50 Best Pizza Restaurants near St. Matthews

“We stopped in on the 4th of July and Alex was the only server/bartender working. His attitude and service was excellent and hopefully he made a lot of money in tips. The food was warm and the beer was cold! Thanks for the exceptional service!“

“I go to the one on Hubbard's Lane and this is the best pizza in the city.“

“Gigantic slices that are delicious! If I lived in Tullahoma I would eat here everyday.“

“Spinellis Pizza never disappoints! The food is consistently delicious, but what really stood out during my recent visit was the exceptional service provided by Porsha. She was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect from start to finish. Porsha went above and beyond to ensure we had a great experience. Highly recommend Spinellis if you're looking for amazing pizza and top-notch service!“

“Those looking for a pizza that tastes like it came out of Naples, this is as close as you’ll get around here.“

“When I lived in Louisville I ate here about four times a week for lunch. I was so happy to come back and see Gary and everybody this weekend. Hands down the best pizza joint in America.“

“You won't regret it! Delish!“

“The pizza is lit. Service is efficient and dude is super nice. I really wish the ranch was better and did not care for the type of cheese on the white pizza but other than that I cannot complain- I love all the other slices. The texture/chew/crunch of the crust is perfectly balanced, the flavor is spot on, and the options, value, and recipe are right on point. I stopped going to The Post when I found this place- this pizza exceeds Spinellis, The Post- better than any other NY style pizza around here. Plus, Locally owned and operated ? ❤️“

“We love Danny Mac’s!! We are there every Tuesday while our daughter has drama class. The owner’s are the nicest people & they always take great care of us! The food is hot, fresh & delicious & the breadsticks are out of this world!“

“10/18/24

We've come to eat lunch a number of times, and I have to change my review. Wicks has to be in the top pizza stops in the Ville. Service, Food, Atmosphere Wicks has it all. Pizza is Excellence, you won't be disappointed you stopped in.“

“just what I needed for the lunch cravings“

“I don't really like pizza but my kids love it. I decided to try Blaze with my kids and it was Amazing. The Price isn't that bad either. I recommend it!!!

Kid-friendliness: They have a kids size pizza that your child can build. This is good for picky eaters.“

“Love Dani!!!! The food is soooooo goooooood. Atmosphere is great.“

“Love the pizza here, every time we stop in Louisville we grab a pizza. Had a half South Pacific/Lone Wolf and a small cheese bread and some craft beers after checking out the Speed Art Museum.“

“Only my second time ordering from Parlour. I travel across the country for work. Normally I try different places but when I’m in Louisville, I know I don’t need to. The wings were perfectly cooked and seasoned, and the sauce was perfect. They’re never sitting in a puddle of sauce, and even after delivery they were still piping hot. They literally put me in a better mood ?

The pizza also is absolutely delicious. I *do* prefer my toppings on top of the cheese but that’s not a knock on Parlour at all, I didn’t think to ask. Great work, and I will continue to come back!“

“Very good Italian style pizza. They use hand tossed dough and fresh ingredients.“

“The pizza is consistently some of the best I’ve had. Prices are very reasonable, including the 2 slices and a soft drink. Not many places offer a variety of by-the-slice quite as extensive at Old School NY Pizza. Also had the wings for the first time today - very good buffalo flavor, plenty of ranch/blue cheese and the wings were very meaty! Service is always very attentive and prompt!“

“Staff was nice… good pizza in town“

“Top 5 pizzas in the city without a doubt!“

“Excellent food! Highly recommend pizza, sandwiches and d the jalapeño crunchers are awesome!“

“This is a good place to visit great customer service thanks to Anthony outdone himself took care of everything I needed.“

“Best pizza I’ve eaten! Meatballs & mushrooms were also delicious! Friendly employees & excellent customer service! Will definitely be back!“

“Excellent pizza with a good brew selection. I look forward to visiting again!“

“Excellent pizza with a good brew selection. I look forward to visiting again!“

“Such a fun place! We enjoyed drinks/beer from the self serve tap wall, while our son did racing simulations. We will have to check out the axe throwing and VR sometime soon!“

“My wife and I had a great experience here. We have been here several times and the service and food has been excellent! Rachel was our server and she took great care of us. She checked in on us plenty of times and was very accommodating. We will definitely go back soon. Highly recommend the craft beer selection they brew themselves too!“

“We had dinner there last night with some of our family for our grandson’s birthday. The food was excellent! The service was superb with all the waitresses being so friendly and exceptionally helpful to us. It was a wonderful birthday celebration and we will definitely be going back to “bar Vetti” again and highly recommend it to all our friends. Thank you for a great evening!“

“big fan of the blonde ale“

“Love it! Great atmosphere, food is awesome!“

“Great pizza. Great Crust. Great prices. Will be back. You gotta try it!“

“I'm not even a big fan of Italian food, don't care for tomato sauce that much. But after kyushu wasted 2 hours of my parties time, we went to boombozz, got seated immediately, and had great service and a delicious meal. I wish I could remember the young lady's name who waited on us, cuz she was an absolute delight. Great service, prompt and friendly. Food was hot, fresh, delicious, and cooked as it should be. I may not be a big fan of pussa and spaghetti, but im definitely gon a be goin back to this place in the future. 5/5 stars, would go again, and definitely would recommend.“

“Great food! Great service! We will definitely go back here to eat!“

“This place gets better and better. Food is great, and the seasoned staff provides friendly, professional service and are at the top of their game. The owners love the community and treat most everyone they know like family. They hire a lot of young guys and gals for their first jobs, so that might explain other critiques themed with inexperience. Overall one of the best pizza joints in this region. Consider supporting this worthwhile local small business.“

“Such a fun energy here! Our server was great! Talkative and helpful! The pizza was incredible! My only complaint is that my stomach wasn't big enough to eat more of their delicious pizza! Drinks were good. The atmosphere is really chill and cool. It's set in an old building that has been remodeled into a beautiful space.“

“I love Boombozz!! The food is delicious, no matter what you choose. They have appetizers, wings, pasta, pizza, desserts, wine and a list of beers on tap. There’s something for everyone here. Not to mention the atmosphere is great!! I highly recommend!!“

“The service was great and the food was wonderful, it was our first time eating there and planning on coming back. It would be better if you all had a handicap accessible entrance to the restaurant and handicap accessible bathrooms for guests that are handicap“

“Stopped by with friends and had an amazing experience. Pizza was delicious and the service was fast. Beautiful location with multiple sitting spaces including a patio and incredible speakeasy on the back. I was shock to found this jewel in a pizza bar. Cocktails are unique, and the vibe is amazing. Shout out to Emely for making me the best Expresó Martini, and Hunter for the recommendations, all was delicious. Staff are friendly and fun to talk to. What a great time, we will definitely be back.“

“Really a great spot. We were there in between lunch and 5pm so it wasn't busy. The beer was cold and the appetizers were hot. Really good toasted ravioli. And the service was perfect. Worth going out of your way to eat and kick back for.“

“I purchased a pizza from Sicilian (Bardstown location) about 3 months ago and have gone back every Friday since. The pizza is excellent and the owner (she) has a wonderful personality. If you haven’t been to Sicilian you need to go. I had their cannoli for the first time today; they do Sicily proud.“

“We drove up from Lexington and a great experience with Parlour. The food was delicious and the staff was beyond our expectations. Can’t wait for the one in Lexington. I only wish I could remember the staffs name so I could give the waitress manager the credit they deserve.“

“Love it! Great atmosphere, food is awesome!“

“Love the Pizza and Cheesestix“

“Ordered delivery from our hotel. Both the driver and the person I spoke to on the phone were very friendly and helpful (even at 10pm and with what sounded like a very busy restaurant). The pizza was absolutely delicious!! Very hot upon arrival and tasted so fresh!! 10/10 thank you guys!!“

“Great place for pizza and cold beer!“

“On-line seating request worked great. Until we were seated in the heated outside area. Heat was intense, table was so loose we would not be able to hold it and eat, and table was covered with some sticky substance. We would have asked to move but nobody came to the table. So we left. Sad because the food is good!“

“? wings are great, had honey?and sweet chilli ?️ boneless tasted amazing thought they wouldn't be as good as they were, the deep dish pepperoni was great too, me and the other turtles loved it ? definitely recommend ranch and pizza dipping sauces“

“It was all delish, but it was so cold in the restaurant. I noticed several people went out to get sweatshirts and jackets. We didn't have anything with us. It's summer time. I wouldn't usually mentioned it but it was just cold it was freezing cold. The workers were all standing by the oven ?.“

“it was pretty good food but the host tristan is weird as hell and he came up to our table, flirted with my friend, and then said time to get silly and sat down at our booth with us“

“Always fast and polite service, delicious toppings, these folks put craftsmanship into these pies it shows!

Vegetarian options: Make sure your pizza has a vegan friendly sauce if that's part of your program. They offer vegan cheese opts too.“

“My granddaughter paid for Chuckie to come out. They totally forgot this was my great granddaughter’s second birthday. I can say the management was very apologetic, but my daughter Grand Daughter paid extra and barely got to even see Chucky for the last minute because they were closing other kids came over, but Granddaughter really wanted to enjoy it with her daughter.“