Company of the Cauldron
$$$$ • American, French Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Company of the Cauldron
Customers' Favorites
Fried Chicken & Belgium Waffles
Beef Wellington
Caesar Salad
Company of the Cauldron Reviews
103 ratings
Share your opinion about Company of the Cauldron
I just had the best 70th birthday dinner here! Chef Joseph created a delicious menu and paired wines. The Company Popovers accompanied a crisp Caesar salad,
Wagyu beef and a lobster tail with smashed potatoes & broccolini was the entree, rounded out with “The Marriage of Crème Brûlée + Chocolate Mousse” and Dows Fine Sherry Port. The service was spectacular (thank you Johnny) and the intimate and cozy atmosphere made for a wonderful experience for my party of 10. I...read full review
Wagyu beef and a lobster tail with smashed potatoes & broccolini was the entree, rounded out with “The Marriage of Crème Brûlée + Chocolate Mousse” and Dows Fine Sherry Port. The service was spectacular (thank you Johnny) and the intimate and cozy atmosphere made for a wonderful experience for my party of 10. I...read full review
Absolutely phenomenal experience and dining, cannot recommend any restaurant higher. Vegetarian option was also amazing.
We dined at Company of the Cauldron during our trip to Nantucket in July and unfortunately left disappointed. The dinner was a set menu, but the overall experience didn’t meet our expectations.The meal began with popovers which was their staple bread, followed by a Cobb salad that was underwhelming. It had very little dressing and only a small amount of bacon, making it feel dry and lacking in flavor. The main course was steak, it was tasty but quite chewy and difficult to enjoy....read full review
Hours
| Monday | Open 24 hours |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 10:30PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 10:30PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 10:30PM |
Company of the Cauldron offers a perfect evening with attentive and friendly service, making it a great choice for special occasions. The restaurant is known for its delicious food, including the Beef Wellington, and has received praise for the impeccable lobster, which is perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. The expertly suggested wine pairings enhance the memorable dining experience. Guests have highlighted the warm, intimate ambiance and charming atmosphere, further enhanced by the music.
The kitchen is well-orchestrated, and the chefs have earned recognition for superbly prepared meals. The staff is incredibly kind and attentive, with the sommelier being friendly and knowledgeable. Many have enjoyed the personal touch when the chef comes out to greet customers. However, some diners have raised concerns about timing, with courses sometimes arriving later than expected, leading to increased wine consumption during the waits. While the service is attentive, the noise level can be high, making conversation challenging. Despite these issues, Company of the Cauldron remains a beloved choice for many, shining brightly among dining options on the island. It may be on the pricier side, but guests feel the quality of the food, service, and atmosphere makes it worth every penny.