12 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

Legacy Pizza & Bakery Pizza • $
1001 Vincennes St Suite 100, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Calzones Are Loaded with Cheese and Up to 3 Meats Veggies
Ruby Rose Cannoli Is Only Available February to May
Brioche Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
Legacy Classic Pizza
Spaghetti Squash
Bread Pudding
Meatball Sub
Strombolis
Breadsticks
Sandwich

“Amazing food! Had the Rob Deep Dish, my fam got their own pizza and sandwiches they also loved. I asked for a substitution of bacon to replace the ham. They had a mix up and forgot to put the substitution in, which is fine -things happen. Unexpectedly, they comped me the messed up pizza and made me a whole new deep dish! Maybe I’m from an area with crappy restaurants but being left the food AND getting a replacement was a breath of fresh air! Will definitely return to eat some more delicious food“

4.7 Superb120 Reviews
8th Street Pizza Pizza • $
411 E Spring St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Onions
ETH Street Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Breadsticks
Garlic Cheese Bread
8th Street Special
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Bread Sticks
Meat Pizza
Cannoli
Calzone

“Their dough is like no other. They forgot one of my fillings for the Calzone, but the dough and cheese mixture will definitely have me come back sometime. And the inside is cute giving a nice stop in a pleasant town. The staff were quite polite and made the food within a reasonable amount of time. Wish they gave a little bit more marinara for the Calzone. Still one of the best places for a Calzone in New Albany!“

4.5 Superb85 Reviews
Parlour Pizza • $
225 State St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Triple Cheeseburger Pizza
Hot Honey Pepperoni
Big Four Meat Pizza
Ice Cream Sandwich
Tropical Habanero
Big 4 Meat Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Bombs
Hawaiian Pizza
Chicken Wangs

“Decided to try this place because it was near our hotel. I'm not much of a pizza lover but I got the Deluxe and It was so good I decided to go back a second night to try another kind. 2nd night I got the pulled pork pizza. I was hesitant because of Sriracha BBQ? But it was soooo worth it! Definitely recommend this place and to top it off the staff was wonderful!!!!“

4.3 Superb94 Reviews
Forest Music Hall Pubs • $$
41 W 1st St, New Albany

“This place was so fun and we came here on day and time that not much was not going on but yet it was still awesome I can not imagine how cool this place is when everything is open for events or what not. But my boyfriend were looking for a place with good beer and found good pizza and beer plus live music!“

4.7 Superb30 Reviews
Mimo's Pizzeria Pizza • $$
2708 Paoli Pike, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana
Eggplant Rollatini
Pepperoni Sticks
Meat Lovers Pizza
Lobster Ravioli
La Bianca Pizza
Fried Calamari
Baked Ravioli
Caprice Salad
NY Style Pizza

“The owner is awesome he will personally come out and see his customers and joke with them or wait on them if staff is running short , the food is amazing and not overpriced, memo cam out and even got a selfie with me and my wifeThis is my 3rd time there and it's been awesome each time! 5 stars all the “

4.2 Good70 Reviews
The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House Pizza • $
3312 Plaza Dr, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Garlic Bread with Beer Cheese and Garlic Butter Dripping Sauce
Order of Bread Sticks
Upside Down Pizza
Beer Flight
Carnivore
Big Ten
Chili

“We arrived at 4:30 p with plenty of seats available. We were told to sit wherever we liked. Once seated, Emily came to our table and took our beverage order. Emily came back and took our puzza order which was a Roundhouse (Burnt cheese edge) with 10 toppubgs qhich can be alternated. The puzza was fine and Emily came by table a couple times to check on us. We will probably come back. They have many local brews if you like that. There is no military discount.“

4.2 Good56 Reviews
Rich O's Public House Pizza • $$
3312 Plaza Dr, New Albany

“I brought the kids in on early Tuesday afternoon. Are server was Tabby and she was attentive and knowledgeable.Some great news for root beer lovers They brew their own and have many local beers.The place was small but clean.We enjoyed the pretzel bites and they have amazing beer cheese.We ordered a small pepperoni, which was very good. The cheese blend was so flavorful.I did enjoy the calamine as well.Be back!“

4.3 Superb33 Reviews
Pizza King Pizza • $
3825 Charlestown Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Extra Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pretzel Breadsticks
Philly Cheese Steak
Garlic Cheese Bread
Customized Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Beer Cheese
Nacho Cheese
Greek Pizza

“My first time being here in awhile and my boyfriends first time ever. We went at a busy time so we knew ahead that wait would be awhile. Pizza was ok but tasted pretty salty. The bench seats on the train side are very lumpy and need replaced. I do love how the train delivers your drinks.“

3.8 Good82 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
811 Talaina Pl, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Lava Cake

“Domino’s is one of the best and consistently done pies. No matter which location we go to, we have not had a poor experience. This location was a bonus as there was a drive thru window and with rainy weather, it was nice not having to get out. And super friendly guy at the “

3.8 Good46 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
2221 State St Suite C, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Herb Chicken Mediterranean
Pizza with Dipping Sauce

“I stopped coming here for a while due to a number of reasons. Decided to give it another try this past Tuesday and I was truly impressed. The atmosphere, service and quality was amazing. I can’t recall the woman’s name, but she was super friendly and accommodating. Although the Chic fil a traffic can be a headache at this location. I will become a regular again. Gourmet vegetarian is my fave!“

4 Good10 Reviews
Bearno's Pizza Pizza • $
3002 Charlestown Crossing, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
Domestic Draft Pints
Meat Lovers Pizza
All Meat Pizza
Fried Pickles
Lunch Pizza

“I hadn't been here for a dinner service in a couple years. I had come for the lunch buffet off and on (which is usually great especially for the value) but hadn't sit down for dinner here We got cheese sticks and the mama bearno's special. Both of these were great choices! The mama bearno's can be described as a "supreme" type pizza with a lot of toppings. Each bite had many toppings with a good taste and quality. Additionally I think I have found this place to have possibly the cheapest Guinness draft in the local area. As a Guinness lover this is especially important. Service was efficient even though they were clearly a bit short handed the night I was there.“

3.7 Good62 Reviews
Arni's New Albany Pizza • $
1208 State St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Deluxe Pizza Extra Cheese Well Done
Pizza Half BBQ&Pepperoni
Bacon and Mozzarella
Chicken Philly
Light Sausage
Hot Silcilian
Nachos With
BBQ Sausage
BBQ Sauce
BBQ Pizza

“The food was as good as could reasonably be expected for a pizza place. The salad is actually fantastic, which is a shocking change for a pizza joint.The interior is closed to the public, so you'll have to place your order in advance over the phone, or call the number taped to the window. There are a few picnic tables set up outside nearby, but it's not exactly picturesque nor private.Parking: The parking lot is rather small, only having about 15 parking spots. It would only be a light challenge to get a box truck parked in the back if parking is available. I would not attempt it with a semi and trailer.“

3.5 Good71 Reviews
Loading...
map Map