13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Winchester

“If you’re anywhere near Main Street and haven’t tried Maka Mia on Main, you are missing out BIG time! 🙌🍕 From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with friendly service and that mouthwatering smell of fresh dough and melted cheese. Everything tastes homemade and made with love. The crust is perfectly baked — crispy on the outside, soft and fluffy on the inside — and the toppings are generous and fresh. What do I recommend? Honestly… ALL of it. But if I had to narrow it down: 🍕 Their specialty pizzas – Loaded with flavor and perfectly balanced. You also have to try their Philly steak hoagie 🤤🔥 It’s the kind of place you go once and immediately start planning your next visit. Great for family night, date night, or grabbing a quick slice that tastes anything but ordinary. Maka Mia on Main is officially one of my favorites — 10/10 recommend every single time! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“The folks were friendly but I think it was a little over priced and the pizza was a tad over cooked, I would eat from there again with a few extra comments on time in the oven.
I have recommended several friends to try them out also !“

“Excellent food and atmosphere! very nice staff! highly recommend!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Tonight are around 6:45/7:00 PM, I had the most pleasant experience in your drive-thru after a horrible day full of mean people. The lady working the window was a breath of fresh air. She was not only very helpful and polite but her kindness truly ended my day on a positive note. The world needs more people like her. ☺️“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“This pizza is incredible. Cannot believe that I got it from a gas station“

“Delicious, fresh, and wonderful customer service. They will fix any pizza you want if you ask for it. Very clean and priced reasonably.“

“Excellent pizza at Winchester Ky location. We ordered the royal feast and I asked that the crust be cooked well, so they put the order in for well done and it was perfection! In the past the center of the crust wasn’t done how we like it, so I asked for them to be sure the crust was well cooked and they did! Very pleased (I called the location and let them know).“

“This was the best pizza my fiancé and I have ever had. I’ve never been to this location before, I live over 2 hours away, and was just passing through on our way home after visiting the national park. It’s literally the best pizza we have ever had, when I’m in the area again we are for sure stopping by to eat ❤️?“

“I don’t know how long my pizza sat outside for, since the delivery driver didn’t ring the door bell like I had asked. The pizza was warm at best. That being said, I will still order since they have the best pizza in town.“

“Pizza tasted fine, was made a little sloppy and must've gotten a big bubble while in the oven. You could definitely see where the bubble had been. Which made the looks of pizza not so visibly appeasing. Also had to wait for the pizza to get done for about 45mins for a pickup. I live 20mins from store and still had to wait another 25-30mins at the store.“