Black-Eyed Susan's
$$ • New American, American Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Black-Eyed Susan's
Customers' Favorites
Sourdough French Toast
Scrambled Curried Eggs
Buttermilk Pancakes
Blueberry Pancakes
Corned Beef Hash
Black-Eyed Susan's Reviews
363 ratings
Share your opinion about Black-Eyed Susan's
a stand-out of rustic humility in a sea of nantucket preppy. just two chefs helming the kitchen stage but everything moved seamlessly and calmly throughout a restaurant that felt more like a living room in a cosy home. our souls were exhausted from a day of big blings & gravitas but the flowered napkins & warm hosts soothed us into relaxing along with the gentle laughter of other happy diners.
a simple salad & one of the best clam pastas i’ve ever had brought us back...read full review
a simple salad & one of the best clam pastas i’ve ever had brought us back...read full review
A little bit of a wait but food was good.
Dinner here is scheduled turns so try to show up a couple mins early otherwise you’re in a gigantic queue for food. They do their best to keep things moving and it works well for them.
But holy cow is it loud in here. You’re inches from your neighbor (close enough to hear them better than your dining partner) but the whole place is so loud you’re probably lip reading anyway. Just be prepared for the setup or maybe go on the earlier side for a more peaceful...read full review
But holy cow is it loud in here. You’re inches from your neighbor (close enough to hear them better than your dining partner) but the whole place is so loud you’re probably lip reading anyway. Just be prepared for the setup or maybe go on the earlier side for a more peaceful...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 12:30PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 12:30PM |
| Wednesday | 5:30 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 5:30 - 9PM 7AM - 12:30PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 12:30PM 5:30 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 12:30PM 5 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 12:30PM |
Black-Eyed Susan's is a charming island institution on Nantucket, known for its good food and reasonably priced menu. The restaurant offers amiable service and a cozy ambiance, making it a perfect spot for special occasions. The menu features a range of dishes, including the asparagus appetizer, beet salad, trout, linguine with clams, shrimp and grits, tuna tartare, and decadent chocolate mousse dessert with macadamia nut cookies. The food is superb and consistently fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared, with a thoughtful menu that never disappoints. Guests have enjoyed breakfast at Black-Eyed Susan's, praising dishes like corned beef hash, which is tender and unique, and huevos rancheros with a great sauce. The staff are warm, attentive, and truly accommodating, making every visit feel special. While some minor issues with service and pricing were noted, overall, Black-Eyed Susan's provides an excellent dining experience with a focus on quality and hospitality. A true gem that feels like home while offering innovative fare.