50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sherborn

“The Ownership has changed hands over the years and is not a huge place but the current ownership does an outstanding job with their crust and they use quality ingredients on their Pizza. We drive the extra 10 minutes to this location and to date they have not failed up in providing a delicious pizza. We will continue to order from them.“

“Even though we no longer live in Natick, we still get our pizza, subs, chicken tenders and fries from here every time we are in the area. We love it and so do our kids. Highly recommend!!!“

“Stopped by on our way from Norfolk Ice Arena, and the pizza was the best I've had in long while.

Hot, cheesy, with the smell to die for.
The server (not sure if he was the owner) was nice and helpful.

Will be back.“

“Very happy with the food! Been there a few times. It was hot and tasty! Owner greeted me and was very personal. I will be back and recommend trying.“

“AMAZING FOOD! And great staff!“

“Medway famous is the absolute best pizza house here in Medway for classic, family owned, quality pizza and food! There are not enough words to express how lovely the woman at the counter and her husband are! They are so accommodating, and sweet. We order pizza in larger quantities at a time for our shop. and they always have it ready right on time!. They take the best care of us and their food is fresh and good quality!!! They go out of their way to ensure everything you ask them for is there in the order. Extra sauces, napkins, drinks It is always spot on! They never disappoint. The pizza, pasta, subs are delicious! We, the Sullivan Tire crew, love Medway Famous and are so grateful they're practically our neighbor so we can enjoy the food often. Thank you for doing an outstanding job, consistently, and for being so accommodating! Mostly, thank you for making every experience a very pleasant one! Check them out, you will not be disappointed!“

“Simply a great place for great food!“

“Fantastic pizza!! The crust is crispy and tender like it should be. Cooked perfectly. The other non-pizza items are ALL great as well. Nice little bar area too serving great drinks.“

“First time trying Palace Pizza. Ordered 2 pizzas. At pickup, he handed me 3. He said he didn’t like how one came out, so he gave us the extra at no cost. That’s never happened in my 54 years. The one pizza he wasn’t happy with had a couple bubbles but still tasted excellent.“

“Scott gave us fantastic service! He appeared to be the only server this afternoon but you would never know it—he was so quick and attentive. He put us at a quiet table as requested, then got our order right in, refills on drinks, rolls, and then automatically got us a second pizza to take home as he said the first one didn’t come out the way he wanted it to.. we were so lucky to have him today—thank you Scott for giving us such a wonderful dining experience!!“

“Yesterday was the first time we tried the pizza at Pizzeria Enzina...Wow... and we are so glad we did. My husband and son ordered a calmelized onion and red pepper version and I tried the vegan veggie pizza. We were thrilled at how delicious each slice was and we loved everything, from the taste of the dough to the generous amount of toppings and how incredible the vegan cheese on mine tasted so amazing...yes my husband and son both swiped slices of mine... it was that good. So happy we found you Enzina....my new favorite ....can't wait to try other dishes and the canoli too!!! We are so grateful for such a wonderful meal!!“

“They are Amazing!!! Food is always great!!! Customer service is always great!!! The owner went out of his way today for us. Thanks so much.“

“The staff and service are always exceptional when I stop here. It is easy to see that the service plaza is falling apart and filthy but Papa Gino’s is always very clean and ready to help the very few people who come through that plaza. I commend the staff on their attention to detail and their efforts to help guests like myself“

“Stopped in due to convenient location by our hotel. It's decent pizza, but nothing special. Subs were above average and service was quick and easy. Place is clean and order took less than 15 minutes to prepare so it's pretty fast if you're in the area, but nothing worthy of going out of your way for.“

“I grew up in Detroit off of Buddy’s Pizza. This pizza IS BUDDYs pizza. Legit! Well done!“

“Great owners and food. They aim to please“

“The aptly-named 'Weston' pizza is hands-down the best pizza in the Weston/Wellesley area. A thin crust white pizza with organic baby spinach, sliced cherry tomatoes, caramelized onions, prosciutto and a drizzle of honey...you won't be diappointed!“

“The pizza was great! The kids asked to come back the next time we’re in the area. They were impressed with the size of each slice! - Franchesca - Rochester, NY“

“Always went PaPa Ginos it was very good until I went to Sudbury PaPa Ginos. I am there most Saturdays, but the pizza the best, never changes. The young lady that makes them is Niran always the same, she deserves a very big applause because to make it the same takes commitment.“

“Our go-to pizza place now! Pineapple pizza with bacon and peppers. Oooh! 🥳 Am I missing something on the app that lets me reorder my last order with one click? I have to go through building the pizza each time. Keep it up guys‼️“

“Last night me and my brother ordered an extra large eggplant pizza, and an order of bruschetta. That pizza hit on every single note. The thickness,freshness, and flavor of the eggplant was legitimately 11/10. The bruschetta tasted so fresh and perfectly drizzled. We were so impressed we are going to order again today (something different) and see if it was just a fluke or very possibly the best pizza joint this side of Boston. Also the people that work there were all friendly and seemed happy to let me pick it up like 10 minutes before they closed. Wildly impressed.“

“Amazing pizza, perfect crust, and friendly service! My top choice for a pizza night.“

“Way to go! Incredible Detroit Style Pizza for dinner tonight. Delicious and very different anything else in town. Great job!“

“they have been a staple in my family for over 40 years ...“

“Awesome food, gracious quantities, good service & great Adult Beverages in a fun, friendly bar!“

“My son and I stopped here after his game. We only came chose this one, as it looked empty and tge plan was to get going as quickly as possible. Did we make the right decision. This was the beat pizza we had since moving ro MA 4 years ago. The crust was thin and crispy. The sauce was just sweet enough, and the cheese was perfect!
Our only issue, us that this is 25 mins from our house. We will now have to drive 5 towns away to get the best pizza in MA. But is it worth it? YES!!!“

“The pizza is amazing!! Besides that I took my 79 yr old father and you can stay and eat. It’s handicap accessible. Bubba’s pizza is out of this world and his staff is so friendly and courteous. I recommend this place to kids and adults of all ages!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Best food in Town.. i am a loyal customer !! i love the roast beef and the pizza ❤️❤️ customer service excellent🎉“

“Been going to place for a very long, since Polaroid days my absolute Are their Calzones. more specifically is the Italian Calzone, I can eat it all day.“

“I have been coming to the Hearth for many years...the staff is friendly, the atmosphere relaxing and comforting, and the food and beverages are from local sources, well prepared, tasty and satisfying. The owners and management have also shown a dedication to supporting the arts by encouraging local musicians to play at the restaurant. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Really great food, really nice employees and super fast. Highly recommended, I go here about once a week on my lunch break :)“

“Love this place. Long time customer. Everyone on the menu is great! Recommend this place to all.

One thing I'd like to request. Please add your grape leaves to sides or make a grape leaf dinner. Your grape leaves remind me of my childhood. Stuffed with meat and rice with authentic lemon sauce. Love your grape leafs. I order the Greek salad just because it comes with a grape leaf.

Thank you for great food!“

“The best gluten free pizza ever! The crust was light and fluffy not thin and cardboard tasting. We will be back.😊🍕🇺🇲👍“

“West Newton is tried and true. Its consistent. It’s everything you want for a sub shop. You’re not going there for some yuppie gourmet entree you’re going there for a solid sub and a Greek salad with chicken for your girlfriend. This place is steadfast. You’re getting what you asked for and it’s quality is dead on. We order from this place multiple times a week from work and there’s literally never an issue. 10/10 suggest west Newton pizza“

“Love LOVE THE FOOD Service was amazing also ❣️⭐🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I would suggest it for anyone have a lot of good food to choose from ❣️“

“Nice place. Good food. Keep it up!“

“This is the best pizza place in all of New England, every item we’ve tried from here has been amazing, and the owner is the nicest guy I have ever met. Never a wait, and food is always top quality. 10000% recommend supporting this family business🍕“

“We hosted a baby shower today at Conrad’s Restaurant,
In Needham, and it was absolutely perfect from start to finish. The staff went above and beyond to make the day special, welcoming our guests with genuine kindness and ensuring every detail was taken care of. The food was exceptional, fresh, beautifully presented, and loved by everyone. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, making it the ideal setting for such an amazing celebration.
A heartfelt thank you to Conrad’s for helping us create such a memorable event. Your team made the day truly unforgettable, and we’re so grateful for the care and attention you put into everything. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Thank you! Baby Opper.“

“excellent food, great customer service. they treat customers like family“

“Great food,good pizza and great service 👍🏿“

“Called ona whim bc we were passing heading into t eh city for a concert (all last minute) Asked for slices - they don’t do at night and we weee 6-7 mins away. Gentleman said plain or pepperoni and I got you covered! Wish I had more cash would have left a bigger tip! Thank you Westin Theo! Pizza was delicious and perfect! We will visits you again on our ride into the city for concerts - but we will order ahead!“

“I deliver to Peter's Pizza and I thought I would share my experiences first of all great people The guys that work there Will and the owner awesome people. every time I go there before I leave they insist on feeding me which is awesome because it's usually lunch time by the time I get there laugh out loud. all around good people great pizza and it's a pleasure to deliver there.“

“Got a eggplant sub and it was out of this world good!!!! The bread was so delicious which really makes a huge difference in the taste. The eggplant was cooked perfectly perfect sliced and crispness! The sauce and cheese was good not over powering. Could use the cheese spread out some more would be my only suggestion. Would definitely go back and order the same and then try something different too!“

“We absolutely love this place!! Best pizza in town and awesome sandwiches! People here are great!“

“Went in for a XL pizza at like 8 PM on a Friday night. They were absolutely slammed but even then I only had to wait 10-20 for my order that I had ordered in advance. That’s what happens on Friday nights! XL roni was fantastic. Solid food here.“

“We had an issue with Grub Hub, and ended up having the restaurant cancel the order (ordered large but they only had the small dough at the time, which I didn’t think would feed the family, they were very obliging in canceling) we ordered from Papa Gino’s which was more money, and honestly not great, my son (ASD and ARFID) didn’t like it and refused to eat because it was cold. Rocco’s then delivered a large caramelized onion, and gave it to us for free (we owe you a double tip next time, my husband forgot in the confusion). My son immediately dove in eating the onions off the piece and the rest of the piece of pizza. You have made a customer out of us. Not only because of the excellent customer service but the food was very good and reasonably priced. Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes as well, due to the reviews.“

“From the moment we decided to have Pizza Market West Newton cater our Christmas party, we knew we made the right choice. This local, family-run business went above and beyond to ensure our event was nothing short of spectacular. The quality and taste of their food were incredible, leaving all our guests raving about the delicious pizzas and the variety of options available. Their attention to detail, prompt service, and warm hospitality added a personal touch that made our celebration even more special. It's not just the mouth-watering food that makes Pizza Market stand out; it's the passion and care they put into every order. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and are grateful to have such a gem in West Newton. Highly recommend to anyone looking to make their event memorable with fantastic food and service!“

“Don’t walk, RUN here! Me, my hubby, and some friends had our first visit last night! I’m gluten sensitive and was THRILLED to have homemade Gf bread and chicken parm with gnocchi!! It was AMAZING!! All gluten sensitive and no issues today! #davinciforthewin 🙌🏻

In addition to great food, staff was awesome! 😎 Melissa the bartender was SOO nice and made amazing drinks! Chef Peppino, the owner, was so welcoming and friendly!! Can’t wait to go back!!“

“I’ve never been disappointed ..“

“Supreme is under new ownership and the new team is a delight! Just got a call from one of their staff members ensuring he got my order exactly right and the food was delicious, would recommend!“