17 Best American Restaurants near Sheffield

“Pleasant outdoor dining! You bus your own table“

“Food and service were outstanding!“

“Beautiful cozy atmosphere in the dining room. The host (owner?) was very friendly and made us feel right at home. One of our kids broke a glass and he made jokes while cleaning it up. It's clear that this place is a passion project. The food was delicious. Overall it's a pretty fancy place. We paid just under $200 plus tip for a family of five.“

“Omg. Fried shrimp chili you need nothing more don’t misunderstand. I’ve had the other food. It’s amazing. Would highly recommend who knows might even see you there one day.“

“I had put on a Premiere at The colonial theater where I had lots of guest from all over coming to visit and wanted a venue close by to host an after party and right across the street is Industry Kitchen & Bar . The Event would be wrapping up around 9pm and I knew this might be late knowing that Industry typically didn’t have their kitchen open that late but after reaching out They were more than happy to accommodate myself and the 30+ guest. Food was amazing, drinks were amazing, and it made for a great end to an already amazing event. Big shout out to their server Gabby who held it down phenomenally for myself and guest. Hope to be able to do this again with Industry Kitchen & Bar in the future thank you so much!“

“On our way home from drone daughter off at camp we stopped in. I got the brisket and rib combo. My wife got the burger. We got a pretzel and Mediterranean snack. It was all delicious. Friendly staff and nice atmosphere. I will go again.“

“Chef David makes the most incredible meals…BBQ,duck, steak😋seafood, oysters and clams…. and much much more! Pretty bar keep Cindi can whip you up almost anything... The long time favorites are superb and she has beers and seltzers that won't quit LOL👍👍👍“

“This place was amazing!! It was "date night". We were both very satisfied with the place, our food and our interactions with employees. We started with the fried potato pancakes, Delicious!! He had the chicken and waffles and I had the Cali BLT w/ onion rings. The portions are great and the prices are right!! I definitely recommend checking them out.“

“Charming place with tasty food!“

“My son and daughter in law got married n June is 2025. Everything was absolutely fabulous! If you’re looking for a farm setting for your wedding I highly recommend Gedney Farm! The restaurant is also amazing. Great atmosphere and delicious food!“

“Great accommodations, comfortable and well located in the hamlet of Hillsdale. I would definitely stay there again. There were some stairs to our rooms though, so that might be a little tough if you have mobility problems, though they also seemed to have nice ground level cabins.“

“Truly loved it! Beautiful restaurant with a cute rustic cozy feel and great atmosphere. As someone who eats out a lot, I wasn't sure what to expect but the food was excellent. From the Signature, Caprese Salad, the delicious brick oven pizza, the Rack of Lamb for my husband all through to dessert, everything was extremely flavorful and delicious. The hot food came out hot, a pet peeve of mine is when it comes out luke warm from sitting to be served. Here everything was perfectly temperature. And can we talk about the cocktails? LOVED the Neo’s Negroni. 5 stars from me fully recommend this amazing restaurant won’t be disappointed!“

“There were 17 of us for dinner! The food was absolutely delicious! Our waitress was Linda, she couldn't have been nicer or more attentive if she tried! She took care of us very, very well! Anything we needed, she was right on it pretty much before we even knew we needed it. I'd ask for her any time we eat here and we will certainly be back! Again, thank you Linda it really was our pleasure having you take care of us! The Klondike Crew.“

“Workers always friendly and attentive!! Great business!!“

“Really incredible dinner here. The mushroom soup was something I’ll be thinking about for a long time. Really enjoyed the arancini and the salmon was cooked phenomenally. Walked in on a Friday night at 7 and were able to grab a perfect spot at the bar right away. Bartenders were attentive and the food hit the spot. All the staff were very friendly and welcoming and we had a dinner to remember. Als great back bar.“

“Enjoyed the food and atmosphere“

“They somehow managed to combine the friendliness of a local pub with the food of a fine restaurant. Highly recommend this gem. Havent tried the pizza place nectdoor but the wood fired oven makes pizza that looks delicious. I am a beer drinker but the cocktails look great! No, its not cheap but qhat is these days?“