24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Plymouth

“Pricey, but what isn’t these days? Food was good and view is beautiful. Service was also good but waiter seemed oddly unfamiliar with standard polite expressions such as “thank you” and “you’re welcome.”“

“Delish!! We got split Chicken Pahm and the Meat-Up. This joint won't disappoint. Stop what you're doing right now and order some Edge Pizza!!“

“This is the best wood fired pizza I have ever had!! But overall, this is a great place and the service and ambiance were excellent also, and it is obvious they are using high quality ingredients for there delicious pizzas!!! Even though I live in NY, I am definitely coming back this summer!!!“

“Great food nevr left hungry been going almost 40 years!“

“Always excellent quality love their food thank you“

“Home cooking at it’s best! The fish was so fresh . Had the haddock two days straight! Was so good had to go back and get it again! Fish and salad the first night and then the “to die for” Angelica’s Brazilian sauce with the shrimp over the crispy haddock and salad with real blue cheese dressing! Was really amazing! Her Brazilian Mama is actually cooking in the kitchen! ❤️💯“

“Awesome food“

“Great bunch of folks working there, all the food is really good. I just got their Chicken Gyro for lunch 2 days in row, it was totally awesome!!“

“Wish I hadn’t waited so long to try the best pizza!! We bought two orders this week and both pizzas were incredible!!! The margarita is our favorite so far! This will definitely be our go to place from here on in!!!“

“I am in Florida but ordered a pizza to be delivered to my Mom in rehab in Plymouth. Pizza came really fast. Mom said it was excellent! Thank you so much! Driver even texted me to tell me it was at the front desk! Above and beyond in my opinion“

“they're horrible at taking orders , in the past 5 months not sure if new owner new cooks, or just the lack of training but the food it trash ! I used to love this place but either they mess up on the pizza it's cardboard box nasty flat and the subs are so filled with meat ( turkey) it's falling out the sides breaking the whole roll itself barely any lettuce or pickles! last time I got a turkey sub the bread was hard as a rock and it had barley any turkey meat , what is going on with this place !?! they're rude when you order and it's a pickup waste of my gas for sure and money I won't be ordering again this place went room 5 star to zero lost a great customer get your crap together honestly why are you packing rhe sub with one much meat for it to just fall out that's such a lack of effort horrible service and they don't ever take accountability EVER!!“

“Stevie’s uses high quality, fresh ingredients, and the difference can definitely be tasted! Their pizza toppings are portioned generously and everything is cooked just right! I’ve been told by someone who works there that the kitchen is always kept exceptionally clean! The people who take orders on the phone and the drivers are very friendly and courteous. Five star + IMO!“

“Let’s be clear, we’re talking about pizza in a gas station. But this isn't some sad microwaved Mama Celeste offering that’s been reheated in a toaster oven. These guys make real pizza in real ovens. They specialize in sizeable pies, 19 inches in circumference. But most of their business consists of generously-proportioned quarter slices priced between $5 and $7 dollars. Decent pizza by the slice is tough to find in the suburbs and Sal’s deserves to be on your list the next time you're hankering for pizza but don't want to spring for a while pie.“

“fantastic...chicken broccoli ziti is out of this world. you're missing out if you don't hit up this hidden gem.“

“Wow, let me tell you about my experience at the Plymouth Public House. This place is so amazing, so cozy, but yet you’ll have the time of your life like you’re in Miami. Not only is the restaurant and food good (compliments to the chef), but there is a bar tender there, I think her name was Tara, who made the best drinks AND made me so welcomed/ had me dying laughing at everything she said. I’ll be moving to Plymouth just for this restaurant. God Bless the Public House“

“great good, good people just eat here !!!“

“This restaurant is the best and consistent. I got a pizza and a roast beef wrap. All was great!“

“rotten lettuce....lasagna over cooked. chicken picatti microwaved.....i could pull out day old leftovers from a dumpster better than this“

“Our book club met at the Blackraspberry last night. First time at the restaurant for most of us. Excellent service (server was very patient with us - chatty book club) and the food was honestly fantastic. My hot-honey salmon bowl was so good, I will go back soon for it again! Atmosphere is fun and comfortable. Will definately make it a frequent place to go!“

“they're horrible at taking orders , in the past 5 months not sure if new owner new cooks, or just the lack of training but the food it trash ! I used to love this place but either they mess up on the pizza it's cardboard box nasty flat and the subs are so filled with meat ( turkey) it's falling out the sides breaking the whole roll itself barely any lettuce or pickles! last time I got a turkey sub the bread was hard as a rock and it had barley any turkey meat , what is going on with this place !?! they're rude when you order and it's a pickup waste of my gas for sure and money I won't be ordering again this place went room 5 star to zero lost a great customer get your crap together honestly why are you packing rhe sub with one much meat for it to just fall out that's such a lack of effort horrible service and they don't ever take accountability EVER!!“

“Had a private function after a funeral and they were amazing to deal with. Made sure we had everything we needed and the food was amazing. great job!“

“Never visited this Papa Gino’s before. Have to say it was the best ever experience I’ve had at papa Gino’s ever. Pizza was delicious perfectly cooked, friendly staff , dining area very clean. Will go out of my way to go there again.

Dietary restrictions: Can’t drink sugary or diet soda but was very pleased to be able to have a bubbly seltzer with my meal

Parking: Plenty of free parking.“

“We love going to the Pine hills mama mia's, staff is friendly and food and atmosphere are always great.“

“Hands down the best Italian restaurant and pizza, family owned for 50 years! Love it“