50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middletown

“Excellent pizza with a good brew selection. I look forward to visiting again!“

“The Employee, ms. Alex is the best worker in the lower 48 states...... By far!!!! Outta this world needs a raise and a promotion!!! She makes the place my fav!! Overall awesome pizza place!!!! 5 stars!!!! & We recommend everyone go here or order delivery!!!“

“Wow--my son and his friends did a scavenger hunt for his birthday. Jet's was the lunch stop. Not only did the employees let me write a clue in the pizza box, they gave him a bonus dessert with the order. So kind, thoughtful, and special. Thank you!!Oh, and the pizza tasted great!“

“When I lived in Louisville I ate here about four times a week for lunch. I was so happy to come back and see Gary and everybody this weekend. Hands down the best pizza joint in America.“

“You won't regret it! Delish!“

“just what I needed for the lunch cravings“

“I don't really like pizza but my kids love it. I decided to try Blaze with my kids and it was Amazing. The Price isn't that bad either. I recommend it!!!

Kid-friendliness: They have a kids size pizza that your child can build. This is good for picky eaters.“

“The pizza is consistently some of the best I’ve had. Prices are very reasonable, including the 2 slices and a soft drink. Not many places offer a variety of by-the-slice quite as extensive at Old School NY Pizza. Also had the wings for the first time today - very good buffalo flavor, plenty of ranch/blue cheese and the wings were very meaty! Service is always very attentive and prompt!“

“Top 5 pizzas in the city without a doubt!“

“Excellent food! Highly recommend pizza, sandwiches and d the jalapeño crunchers are awesome!“

“This is a good place to visit great customer service thanks to Anthony outdone himself took care of everything I needed.“

“Excellent pizza with a good brew selection. I look forward to visiting again!“

“Best pizza I’ve eaten! Meatballs & mushrooms were also delicious! Friendly employees & excellent customer service! Will definitely be back!“

“My wife and I had a great experience here. We have been here several times and the service and food has been excellent! Rachel was our server and she took great care of us. She checked in on us plenty of times and was very accommodating. We will definitely go back soon. Highly recommend the craft beer selection they brew themselves too!“

“Great pizza. Great Crust. Great prices. Will be back. You gotta try it!“

“Really a great spot. We were there in between lunch and 5pm so it wasn't busy. The beer was cold and the appetizers were hot. Really good toasted ravioli. And the service was perfect. Worth going out of your way to eat and kick back for.“

“We stopped in on the 4th of July and Alex was the only server/bartender working. His attitude and service was excellent and hopefully he made a lot of money in tips. The food was warm and the beer was cold! Thanks for the exceptional service!“

“Love it! Great atmosphere, food is awesome!“

“I purchased a pizza from Sicilian (Bardstown location) about 3 months ago and have gone back every Friday since. The pizza is excellent and the owner (she) has a wonderful personality. If you haven’t been to Sicilian you need to go. I had their cannoli for the first time today; they do Sicily proud.“

“Love the Pizza and Cheesestix“

“Ordered delivery from our hotel. Both the driver and the person I spoke to on the phone were very friendly and helpful (even at 10pm and with what sounded like a very busy restaurant). The pizza was absolutely delicious!! Very hot upon arrival and tasted so fresh!! 10/10 thank you guys!!“

“We drove up from Lexington and a great experience with Parlour. The food was delicious and the staff was beyond our expectations. Can’t wait for the one in Lexington. I only wish I could remember the staffs name so I could give the waitress manager the credit they deserve.“

“Great place for pizza and cold beer!“

“? wings are great, had honey?and sweet chilli ?️ boneless tasted amazing thought they wouldn't be as good as they were, the deep dish pepperoni was great too, me and the other turtles loved it ? definitely recommend ranch and pizza dipping sauces“

“Always fast and polite service, delicious toppings, these folks put craftsmanship into these pies it shows!

Vegetarian options: Make sure your pizza has a vegan friendly sauce if that's part of your program. They offer vegan cheese opts too.“

“We came in at 7 pm. Place was packed. We had a party of 7,they gave us a room seperate from everyone else right away. There was only 1 waitress for the entire restaurant, she told us. She never skipped a beat,she was on top of drinks,food,boxes. She could have let it impact the night that she was overwhelmed but she did a great job with a great attitude. I only did a 2 for atmosphere because of cleanliness but everything else was great! And these days you don't know what you're gonna get.?“

“Best pizza in Louisville, true NY style pizza. Excellent.“

“It was all delish, but it was so cold in the restaurant. I noticed several people went out to get sweatshirts and jackets. We didn't have anything with us. It's summer time. I wouldn't usually mentioned it but it was just cold it was freezing cold. The workers were all standing by the oven ?.“

“it was pretty good food but the host tristan is weird as hell and he came up to our table, flirted with my friend, and then said time to get silly and sat down at our booth with us“

“Is great pizza and great employees“

“The pizza was great, couldn’t stop eating it.“

“My granddaughter paid for Chuckie to come out. They totally forgot this was my great granddaughter’s second birthday. I can say the management was very apologetic, but my daughter Grand Daughter paid extra and barely got to even see Chucky for the last minute because they were closing other kids came over, but Granddaughter really wanted to enjoy it with her daughter.“

“Best domino's I've had in a while!
Almost too much cheese! Id rather have too much than not enough though. It made reheating my left overs perfect!
I get build your own Alfredo with chicken, mushrooms and provolone cheese. So, sauce & cheesy. My pizza is thin crust with bacon & shrooms. The bacon was extra crispy how I like it. 10/10
*pro tip: reheating pizza in the Airfryer is A+

Vegetarian options: This location has a drive through window!“

“Always ready when promised, reliably delicious, and super quick pick up when ordering/paying online. Our new Tues tradition.

Dietary restrictions: Our daughter-in-law gets the gluten free crust and says it's quite good.“

“The food is always delicious“

“CC the bartender was wonderful! Outstanding service, friendly, inclusive and accommodating.“

“We’ve ordered Red Pepper Pizza for delivery twice and love it. Best pizza in Oldham County!“

“I am in love with their gluten-free crust. It is crispy and very close to what a regular for crust feels and tastes like. They always ask me if it is because of an allergy, and since it is, it's very important to me that they take this allergy seriously. Such a variety of toppings and styles of pizza. Service is always good!“

“the food was yummy n the staff was very nice place. can’t wait to go back“

“Friendly local eatery which supports the community!“

“My sister and I shared a wonderful evening at Cuvee last night. We overindulged on some recommended reds, and thoroughly enjoyed sharing a few small plates and the dinner special of salmon over fettuccini pasta. We were pampered by the staff and treated to a birthday dessert. We can't wait to come back.“

“The pizza was good and budget friendly but the service is kinda slow. Had to wait 20+ minutes until my pizza was ready because the name on the screen didn’t pop up until the worker there told me it’s been ready a while ago which I’ve wasted some time waiting there but at least they gave me a new fresh crazy bread to replace the old one.“

“One of my favorite places to eat! Good fresh ingredients, love that a lot of items are homemade! I cant get enough of this place!“

“Fantastic service from employees! Love BEARNO’S!!! Highly recommend“

“Absolutely love yall. My only complaint is that there isn't one closer to home. Preston Hwy has a lot of development opportunities btw lol.“

“I go to the one on Hubbard's Lane and this is the best pizza in the city.“

“I think Domino’s is a good value. We had the 14 inch pepperoni extreme and it was really good. And less than $14. Was it the best pizza I ever had? No. Was it convenient and a good value? Yes! Not sure how to rate atmosphere for pizza takeout!“

“We were really hungry when we stopped there last night. We were thinking it was just your typical Hometown Pizza but noooo. It is Hometown but on steroids. We order the cheese sticks which are some of the best we have ever had. Then we each ordered a medium pizza (waaay too much) but very good. And we will have plenty for the rest of the week.“

“If you are looking for a good New York Style pie, this is it. We make it a point to go whenever we are back in Louisville. We had a Jim Belushi, which is Pepperoni and Sausage with Peppers and Ricotta. They are open until 5am too. Definitely check them “