50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Taylor Mill

“We really like the new patio area.“

“Unfortunate situation with their delivery driver tonight so my order took twice as long. The management staff took care of my bill. My order arrived late but hot and perfect. The driver was extremely courteous as well. Best delivery pizza in NKY. 🙌“

“Mouthwatering and delicious. Drove 20 minutes just to try this place. We will definitely be back. They only have two small tables outside so plan for take out! Best pizza I’ve had in Cincinnati.“

“Nice quaint pizza spot. Good food“

“Dan the man with the pizza pan, was awesome in every aspect of professionalism. Fucking great attitude and very friendly. Thanks Dan front the guy who painted the building on the corner.“

“Amazing pizza!!!!! The Chicago style pizza is hands down the best! Garlic knots were good too and garlic butter and marinara automatically comes with it. a must try and you'll keep going back!“

“I have been meaning to stop by since they opened, finally had a chance tonight. Casual atmosphere of a neighborhood place. Warm greeting upon arrival. You order at the counter and the food is brought to your table. I had garlic knots and a small pizza and both were delicious. The pizza was a 10” pie the size of a paper plate. The toppings were fresh and evenly spread over the pie which was perfectly cooked. The crust was the perfect consistency. The pizza really did taste like a traditional pizza I use to have when I was young and we lived next door to a family from Italy. It’s a can’t miss experience, and I will definitely dine here again.“

“The pizza is always really good! The employees are always welcoming and friendly. I love this place. I eat here at-least once a week!“

“Not a lot of seating but the food was good especially the goetta sandwich the kids meals are nice and plenty of food has a small town feel. Food is quality. I guess my only complaint is the pizza could have been hotter. But I wouldn't call it cold and I would definitely eat there again.“

“It is a good place to get 🍕!“

“My husband and I stopped in today for lunch after seeing it recommended on Google. The fresh focaccia with olive oil and balsamic were hands down the best I’ve ever had. My husband enjoyed his wedge salad and we split a highly delicious pepperoni pizza. Mike and Maddie were so welcoming! We even got to enjoy their brand new outdoor umbrellas which gave such a nice touch to their outdoor dining patio. We will definitely be back sooner rather than later! 🥰“

“Fantastic pizza! Fresh, hot and delicious!“

“By Far….this is the best pizza I have had in along time. Been ordering from them for a few months now. Never been disappointed. Customer service was incredible when a mistake occurred with our order! Wonderful customer service.“

“I was responsible for placing a rather large corporate order with specialty pizzas, dietary restrictions and extra requests. Alicia (unsure of the spelling) was working the morning shift on 2/26 and absolutely rocked. She handled the order for me while handling the walk in orders, made sure everything was perfectly cooked and cut, and it seemed like she was training another employee at the same time (all three folks working on the order were great but only caught her name!). Next time I’m in charge of the group lunch order, I know where I’m going.“

“First time here tonight and the service was amazing and quick we were worried coming in about 7:50 since they closed at 9 and we didn’t feel rushed at all.. Food was absolutely delicious we ordered a pizza and hoagie with some cheese sticks, and that dessert especially the peanut butter pie was absolutely amazing I ask the girl at the register who makes it and Nicole idk if you will see this but you know what your doing with that peanut butter pie, it was absolutely the most delicious peanut butter pie I ever had.. it took a lot of self control to not buy every last piece that was left..“

“Visiting and happened into this restaurant. Exceptional pizza. The sauce is spicy, the cheese gooey and the pepperoni divine. I ordered a personal pizza expecting to have the second half for lunch the following da, nope I devoured the entire thing. The friend I am traveling with agreed we will be having dinner there again tomorrow.“

“We drive from Lexington, Ky every few months just to eat at Newport Pizza Company. Everything is made fresh. Meatballs are great and the hoagies are delicious. Also their Cincinatus pizza puts a whole new spin on my favorite chili. Visit them, you won’t be disappointed.“

“When we showed up with 70 people they were amazing! Service was great, workers were hustling, kitchen staff got all of our food out in a timely manner.“

“Very good quaint place Pizza was really good“

“This was my first time at the gruff and it was absolutely amazing. The food was great. The service was amazing as well, and we got to sit outside and enjoy the weather! Most definitely will be going back.“

“I get there pizza once every payday. closest thing to my pizza here in ky.. not to mention the guy that works there is fantastic. I went in to order today an was like 3 dollars short cause my card wasn't working right. but cause I'm in there a lot and my daughter was hungry they made it for me with what I had. not a lot of places do this especially for some great food..“

“Most authentic New York pizza we’ve found. SO good!“

“Very good food and friendly staff. Was glad to have wandered into this place.“

“We love being able to order a half & half of each of our personal favs😊❤️“

“Best customer service and food.“

“Definitely one of the best Pizzas I've had in Cincy so far, We got the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and it was extremely fresh. You get a great view of 13th and Vine that is excellent for people watching. The Crust was crisp and the dough was herbed which is something you don't see often. Would definitely recommend checking this one out!“

“Fantastic atmosphere, employees. Appetizers were great, Pizza was fantastic. Definitely give this place a try! If we weren't from 5 hours away this would be our go to spot...“

“Mitch is amazingly fun to chat with and made my day with his smile and such great personality. Fresh and hot pizza and all around great!!!!!“

“The guy who gave us our order was fantastic. We ordered the chicken pizza, it was ok, good but not fantastic, what was excellent was the salad we ordered with figs. Outstanding. We ate in our hotel, so maybe if then pizza had been fresh it would have been better, and that's on us. After a long day of traveling, we were too tired to dine in.“

“Delivery - terrible (door dash)
Food - margarita pizza overcooked; pepperoni pizza sporadic meat; veggie on cauliflower crust the best of all but soggy
Some of this is due to delivery imo
Not worth the $75
Eat there; don’t get delivery“

“Came to Taglio’s for my girlfriend and I’s first Presidents’ Day together and had their vegan (veggies) pizza with pumfuroni added. It was so good! And then we couldn’t help but try the chocolate sorbet (dairy free). She said she would only try 20% but it was too tempting to resist! Definitely recommend Updated from previous review on 2026-02-16“

“Amazing food. Wonderful views. The ambiance and service was 10/10. 💜💜💜“

“Had Lucy Blue last night for our Friday Happy Hour. So delicious. Especially love the Lucy Blue tomato sauce!“

“Fantastic pizza! Fresh, hot and delicious!“

“As I’m writing this review I’m still in shock! I’m in Cincinnati on business and I was craving Italian. I can’t believe there’s not a line around the block just for the meatballs! My family owned an Italian seafood restaurant in NJ for 26 years and I can say without hesitation the meatballs here are the best west of Arthur Ave in the Bronx! My NJ mind is blown!“

“Pizza is great and people that work there are so nice. My kids love this place.“

“We ate here for the first time last night , it was packed but we were seated right away and they moved us over to be closer to heat with no issues whatsoever; our server Emily was super sweet and the hostess as well !!! We can’t wait to come back, our food was delicious and great servings … Emily was very attentive and was great with recommendations .. hubby is a cook and can be a little picky haha 🤣 but he LOVED everything he even wanted to tip whoever made the Mac and cheese anywho 10 stars ⭐️“

“Great Manager at the Independence location. Super friendly Ben made us new comers very welcome“

“Some of THE BEST pizza I’ve ever had.“

“My son out of nowhere asked if we could get Sun Valley. I haven't had Sun Valley in maybe 2 or 3 years. Not for any negative reason, but it used to be on my way home and isn't anymore. I had also heard that the prices went sky high. I got a medium pizza and it was basically the same amount that I would pay for Larosa's, but it was way better. I asked for extra pepperoni and asked if they could put it on top of the cheese, which they said no problem at all. I also asked for it well done which they cooked it perfectly. Crisp pepperoni, crispy crust. It was awesome! And again, I don't think the price was too bad at all. They are back in the rotation! Next time we're getting Hoagies!!!
Lastly, there was a guy and a girl both working who were really nice. I really appreciate it. Highly recommend.
(Edited for grammar)“

“This is by far the best pizza and hoagies that I have ever eaten. The food is always hot and fresh and the employees are so friendly and welcoming. The mushroom hoagie is out of this world!! I highly recommend Snappys in Independence Kentucky.“

“Ordered a Steak hogy, lg pepperoni pizza and cheesy garlic bread. It was all hot and wonderful. The guys working behind the counter cooking was so nice and friendly , the restaurant was clean and well lit. Would recommend to anyone wanting great Pizza experience, wonderful service.“

“Fantastic joint. Not pretending to be something it isn’t, just a good old fashioned Biergarten with top notch food and a great selection of beers and other alcohol. Live music was not overpowering, and was appropriate to the crowd. Definitely heading back on my next trip to Cincinnati.“

“Always Great. Service, Quality, & Value. My scale is the only one who wishes I wouldn't eat so much & go so often.“

“I ordered from Door Dash first time ever. My door dasher picked my $50 order up and then canceled the order and “fed his family”. Door dash refunded me but the owner is having to fight for a refund, he will get it but my first experience with door dash will be my last. They were not very apologetic and didn’t seem to be surprised at this behavior from a driver. I called the store and wanted them to make the order again and said I’ll pay for it as I will get a refund. The manager was so kind and took care of us. I insisted on paying again for the full order and he would not accept full payment and only wanted a partial payment. The kindness of the store goes beyond what they had to do since currently they are shorted out of the food and it’s not payed for. I will be back for their delicious crispy crust pizza and my daughter had her first hoagie and loved it! Thanks NYPD!!! Thanks for making right what you didn’t have to do for Door Dash. Door Dash do better and make sure that driver is fired.“

“Thus deserved a review. I've been here for almost a year on a travel assignment and everytime, I have yet to have the wrong order. Being from Wisconsin we have Rocky's and this is as close as it gets to home especially their pizza dipping sauce. They have cheese sauce! and it's different, but in a good way. I can't explain it. Lately their cookies seemed over baked to me so I decided to call and see if theh can cut the time down just a tad bit. And they absolutely delivered! Which is why I'm writing this. Honestly, I should've written a review a long time ago but I usually smash their pizza and by that time, I'm fully, tired and satisfied hahaha and completely forget. To the woman on the phone, Catherine? Cassandra? Whomever worked the night of 12/5/25 at 815pm she deserves a raise! Great customer service. Patient and most importantly everything was on point. Fast delivery too! Thank you girl and to the rest of the team all the way down to the delivery folks. Thank you. I wish I could take you and the whole store to Madison, WI with me as my time here comes to an end. Wishful thinking.“

“Not only does the Queensgate store have the best food.. the staff is so amazing! Antone is my favorite, he knows me by name and I like that! #GreatPeople“

“Great pizza! Everytime we're in town we order from the one on Sutton. Never disappointed. Very friendly and accommodating.“

“I’m a regular at the Delhi Pike LaRosa’s and they always kill it. The food is consistently great exactly what I expect every time and the team makes the experience smooth and friendly. Appreciate the reliability and care. Keep up the great work!“

“Very good pizza, pasta, salad & deserts!! Price is a fairly good value, $9.99 for the buffet for adults, $10.99 if you want a drink. The buffet was kept stocked & fresh, service was very friendly & welcoming, there is some games to play, sort of like Chuckee Cheese's games or Mr. Gatti's, however there are no prizes or toys to win or exchange tickets for. Bathrooms & restaurant was very clean & well kept. Highly recommend this place!!

Kid-friendliness: Yes it is kid friendly“