13 Best Mexican Restaurants in Shelbyville

“Pepper’s Mexican Restaurant offers the best Mexican food in town with unmatched management and service. The restaurant provides a clean and friendly environment, making it highly recommended by many. Guests can enjoy a beautiful night on the terrace with live music while enjoying delicious meals like veggie fajitas and cheese enchiladas. The attentive staff ensures that every meal is served exactly as ordered. Despite being a bit of a drive for some, customers keep coming back for the outstanding food, great service, and welcoming atmosphere. If you're tired of the same old Mexican restaurants, Pepper’s is a must-try!“

“La Cocina de Mama is a popular spot with a warm welcome and prompt service. The restaurant offers a variety of dishes, including the Molcajete Azteca, which is served exactly as depicted on the menu. The menu features a range of options, including chimichangas, which are smothered and grilled to perfection. The chips are fresh and warm, and the salsa is not overly spicy. Sides include rice and beans, as well as guacamole. Parking is available on Main Street or in the back lot.“

“Taqueria El Taco Feliz is a Mexican food truck located in Kapaa, known for its fresh and delicious food. The tortillas are made from scratch daily by the owner's mother, adding a unique touch to the dishes. The fish tacos and Carne asada are popular choices, but the al pastor and carnitas are recommended for those looking to try something new. The chimichanga is generously portioned, served with fresh toppings and tender meat. Prices are decent for the island, although it may be a bit steep for some. The food truck is easy to miss, as it is located off the main road and parking can be challenging to find. The server is friendly, and the menu is displayed on the side of the truck for easy viewing. However, they do not serve horchata, which may disappoint some customers. Despite the lack of horchata and parking, the food is generally well-received, leaving customers with full and happy bellies. The atmosphere is described as welcoming, and the food is consistently fresh and flavorful.“

“Chamoy Ricos Latin Cafe offers a delicious menu featuring good Mexican street corn and nachos, although the strawberry dessert option, with frozen strawberries that taste burnt, could be improved. The staff is friendly and provides excellent customer service, making it a great spot to bring the family.“

“Marimba Mexican Restaurant offers a great menu with large portions and reasonable prices. The margaritas are superb, and dishes like the queso with chorizo are delicious. The restaurant has a wide variety of vegetarian options and can accommodate dietary restrictions. The outside patio is a great spot to enjoy live music on certain days. With excellent food and service, Marimba's is a highly recommended spot for a meal.“

“Mi Casita Shelbyville is a Mexican restaurant known for its decent food. The enchiladas are tasty, with a good portion size of rice and beans. The quesabirria is a must-try, according to one customer who found it to be their favorite dish. The staff is kind and helpful, although the prices are a bit high. The restaurant is located in a large strip mall with ample parking, though it can be challenging on Sunday mornings due to a nearby church. Suggestions for improvement include updating the restroom facilities to be more modern and convenient for customers.“

“La Fogata offers a welcoming atmosphere, with a recent remodel making the space look great. The restaurant is family-friendly, with a kid-friendly atmosphere and a variety of options, including gorditas, soup dishes, and lemonade. They also offer authentic Mexican cuisine, including tacos and empanadas, with top-notch service.“

“Tacos Ebenezer is a beloved food truck that serves delicious tacos and other Mexican specialties to the local community. The hardworking staff strive to provide a homely and welcoming atmosphere, with customers praising the tasty food, including the popular green salsa and corn cups. This truck is a favorite for both casual dates and a regular Friday night spot.“

“La Poblanita Taqueria serves delicious Mexican dishes at an affordable price. Their menu items, such as chicken quesadillas, steak burritos, and soft tacos, are made with fresh ingredients. The restaurant is clean, and the service is generally helpful and polite. While some dishes may have minor issues, such as dry meat, the flavors are wonderful. The tacos are a highlight, rivaling those of other Latin restaurants in town. Try the wet burrito, and be prepared for a filling meal at a great value.“

“El Molcajete rdz offers an authentic Mexican dining experience in Kentucky. The menu features both recognizable and unique Mexican dishes, with standout options like the rotisserie chicken. Despite some language barriers, the friendly staff provides attentive service and ensures a comfortable, home-like atmosphere for an affordable price.“

“Now under the name.. "Mi Cabanita".. most highly recommended! Wonderfully fresh food.. lots of unique Mexican cuisine items such as Sincronizadas, Pambazos, Campechano and Lomo tacos... also very flavorful and fresh homemade salsas of all heat levels..“

“Fiesta Mexicana serves top-notch food with generous portions worth the money. Highly recommended are the frozen Peach Margaritas and Quasadilla DeLight, as well as the authentic soup with pork. The staff is friendly, although they can get busy. The restaurant offers a welcoming ambiance, fresh hot chips, and excellent salsa. It's a great spot to stop by, with quick seating and food service.“

“El Nopal Taylorsville Rd is a Mexican restaurant that has received mixed reviews. While some customers have praised the amazing food, fresh ingredients, and friendly staff, others have noted a decline in the quality of the food over the years. The restaurant was previously dog-friendly, but that is no longer an option. Overall, the reviews suggest a comfortable atmosphere and attentive service, though the consistency of the food quality may be a concern for some diners.“