16 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Pizza Restaurants in New Albany.

Showing 16 of 20 restaurants

  • Legacy Pizza & Bakery 1001 Vincennes Street Ste 100, New Albany Pizza · $

    1 Legacy Pizza & Bakery

    4.8 Superb 264 Reviews

    1001 Vincennes Street Ste 100, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Calzones Are Loaded with Cheese and Up to 3 Meats Veggies
    • Ruby Rose Cannoli Is Only Available February to May
    • Brioche Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
    • Legacy Classic Pizza

    “I have dined in and also ordered carry out many times. This place is one of my favorite go to’s for excellent food, baked breads and desserts! Love the Strombolis, meatball sandwich, your bread pudding and cannolis are the best! The Orange Lavender bread is one of my favorites also. My friends and I tried out Legacy Pizza when they first opened and loved it. Very friendly staff and always a great dining experience. Just happy I can swing by and pick up curbside service while out shopping and in the area. The owner is always so nice! Highly recommend!”

    Menu Order
  • PARLOUR Pizza + Pints 115 West Market Street, New Albany Pizza · $

    2 PARLOUR Pizza + Pints

    4.4 Superb 331 Reviews

    115 West Market Street, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Triple Cheeseburger Pizza
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza
    • Hot Honey Pepperoni
    • Big Four Meat Pizza

    “Came in for the Bears game, they have all NFL games available. Miranda, the bartender and server was quick and efficient. The cheese sticks is like a mini pizza, very good. Also had the caprese pizza, wasn't as good as the appetizer pizza, but still good. Highly recommend!”

    Menu Order
  • The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House 3312 Plaza Drive, New Albany Pizza · $

    3 The New Albanian Brewing Company Pizzeria & Public House

    4.4 Superb 310 Reviews

    3312 Plaza Drive, New Albany

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Cheesy Garlic Bread with Beer Cheese and Garlic Butter Dripping Sauce
    • House Salad and Bread Sticks
    • Cheese Pizza on Metal Tray
    • Italian Sausage Sandwich

    “We recently ate here for the first time. Never knew this place even existed lol. The upside down pizza was absolutely fantastic. We have been back twice and plan to return again soon.”

    Menu
  • Mimo's Pizzeria 2708 Paoli Pike, New Albany Pizza · $$

    4 Mimo's Pizzeria

    4.3 Superb 243 Reviews

    2708 Paoli Pike, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • NY Style Extra Cheese Pizza
    • Complimentary Garlic Knots
    • Eggplant Parmigiana
    • Eggplant Rollatini

    “If you've been looking for pizza that tasted like it was from the heart of NYC this is the one. Best pizza I ever ate!”

    Menu Order
  • Dough Boy Pizza 411 East Spring Street ste b, New Albany Pizza · $

    5 Dough Boy Pizza

    4.8 Superb 45 Reviews

    411 East Spring Street ste b, New Albany

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Beef BBQ Sandwich
    • Garlic Butter

    “We got 2 calzones and two slices of Abruzzos cheesecake for around $50, don't let the price tag fool you! The calzones are easily shareable and that's well worth it to me. Especially considering I walked in on a mostly dead night and was greeted warmly. My food was fresh and was still wonderful after my 30 minute drive home. We will be back multiple times. Also if anyone drives by at night, the light in the shop is a little dim but they're still open!”

    Menu Order
  • Domino's Pizza 811 Talaina Place, New Albany Pizza Delivery · $$

    6 Domino's Pizza

    4.2 Good 118 Reviews

    811 Talaina Place, New Albany

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
    • Meat Lover's Pizza
    • Pepperoni Pizza
    • Chicken Wings

    “so yummyyyy i love their pizza😃😜”

    Menu Order
  • Rich O's Public House 3312 Plaza Dr, New Albany Pizza · $

    7 Rich O's Public House

    5.0 Superb 8 Reviews

    3312 Plaza Dr, New Albany

    • Take-Out

    “This place deserves more good reviews!This was a favorite family hangout spot a while ago and I’m always very excited to visit again. The waits can be long at times since they share a kitchen with the neighboring restaurant, but as long as you have good company, you’ll never notice!”

    Menu
  • Hunt Brothers Pizza 624 West Main Street, New Albany Pizza · $

    8 Hunt Brothers Pizza

    5.0 Superb 4 Reviews

    624 West Main Street, New Albany

    “love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

    Menu
  • Derby City Pizza 412 West Daisy Lane, New Albany Pizza · $

    9 Derby City Pizza

    3.9 Good 118 Reviews

    412 West Daisy Lane, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Large the Runner Up Meat Lovers
    • Large the Champ It's Loaded
    • The Champ It's Loaded Pizza
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    “We were there today, Wednesday, November 5, 2025 had a great server, Heidi! She made great recommendations and we decided to get the extra large obviously we could not eat it all and took some with us, but it was fabulous so many things included on that one! I cannot name them all we loved it! Highly recommended you give them a try and ask for a young lady server by the name of Heidi!”

    Menu Order
  • Arni's New Albany 1208 State Street, New Albany Pizza · $

    10 Arni's New Albany

    3.9 Good 297 Reviews

    1208 State Street, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Deluxe Pizza Extra Cheese Well Done
    • Big Daddy Meat Lovers Pizza
    • Pizza Half BBQ&Pepperoni
    • Bacon and Mozzarella

    “Don't get me started here. Since I was 20 years old I have loved Arnie's Pizza New Albany. I'm 60 now and just returned from a trip back East to see my granddaughter and son and immediately went to Arnie's Pizza. My granddaughter got the barbecued chicken pizza this time and let me tell you that's become my second favorite. I love everything on my pizza when I go to Arnie's but let me tell you that barbecue chicken pizza with something else!!! What a great business! Oh wait we got cheese sticks and couldn't stop eating them to get to the pizza. The best pizza place in Kentucky and Indiana. That is all”

    Menu Order
  • Pizza King 3825 Charlestown Road, New Albany Pizza · $

    11 Pizza King

    3.9 Good 353 Reviews

    3825 Charlestown Road, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Beer Cheese Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Delivery: No Curbside pickup: Yes
    • Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese
    • Pepperoni Extra Cheese Pizza
    • Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza

    “I love both Pizza King locations, but I do prefer the Jeffersonville location. It's smaller, usually less crowded since it doesn't have a train side, and the staff is very friendly. I love their pizza, it's my favorite place to eat! The only downside is the fact they are closed on Mondays.”

    Menu Order
  • Little Caesars Pizza 2868 Charlestown Road, New Albany Pizza · $

    12 Little Caesars Pizza

    3.8 Good 234 Reviews

    2868 Charlestown Road, New Albany

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Stuffed Pretzel Crust with Cheese Sauce & Pepperoni
    • Pretzel Crust with Cheese Sauce & Cheese
    • Crazy Combo Crazy Bread & Crazy Sauce
    • Crazy Combo Crazy Bread & Crazy Sauce

    “Sunday afternoon around 2pm, very friendly staff and order was ready in the pickup portal by the time I arrived. Pretzel crust with cheese sauce and pepperoni, and an order of crazy bread. 2 garlic butters and a crazy sauce (asked to swap for cheese since that's not an option in the app, girl working was very attentive and polite). Made the drive home and pizza with crazy bread was hot, fresh, and tasted great! After my first slice and breadstick, im questioning if this is the best little caesars I've ever had in my life. Im so used to ordering from either the jeffersonville or clarksville location, with not the best staff and not the best quality or tasting food compared to what I got today, how it should be! Will 100% order more often from now on.”

    Menu Order
  • Bearno's Pizza 3002 Charlestown Crossing, New Albany Pizza · $

    13 Bearno's Pizza

    3.8 Good 228 Reviews

    3002 Charlestown Crossing, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
    • Domestic Draft Pints
    • Mama Special Pizza
    • Meat Lovers Pizza

    “Tonight’s pizza was exceptional!!”

    Menu Order
  • Marco's Pizza 2011 Charlestown Road, New Albany Pizza · $

    14 Marco's Pizza

    3.6 Good 223 Reviews

    2011 Charlestown Road, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Thick Crust Sausage Pepperoni Slices
    • Pepperoni Magnifico Pizza
    • Build Your Own Pizza Bowl
    • Build Your Own Bowl

    “My girlfriend and I love this location! We drive from Louisville, not caring there could be tolls, for this pizza and customer service has been great. We’re actually getting this for our anniversary November 13th!”

    Menu Order
  • Domino's Pizza 2613 Charlestown Road, New Albany Pizza Delivery · $

    15 Domino's Pizza

    3.4 Good 228 Reviews

    2613 Charlestown Road, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Custom Medium 2-Topping 12 Pizza
    • Ultimate Deep Dish Pizza
    • Domino's Marbled Brownie
    • Stuffed Cheesy Bread

    “Pizza was delicious and fresh and hot !”

    Menu Order
  • Pizza Hut 3316 Grant Line Road, New Albany Pizza Delivery · $

    16 Pizza Hut

    3.3 Good 289 Reviews

    3316 Grant Line Road, New Albany

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta
    • Oven-Baked Cheesy Alfredo Pasta
    • Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie
    • Oven-Baked Veggie Pasta

    “Haven't had any pizza in about 3 years. Tonight my husband ordered a pizza and breadsticks for me. Delivery was right on the estimated time frame, pizza was hot, smelled and tasted delicious. Hit the spot! Thanks Pizza Hut!”

    Menu Order

Pizza Restaurants Nearby

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In New Albany

You May Also Like

All articles
  • California Pizza Kitchen Wants 1,000 Pizza Vending Machines in Three Years

    California Pizza Kitchen Wants 1,000 Pizza Vending Machines in Three Years

    A pizza from a vending machine takes 90 seconds. California Pizza Kitchen is betting on a thousand of them. The chain has partnered with retail services firm T-Roc Global to install and operate up to 1,000 automated retail machines across 30 U.S. markets over the next three years. The kiosks will go into airports, universities, hospitals, hotels and office complexes, places where a decent sit-down meal is hard to find. CPK will fill each market with a cluster of at least 20 machines before pushing further.

  • A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in Chicago

    A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in Chicago

    Pizza is a huge part of Chicago's food culture, offering a wide variety of styles beyond just the famous deep dish. Here are 10 pizzerias, where you can try this famous food in all its different types. We'll look at old pizza shops that have been around for decades and recent places trying new things with ingredients.

  • A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in New York City

    A Guide to the Best Pizzerias in New York City

    Pizza in New York is a part of the city's culture and history. Each pizzeria has its story, often reflecting the neighborhood's character and the passion of the people who run them. Here are ten of the best pizzerias in New York that you should try.

  • PizzaExpress Plans American Debut After 60 Years in Britain

    PizzaExpress Plans American Debut After 60 Years in Britain

    PizzaExpress, a popular British restaurant chain that's been dishing out what it calls "Britalian" pizza for nearly 60 years, plans to make its U.S. debut in Florida this year. The chain, which generates more than half a billion in annual revenue from its nearly 360 locations across the U.K. and Ireland, isn't just another pizza joint.

  • California Pizza Kitchen to Grow in Nevada and Utah

    California Pizza Kitchen to Grow in Nevada and Utah

    California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) has partnered with multi-unit restaurant operator Sundine LLC to expand its presence in Nevada and Utah. It's CPK's first big franchising deal in the U.S. - and it couldn't come at a better time. The casual dining chain, known for its inventive pizzas, has struggled in recent years to keep stores open.