arrived late, I received GREAT SERVICE and FELT WELCOMED by my Server. (Please forgive me I am horrible at remembering names, it's the onset of Dementia). She was a delight, and did not make me feel the need to hurry. Upon leaving the Management seemed a little put out. However, they did not speak down to me. No words, just a little show in actions! And I could have been wrong! But that's fine. I just remember Years ago, when you "shopped or went out to a fine Restaurant for a nice Dinner", employees did not stand with disgusted looks on their face when it was 30 minutes before closing. Now employees act as if they are doing you a favor if they help you, or if it was closing time they were polite in saying it was time to close. Now it's "if you're not in line you will not be checked out"!!!! Usually said in a very harsh voice! Stores are not doing YOU a favor YOU are doing them a favor buying in that store". I will not tolerate that treatment, but many will. This is NOT the case of the Olive Garden. It was a nice diner and Server I will return. I'm“

“I loved eating here previous times . Tonight ( winds day 3/6/2024 I noticed something unsanitary and nasty . As I could see in the kitchen from my table there was a young guy running his fingers through his hair and cutting pizza. To me that is disgusting and hair nets need to be worn....“

“There were 16 of us from our Condo Association that went to Bearnos Middletown tonight. The address was 13829 English Villa Dr. 40245.I had a Cheese and Ham Pizza on a cauliflower crust. It was very good. It was served good and hot. It’s hard to find a pizza restaurant that makes cauliflower crust pizzas that doesn’t taste like cardboard. I shared a piece with one of my neighbors and she really liked it too and was going to try the cauliflower pizza herself the next time she’s there.My husband had “make your own lasagna” with beef, Italian sausage and extra cheese. He was able to add up to 3 items at no extra charge. It came with garlic bread. He absolutely loved it and ate every bite! It was delivered with steam rolling out. It was a big serving!!Our receipt didn’t have our server’s name, just Cashier 98. She was precious. I didn’t see anyone send anything back or complain about their order. We all told her she did a great job. She even asked if anyone needed a drink to take with them.There was another small group there but there was still enough room for all of us. We had plenty of room to enjoy ourselves and we were all able to talk and hear each other. We’ll go back again. It was close to home.Dietary restrictions: I had dietary restrictions and cauliflower pizza is one that I can eat. I had my choice of toppings.Parking: It was a small shopping center with plenty of parking spaces.“

“First time at this Bearnos and we really enjoyed the company, the music, service and the food was really good! The wall of beers and other drinks is a nice way of trying new beers and such without having to pay for a full glass of so.ething you don't care for. Great idea!“